Prayer, Plain and Simple

Prayer, Plain and Simple


Elinor Ostrom Shares the 2009 Nobel Prize in Economics – Her Case for Social Humility

posted by Mark Herringshaw

The Nobel Prize for Economics in 2009 goes to Elinor Ostrom, the first woman to receive the award. Ms. Ostrom’s research challenges the traditional view that common ownership of a resource results in excessive exploitation, that fishermen for instance left to their own devises will overharvest their product. The typical resource management solution has always been to privatize a resource, giving responsibility to a single legal owner – capitalism, or to govern it by the fiat of a central authority – socialism. Ostrom’s work challenges these solutions. She shares the Nobel honor with Oliver E. Williamson, whose separate work also explores the mystery of economic cooperation.

Countering popular assumptions – the either/or paradigm of individualist capitalism on one hand and governmental-centric socialism on the other – Ostrom’s work demonstrates that common property is often well-managed by the groups that rely on that resource. She shows that common users often negotiate rules of use that mitigate overexploitation without resorting to privatization or government regulation.

In other words, the community is often smarter than we think! We don’t need tycoons on the one hand or kings on the other to make decisions for our best interest. There really is such a thing as community wisdom. Concentrating ultimate power in the name of common good is dangerous and now, it seems also unnecessary.   

Plato’s “The Republic” warned that a human community is too weak to govern itself. We need philosopher-kings, super-smart rulers given absolute power to act on behalf of the governed. Unfortunately human history is a tragic demonstration of the failure of entrusting power to individuals. “Power tends to corrupt; absolute power tends to corrupt absolutely.” Ostrom’s work reaffirms suspicion in centralizing power, and offers the comforting, even exciting suggestion that local communities can be trusted to “do the right thing.”

As a Christian, I am deeply suspicious of concentrating capital in the hands of single individuals. The God of the Bible set up an economic system in ancient Israel that mitigated against centralized wealth. It was called “Jubilee” – the institutionalized redistribution of wealth, every 50 years back to the original clans that traditionally managed the resource. On the other hand I’m also wary of giving centralized control to any governmental power. In the scriptures, God limited that power of Kings by making them subject to his universal Law – including the stipulation of Jubilee. The rule of Law limits human control and continually moves power away from individuals back to the check and balance of the whole community.

This is best demonstrated in the economic “jazz session” brilliantly improvised in the early Christian church. The story is portrayed in the New Testament book of Acts (chapter 2-5). Without governmental oversight and without reliance on any single wealthy benefactor, the Christian community – as a whole – redefined economic reality. They VOLUNTARILY shared their resources, selling their properties to be distributed to those in need. Early Christians owned the responsibility to eradicate societal poverty, relying neither on wealthy individuals or governmental dictates to do the right thing. They acted justly by choice!

Christian charity for the benefit of the common good worked, not because any forceful hand forced generosity. Today we’re seeing this still. Christians around the world still lead the charge to bring clean water, medical care, rescue from human trafficking, and food distribution to the hungry. And we do this without any individual power source taxing us with a gun to the pocketbook. Christians gave and give to the poor because God gives us the desire to do so. The motivation comes from within us as individuals when we live and worship within a healthy, functioning community that holds the value that the good of the community comes ahead of our self interest. This is a pure and simple miracle, a miracle Ostrom has found operating all over the planet… I’d suggest that I see it best working inside Christian communties. I challenge you to explore this phenomenon. Look honestly at the voluntary work of groups like “Feed My Starving Children,” the “International Justice Mission,” and “World Vision.”

We typically see capitalistic or socialistic solutions as the only option for justice because we rightly do not trust individuals or communities of individuals to make right decisions for the common good. Ostrom’s research (and I would suggest Biblical and Christian history) challenge this assumptions. As a Christian I share the suspicion that we humans can ever solve our own problems. But Ostrom’s research seems to suggest that it’s possible for humans to find a motivation “outside” self interest. If we want to live free, beyond the tyranny of the wealthy few and the tyranny of an intractable government, we’d better find a ready source for the motivation to live beyond our personal immediate gratification. I’d suggest that that Source is God himself and that prayer can activate real love in our real lives. We can have an Acts chapter 2 generosity in our world once again. Kudos to Elinor Ostrom for giving us another glimpse that freedom really is possible and should be encouraged.

Follow me on Twitter  



  • mmagnolia

    Bouquets of Alleluia!
    Ms. Ostrom scores a homerun for The Human Team!
    Cheers to Ms. Elinor and to Mr. Oliver for being Heaven’s handmaidens!

Previous Posts

God Will Always Answer This Prayer With a Ready YES!
“...If your children ask for a fish, do you give them a snake instead?  Or if they ask for an egg, do you give them a scorpion? Of course not! So if you sinful people know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him

posted 8:57:50am Jul. 29, 2014 | read full post »

Eternal Life Begins Today
A religious expert came up to Jesus and asked him a question. It was a loaded one. "How does one inherit eternal life?" He was quizing Jesus and hoping to humiliate Him in public. It didn't work. Jesus didn't need to hear Himself talk, so, in his usual fashion, he turned the question around and ha

posted 12:25:50pm Jul. 23, 2014 | read full post »

Trump Your Fear
So be strong and courageous! Do not be afraid and do not panic... For the Lord your God will personally go ahead of you. He will neither fail you nor abandon you. ~Deuteronomy 31:6 Do not be afraid or discouraged, for the Lord will personally go ahead of you. He will be with you; he will neither fa

posted 12:13:26pm Jul. 22, 2014 | read full post »

My Safe Place - A Prayer
If you say, “The Lord is my refuge,” and you make the Most High your dwelling, no harm will overtake you, no disaster will come near your tent. Psalm 91:9,10 With the convenience of instantaneous news from all around the world at our fingertips 24 hours a day comes the ever increasing ten

posted 8:38:35am Jul. 21, 2014 | read full post »

The Power of Your Words to Hurt or Heal, Harm or Help
The words of the godly are a life-giving fountain... The words of the godly encourage many... The lips of the godly speak helpful words...  The words of the wise bring healing... Proverbs 10:11,21,32; 12:18 Words from our mouths can be refreshing, uplifting, and edifying. One word from you tod

posted 10:37:17am Jul. 10, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.