Reports came last month that the Japanese bishops were going to the Vatican with concerns about the Neocatechumenal Way.
Today, in The Tablet, Robert Mickens reports that the Neocatechumenal seminary in Japan is to be closed:

A NEO-CATECHUMENATE seminary in Japan is to close after the country’s bishops convinced Vatican officials that the movement was causing divisions in the Church by its way of thinking and in its attitude towards Japanese culture. Four senior Japanese bishops, including the president and vice president of the national episcopal conference, met for nearly an hour on 25 April with Pope Benedict XVI, according to a recent Union of Catholic Asian News report. It was the third time in five months that they were in Rome to express serious concerns over the presence of the Neo-Catechumenal Way in their country.

The movement, founded in Spain in 1964, has spread to 105 countries and operates a missionary seminary in the small Diocese of Takamatsu some 320 miles south-west of Tokyo.
Francis Xavier Osamu Mizobe, the Bishop of Takamatsu, encountered difficulties with the “Neo-Cats” four years ago when he was appointed head of the diocese. He and other bishops raised their concerns directly to the Pope and other Vatican officials last December when they came to Rome for their five-yearly ad limina visits. “In the small Catholic Church of Japan, the powerful sect-like activity of Way members is divisive and confrontational. It has caused division and strife in the Church,” said Archbishop Peter Takeo Okada of Tokyo, the bishops’ conference president, during his group address to the Pope.
But it is believed that Cardinal Ivan Dias, prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelisation of Peoples (Propaganda Fidei) and favourable to the Neo-Catechumenal Way, intervened to “protect” the movement. Japan’s 16 Catholic dioceses, with 500,000 members, are directly dependent on the cardinal’s office, rather than the Congregation for Bishops or the Secretariat of State, because they are considered to be in mission territory.
Undeterred, Bishop Mizobe appealed to Vatican officials a second time when he came back to Rome early last month with Japan’s highest-ranking bishops. That second visit still produced no results. The bishops returned for a third time and were finally able to meet privately with Pope Benedict.

For those of you unfamiliar with the NCW – it is one of the “New Movements” flourishing in the Church since the Second Vatican Council, with a particular emphasis on focusing members on living out their baptismal vows as a way of discipleship.
It is hugely popular in some parts of the world, and several reports from the Pope’s visit to the US indicate that members of the NCW were vocal, enthusiastic presences in both Washington and New York. (In fact, the family featured by the NYTimes in its coverage – the family that traveled from Texas to see the Pope – were members of NCW).
There have been problems, of course. Concerns about setting up a parallel or alternative structure that bypasses the parish. Liturgical concerns have been the subject of Vatican directives, giving the NCW a certain amount of time (I believe up until this year some time) to bring their standard Mass into line with the Roman Rite.  
I have absolutely no opinion on this, no personal knowledge of NCW, no inside knowledge.  I have heard frequent complaints of a “divisive” impact, and the liturgical issues are well known. I also know that the general mode of operating among many in the Asian hierarchy still focuses on indirect “evangelization” rooted in presence and dialogue in a culture in culture rather than an overtly evangelistic presence.  Who knows how all this worked together resulting in this rather dramatic move.

More from Beliefnet and our partners
Close Ad