First, he has successfully pursued his political ambitions while remaining faithful to the tenets of Jewish tradition. This demonstrates more powerfully than any rabbinical sermon could that the oft-repeated characterizations of halakah [Jewish law] as somehow at odds with contemporary life are rooted in ignorance of both the halakic process and the reality of observant Jewish life.
We are not privy to Senator Lieberman's sources of halakic counsel or to the full extent to which his personal life measures up to the standards of halakah, nor should we have the interest or right to be. Each of us, after all, has more than enough to occupy us in seeing to his or her own spiritual growth.
But one thing is certain--for decades, Joe Lieberman has earnestly striven to incorporate halakah into the warp and woof of his fast-paced, high-profile life, both privately and publicly.
By the same token, for all that Senator Lieberman has endeavored to live a public life informed by halakic teachings, he has had many occasions--on a weekly, even daily, basis, in fact--to draw a line at certain conduct that says to others, and more important, to himself, "This far and no further."
From his high school days, when he was voted king of the senior prom but chose to stay home and observe Shabbat, to his first run for the United States Senate, when he passed up participating in his own nominating convention because it was held on a Saturday, and continuing with his steadfast commitment to halakah as he has ascended through the political establishment, Lieberman has consistently exalted principle over so-called pragmatism.
In so doing, the senator embodies a powerful rejoinder to the mistaken, indeed ahistorical, notion that, as a former dean of the Conservative movement's rabbinical school put it, "In classical rabbinic Judaism generally we have never taken 'the Torah says so clearly' as a final, decisive and unchallengeable argument."
Joe Lieberman, like countless generations of his and all Jews' ancestors before him, most certainly does take the Torah's unequivocal dictates as the baseline for life decisions.
Commenting on the teenager's decision, his coach wrote: "So Tamir gave the [university] its scholarship back. They told him that Shabbos was a problem. He told them Shabbos was a blessing. They told him if he didn't play it would affect his 'career.' He told them if he did play it would affect his 'life.' They drew a line in the sand. He planted his feet firmly and told them who he was and what he believed in."
One further aspect of Senator Lieberman's fascinating life story merits the attention of the Jewish community and of political strategists as well. By his own account, the senator's religious commitment has not hurt, and has possibly even aided, his career aspirations.
In a public address before a Jewish group some years ago, Lieberman recalled his first senatorial campaign in 1988. After the media reported that he was absent from his own Saturday-scheduled nominating convention, he kept meeting non-Jews throughout Connecticut who would say to him, "I respect you for putting something above political success." Often, they would add: "[T]he fact that you put something ahead of your political success, more than any particular position that you took on an issue in the campaign, is why I'm going to vote for you." Senator Lieberman concluded by noting that "we only won by 10,000 votes that year, that was less than 1% . . . . [A]nd who's to say whether it wasn't the fact that I didn't go to my convention on Shabbos that gave me the margin of victory? . . ."
This episode is representative of something that observant Jews in many different walks of life have experienced firsthand. By adhering to principle, rather than making accommodations born of discomfort with our beliefs and visibility, Jews often engender a profound respect from non-Jews who find such principled positions refreshing amidst the prevailing "everyone has their price" mentality. And that Lieberman position, no less than his positions on matters political, is one Jews would do well to ponder.