Attorney General Eric Holder says he is disturbed about news reports that attack surveillance methods used by the New York City police department in the Muslim community to prevent terrorist attacks. Holder now says the Justice Department is reviewing the situation, which really means the DOJ is considering an investigation.

Why smear New York Police Commissioner Ray Kelly and his team? There’s no need for an investigation here. The NYPD is doing what good investigators do – follow leads and track down those individuals who are dangerous and want to destroy America. This is not called discrimination. It’s called good police work.

As I told FOX news today, Kelly has done a fantastic job and should be applauded, not criticized.

The fact is the NYPD has a tremendous track record of success – preventing 14 terrorist attacks since 9-11. The NYPD is utilizing constitutional surveillance methods – gathering public information, attending open meetings, examining online websites – all reasonable, all legal.

There’s opposition to this effort from some – including members of the Muslim community and the ACLU. In defending his program, Commissioner Kelly correctly notes that “a broad base of knowledge is critically important to our ability to investigate terrorism.” In another interview, Kelly went even further: “Criticism comes with the territory. But it just won’t deter us from doing everything within the law to stop terrorists from killing more New Yorkers.”

The fact is there’s nothing wrong with police focusing on areas where terrorists live, hide, and plot. This opinion editorial in today’s Wall Street Journal puts the issue into the proper perspective:

“Criminals often share ethnic backgrounds. For police to look for certain criminals among certain ethnic groups is only logical, and it doesn’t suggest a belief that all, or even a significant minority, of that group are criminals. Cops look for Cosa Nostra members in Italian communities, for Yakuza criminals among Japanese, for Triad criminals among Chinese. To look for al Qaeda members in Muslim communities is not to disparage such communities. Indeed many Muslims help law enforcement identify such potential threats.”

Commissioner Kelly and the NYPD deserve our thanks and support, not criticism and attacks.

We will have more about this issue on Monday.

Jay Sekulow


More from Beliefnet and our partners
previous posts

Last Friday’s standing-room only hearing before the Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission was among the most dramatic I’ve witnessed.  There was outrage – outrage not just from me as I declared the State Department “AWOL” in our quest to free an American Pastor, Saeed Abedini — a U.S. citizen — captured by Iran’s Revolutionary Guard […]

One of the most important things we can do is keep the story of Pastor Saeed Abedini in the spotlight. This U.S. citizen is facing eight years in a deadly Iranian prison, convicted for his Christian faith. We know that the situation he faces gets worse day by day. He remains cut-off from speaking with […]

It’s unlike any judicial system in the world. On Monday, American Pastor Saeed Abedini went to court in Iran with his attorney to address charges of attempting to undermine the Iranian government. The real problem: he converted from Islam to Christianity 13 years ago and started working with house-churches in Iran. Pastor Saeed and his […]

An American Pastor is being held in Iran’s most notorious prison – Pastor Saeed, a U.S. citizen, has been told that he “will hang” because of his Christian faith. And, now the Iranian government has put this case on the fast track – and scheduled a trial that’s just days away. After sustaining painful beatings […]