I started City of Brass in March 2002 at Blogspot, and moved to Beliefnet in August 2008. Over a thousand posts and a million page views later, it is time to end this chapter and start a new one. However, I am not technically going anywhere – Beliefnet recently acquired Patheos, where I am going […]
Color me unsurprised – the plight of the Uyghurs hasn’t received much attention from the muslim world:
A leading Uighur rights activist has criticised Muslim-majority countries for not speaking out against decades of alleged repression and persecution from the Chinese government.
Speaking in Washington on Monday, Rebiya Kadeer, a businesswoman who was jailed for years in China before being released into exile in the US, hit out at what she said was decades of “brutal suppression” of Muslims in China’s western Xinjiang region.
Speaking after a day of unrest in Xinjiang left at least 150 people dead, Kadeer pointed to the lack of response from Muslim countries to the violence and the situation faced by the Uighurs.
“Muslim countries such as Pakistan, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Syria and a number of other Muslim countries as well as the central Asian states like Kazakhstan Kurdistan and Uzbekistan – they all deported Uighurs who had fled Chinese persecution for peacefully opposing Chinese rule, for writing something, for speaking something,” she said.
Kadeer’s opinion on why the Ummah isn’t interested is interesting, too:
Kadeer attributed the lack of action from Muslim countries to what she said was the success of Chinese “propaganda” to the Muslim world.
“So far the Islamic world is silent about the Uighurs’ suffering because the Chinese authorities have been very successful in its propaganda to the Muslim world.”
That propaganda, she said, sent a message to the Muslim world “that the Uighurs are extremely pro-west Muslims – that they are modern Muslims, not genuine Muslims.”
At the same time, she said, to Western countries the Chinese government “labelled Uighur leaders as Muslims terrorists with links to al-Qaeda – so the propaganda has been pretty effective on both sides.”
She certainly reads the Western terrorist-paranoia attitude correctly, but her analysis for the muslim nations’ apathy relies on a false dichotomy between “modern” muslims and “genuine” muslims. It’s actually kind of insulting, and more of a Western stereotype than an Eastern one.
I’ve always been skeptical of the (political) concept of Ummah, considering it to be more of a romantic idealization than anything that has any material impact or benefit to muslims worldwide. The fact that most of the muslim nations in the world are still struggling with modernity, reform, post-colonialism, and autocracy suggests that the reservoir of energy for pan-Islamic causes is pretty much absent, with the exception of Israel and Palestine. That is a unique case, representing a projection of all the colonial resentment into a single focus, and tainted with the European export of anti-Semitism. Other than that, is there pretty much any issue on which muslims worldwide can be roused to actually care?
That said, what attention can be expected? If Saudi Arabia were to lecture China on human rights, the result would be farce. This is in some ways akin to the griping that Obama wasn’t doing enough to “support” the Iranian protestors. Is there any real action that muslim states can take on an official basis that would not be a purely symbolic and rhetorical gesture?
Kadeer further complains that Uyghurs who fled Chinese persecution are deported from muslim countries, but is fleeing to Egypt really any better? Of course Uyghurs are persecuted in China, just as Baha’i are persecuted in Iran and Shi’a in Saudi Arabia. I don’t see Shi’a fleeing Arabia for Xinjiang, either. While America remains a haven of religious freedom for its muslim citizens, it’s also clear from the treatment of the Uyghur detainees from Guantanamo that there are no welcoming arms here for foreign muslim refugees, either.
In addition to calling for support from the muslim world, Kadeer also demands rhetoric from the United States:
“We hope the White House will issue a stronger statement urging the Chinese government to show restraint, and also to tell the truth of the nature of the events and what happened, and to tell the Chinese government to redress Uighur grievances.”
If only it were that easy! Such rhetoric would assuredly have zero impact on the Chinese government’s policy, of course. Further, it would also make things worse by giving China the excuse to trot out the “interfering with our sovereignity” argument and thus change the subject from scrutiny of Chinese domestic human rights to scrutiny of American foreign policy.
Ultimately the problem of freedom of religion and preservation of culture in an autocratic society is one that each muslim community will have to figure out on its own. There’s no Ummah to save them.
(via Thabet at Talk Islam)