I started City of Brass in March 2002 at Blogspot, and moved to Beliefnet in August 2008. Over a thousand posts and a million page views later, it is time to end this chapter and start a new one. However, I am not technically going anywhere – Beliefnet recently acquired Patheos, where I am going […]
The health care summit at the White House has begun – here’s the live video feed from Whitehouse.gov:
mcjoan at dkos had a preview of the summit earlier which takes a pretty pessimistic view of expectations. But I like what I’m hearimng from Sen. Lamar (R-TN) so far, about wanting Obama to succeed. This is rhetoric that the GOP leadership hasn’t been using until now.
Still, the insistence on a “blank sheet of paper” is simply equivalent to doing nothing. If that’s the line we keep hearing during the summit, then this is indeed pointless.
UPDATE: here’s the simple truth of why the GOP call for “a blank paper” is just “kill the bill” in disguise, succinctly from Ezra Klein:
Think about what’s entailed in restarting the process. The Senate Finance Committee and the Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committee would have to build new bills. The House Energy and Commerce Committee, Education and Labor Committee, and Ways and Means Committee would need to write new legislation. All of those proposals would need to be merged. There would need to be discussions in committees, and then weeks and weeks on the floor. Then there would need to be conference. Then they’d have to come back to the floor.
There’s no time for that. Congress has a few, final months before everyone scurries home to campaign for 2010. And they want to spend those months forcing Republicans to take difficult votes on jobs legislation, not arguing over whether Medicaid is solvent enough for a major expansion.
More importantly, there’s no political upside in starting over. The right will still cry “death panels!” and let loose the dogs of tea, and the left will savage them for failing to pass health-care reform despite controlling the second-largest congressional majority since the 70s. There’s a policy argument here in that a fallback plan will cover more people than no plan will cover, but if covering people is what the Democrats want to do, they’ll pass the comprehensive plan, which both covers more people and actually gives them a major accomplishment.
At this point, health-care reform either passes or it dies. Democrats are all in on this one. They know it, Republicans know it, and maybe more importantly, they know the Republicans know it. Letting health-care reform fail is indistinguishable from conceding the 2010 election. There’s no real fallback plan. If Democrats fall back, they fall.