Crunchy Con

World's stupidest newspaper decision

Monday May 7, 2007


I work in a declining industry -- newspaper journalism -- that makes some stupid decisions. But I can't think of any that tops this: the Minneapolis Star-Tribune has ended James Lileks' column, and assigned him to write straight news stories. Lileks gives us the scoop on his blog. Lileks is one of the liveliest and most compulsively readable voices in American journalism. Most American newspapers are hard to read because they're so flavorless and masticated down into bland mush. We need more Lilekses -- that is, more distinct, intelligent, witty voices. More journalists who can write, for pity's sake.

What on earth could the Strib be thinking? Are they thinking? Why do you put your star prose stylist, the only writer for your newspaper that any non-journalist outside of Minneapolis has ever heard of, into the chorus? Is this one of those Maoist things, where they send the glasses-wearing intellectuals out of the cities and into the fields with a hoe to teach them a lesson?

UPDATE: Here's Dave Barry on the Strib's call:

"This is like the Miami Heat deciding to relieve Dwyane Wade of his basketball-playing obligations so he can keep stats. Sometimes I don't understand the newspaper business. What's left of it."


Lileks fans -- and I know you are legion -- let's have a contest to find the best possible simile to characterize the Strib's decision. Here's a start: Like cancelling "The Simpsons" to revive "Joanie Loves Chachi".

Comments

Sure, was Barabbas going to die for your sins? And The Simpsons is the only good thing to come out of Fox in years!

Like picking Crunchy Con over God's Politics.

OOHH OOHH! Like taking Ernie Broglio for Lou Brock! Cubs fans should know that one.

Excuse me,but I've never heard of James Lileks. I can name several other columnists for the Strib [off the top of my head-- Al Sicherman, Jeremy Iggers, Dan Barrerio, Patrick Reusse, Sid Hartman, C.J., Doug Grow, and Colin Covert], but not him. And I live in Arkansas. :) k.

You're excused,teacherkd. In Indiana, we've never heard of those people you mentioned,but we sure know and love our Lileks!
I think the long knives are out for him because he has not cheerfully accepted his cup of Kool-Aid and continues to represent moderate and reasonable political thought.
It's like refusing a filet mignon in favor of cabbage rolls for dinner.

Read All Comments

Post a Comment

Are you aware of our Rules of Conduct?


(won't be made public)



Ad tag

Advertisement

Search

About Crunchy Con

Rod Dreher is an editorial columnist for the Dallas Morning News, and author of "Crunchy Cons" (Crown Forum), a nonfiction book about conservatives, most of them religious, whose faith and political convictions sometimes put them at odds with mainstream conservatives. The views expressed in this blog are his own.

feed icon Subscribe

RSS Feed

Receive updates from Crunchy Con
Enter your email address below.