Idol Chatter

Idol Chatter


TV’s Medical Dramas Go Jewish

posted by esther kustanowitz

Single Jewish women (and their mothers) are supposed to experience a Pavlovian drool reaction to the presence of doctors, but I never went thusly gaga, not even for television doctors. And while I do admit that Clooney was cute, this whole “Grey’s Anatomy” McDreamy nonsense over the admittedly adorable Patrick Dempsey wasn’t a reason for me to watch. I already had “ER,” so my triage rooms were all occupied. And what kind of hospital in a major city doesn’t seem to have any Jewish doctors, anyway?

But friends I trusted loved “Grey’s Anatomy”–so I gave it a whirl. The format–young doctors dodging barbs from demanding residents and struggling to make it in a hospital–was familiar from other television shows, but the characters are innovative enough to keem me coming back, with each episode peeling back a layer of complexity for the residents of Seattle Grace.

In last night’s episode, the first of Season 3, Izzy–devastated by the death of her heart-transplant patient turned love-of-her-life Denny–lay prostrate on the floor of her bathroom as her friends stood outside and debated who should attempt the impossible task of consoling her. Meredith was making sandwiches, because it’s what you do when people die. “You mean like shiva,” asks Christina Yang (Sandra Oh).

What? Yang reveals that her family is Jewish, so they sit shiva.

“Tell me about shiva,” says Izzy from her prone position on the bathroom floor, engaging in conversation for the first time since her fiancee/patient passed away. “It’s supposed to help with your grieving,” said Yang, explaining that they sat shiva for her grandmother for seven days, offering a detailed–and accurate–description of the traditions of this seven-day Jewish mourning period.

This marks my first awareness that Yang is Jewish, and I wonder what kind of impact that added layer will have on her character’s story arcs over the course of the upcoming season.

An hour and a channel flip later, I’m watching “ER,” where Estelle Harris (who will forever be known to many as “George Costanza’s mother”) shows up as the mother of the burly reception manager Jerry Markovic (Abraham Benrubi, who’s been with the show on and off since 1994) and starts talking at him with “oy veys” and calling him “sheyneh punim” (beautiful face). So suddenly, another Jewish character is outed on a medical drama–this time by his loud, abrasive cliche of a Yiddishism-spitting Jewish mother.

I found myself again wishing for TiVo, so I could rewatch those scenes for intimations of future plotlines, how Jewish tradition might impact story and character development. But most often, a Jewish television character is just Jewish culturally, making the perfunctory remark about how he or she observes Hanukkah, not Christmas, right before joining in the caroling chorus. And unless there’s a Jewish patient, or until Hanukkah rolls round again, we forget that the distinction was even made.

On “ER,” it’s unlikely that Jerry’s religion will become a storyline, but on “Grey’s,” it has a chance–the show never misses an opportunity to raise the stakes for each character, adding layers of complexity and nuance in characters as distinct from one another as they are interdependent and complementary.



  • Marth

    Actually Yang did bring up she was Jewish last season and the only reason I know is because I had just finished watching the second season on DVD. The fact that she was Jewish came up when she was getting together with Dr. Burke and they were just starting to live together and it was near Christmas, and he had a Christmas tree out and wanted to decorate it with her after work and she blurted out she was raised Jewish by her stepfather who was Jewish. And that nite she came home the tree was decorated and the Hanuka candles were in the window next to the tree. Just a FYI>

  • http://myurbankvetch.com Esther Kustanowitz

    Thanks, Marth. Someday, Netflix will bring me Season 2, and then I’ll be all caught up. But you see what I mean about Jewish characters being defined by “not celebrating Christmas.” Looking forward to discovering more about these fascinating characters, in any event…>

  • sandy lerman

    Another FYI but this not a medical show, The Young and the Restless (a daily soap opera)have implemented Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur into the show. How cool is that? Guess we will have to wait and see what they do for Hannukah. I love it. I also love the Yiddishisim on TV reminds me of my upbringing. La Shana Tovah>

  • http://www.ginekologijosklinika.lt/ Ginekologijos Klinika

    So what? I think it’s not so important ;)

  • http://ggoogglle Google

    Estelle Harris really suits for this :D

  • http://www.twitter.com/bustuva Bustuva

    Hey guys! It’s some kind of magic? isn’t it?

  • http://www.bookcar24.com Jim

    This one is really great show. I enjoyed every season

  • http://quoteaboutlove.com/ Quote about love

    Hmmm interesting…

  • http://quoteaboutlove.com/ Quote about love

    Hmmmm i don’t know…

  • http://www.kaunoreklama.lt/spaustuve/ofsetine-spauda/reklaminiai-lankstinukai lankstinukai

    Jews is historical Lithuanian problem… But medical dramas are great. Especialy “Grey’s Anatomy”. Thanks for great article

Previous Posts

"God"
      Catch Veggietales on Netflix November 26th - Click here to go to the next page for the next word in your special message and for an exclusive downloadable surprise at the end! IN THE HOUSE is VeggieTales for a new generation, available exclusively via the streami

posted 10:40:29am Nov. 26, 2014 | read full post »

Review: ‘VeggieTales: In the House’ Teaches Children Valuable Life Lessons, Fun for All Ages
If you’re looking for a show that teaches your child valuable life lessons with a relevant faith connection, “VeggieTales: In the House” is it! I had the pleasure of watching a full episode from the revamped Christian-animated series and had fun the whole way through. I joined Bob the Tomat

posted 2:53:08pm Nov. 24, 2014 | read full post »

The Epic Story of the Early Church Continues
With much anticipation after the smash hit, The Bible, now you can get a glimpse of another epic story--A.D. A snapshot can be viewed of this new series during the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade on NBC. It will be a first look from executive producers Mark Burnett and Roma Downey that will pr

posted 10:58:57am Nov. 24, 2014 | read full post »

The Official Trailer for Disney’s ‘Cinderella’ Is Out, And It’s Magical
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=20DF6U1HcGQ[/youtube] Have courage and be kind. Get ready! Disney has released its first official trailer for the fairy-tale classic ‘Cinderella,’ and it will blow you away. Contrary to the first teaser that simply focused on the glass slippers, this tr

posted 4:10:12pm Nov. 20, 2014 | read full post »

A Sobering Look at Cyberbullying
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kMLJLFfwJV4[/youtube] With headlines blaring about cyberbullying, "Nowhere Safe" is a sobering look at what could go wrong is this “Family Approved” movie by The Dove Foundation. Two teen girls Mel and Alana launch a massive cyber attack on Ashley (Daniel

posted 3:41:32pm Nov. 20, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.