'Board' with Potter
What do Pagans and other Beliefnet members think about Potter?
BY: Paul O'Donnell
This weekend, whether you believe in the Harry Potter's magic or not, you're bound to run up against the fictional preteen's all-consuming power. Televisions, billboards, even your local fast-food joint are already teeming with Potter come-ons. By Saturday, reporters will be accosting blinking Potter fans outside movie theaters to record their judgments. Monday we count the box-office.
This is all the standard hype. Peculiar to Harry, however, is the smattering of stories about Christian fears about Potter and Paganism. "I will not allow my daughter to see this film because I feel it has pagan teachings,"writes theblessed7
(See post #275). But rarely are we told how Wiccans and other Pagans feel about being identified with the staff at Hogwarts.
A tour of the Harry Potter discussions-on which Earth-Based believers are well-represented-shows that Pagans mostly disavow Harry, pointing out, asSilverWinterMoon writes
(post #14) "the magic portrayed in Harry Potter...has very little to do with real Witchcraft." Beliefnet membersypress puts it more technically
: "The ethics are non-Wiccan: no three-fold law, and certainly no Wiccan Rede! (I love the books, but cringe every time the professors use an animal to demonstrate a nasty spell.)"
Not all Pagans take the guilt-by-association so sedately. "I don't know which is stupider and more offensive,"writes Mirror Eyes
, "the idea that Wicca is ANYTHING like fantasy, make-believe magic in those books, or the idea that my religion is something that children need to be protected against." If Christians fear the specter of Satanism, say others, they should look to their own religion, not Paganism. "Wiccans don't believe in Satan. Satan is strictly a Christian boogyman," writesanniecat
The Pagans' sensitivity is perhaps understandable, given the amount of Christian
- Three nations make surprising appeal for church’s help
- Are Christians held to an unfair higher standard?
- Are Young Blacks Turning Conservative, Latinos Evangelical, Jews Secular?
- Billy Graham: I Know Where I’m Going
- Are All These Christians' Complaints of Religious Discrimination Just So Much Empty Whining?