
A new Barna study is exploring just who, or what, teens are turning to for advice. The study interviewed 1,500 U.S. teens from the ages of 13 to 18, the group known as Generation Alpha. The study found that 70% of teens struggle with the question of who they really are. Who they get advice for an answer ranges from parents to the internet. Mom ranked at number one at 84%, followed by Dad at 78%, friends 75%, Jesus 68%, and an adult mentor 67% to round out the top 5. YouTube came in 10th at 39%.
The study explored further how those numbers lined up for what was defined as “faith-activated” teens. Such teens were defined as teens who scored a 75 or greater in six faith “pathways” such as: spiritual practices, evangelism, service, faith integration, a sense of belonging and a perceived calling to ministry or missions. Mom still ranked highest as the source of advice at 80%, followed by Jesus and the Bible both at 78%, Dad at 77%, and friends at 76%. According to the report, faith-activated teens appeared more open to seeking guidance than their non-faith peers.
The report did find that faith-activated teens were more responsive to advice from things like social media and AI than the overall average amongst teens. 49% stated they trusted AI and technology to give helpful information, 20 points higher than all teens. 46% also stated AI was a “safe place” to ask questions versus 28% of all teens. 45% stated they would rather use digital tools for answers than people while 26% of all teens felt the same way. Amongst girls and boys, boys were more likely to get information from YouTube and AI than girls. “When students are questioning who they are, they’re going to go somewhere. Our job is to make sure a trusted adult, not an algorithm, is in that space,” said Richard Hamilton, a youth pastor at Castle Hills Christian Church.
The fact that parents remain so high as a source of information and guidance further underscores the importance of their role in guiding their teens’ faith and identity. “Students are listening more than it seems,” said youth ministry leader, Deborah Spooner. “Students show at youth group how much they love their parents in ways their parents never see or hear.”