That’s how this Plain-Dealer profile describes the Rev. Bob Begin, Cleveland’s “rebel priest,” who has grown savvier as he has grown older, but still with the same zeal on behalf of his flock. The story focuses on Begin’s campaign to fight Bishop Richard Lennon’s order to close Begin’s parish, the 129-year-old St. Colman’s Church, one of 50 parishes Lennon ordered closed in a downsizing plan last March.

All parish closings are painful and exceedingly contentious, the merits of each case a saga like a Russian novel. St. Colman’s is in a poor area and provides a vital service to the community as well as to parishioners, and so it is natural–and right, I’d say, from afar–to champion their cause.

And yes, I cite this story as a counterpoint of sorts to the post below on the pope’s letter for the Year for Priests and his invocation of Saint Jean-Marie Vianney–but truly not so much to say one model is better and one worse, though I and many others might empathize much more with Father Begin. Rather, I think Begin represents another aspect of a dedicated pastor, perhaps every bit as much as Vianney. Yet it is an aspect that is too little appreciated, I think, by the powers-that-be simply because it smacks of a “wordly activism” that Benedict XVI warns clergy against.

Above all, however, I was struck by Father Begin’s approach to this campaign–standing firm but consulting others and “keeping a cool head.” That is a difficult balancing act for many groups in the church, especially reform groups, who are marginalized by the power structure, which often leads to them to become more outspoken or radicalized, which then confirms the suspicions of the authorities who pushed them away in the first place.

Here is an excerpt from Begin’s story:

Begin, a lawyer, wasted no time organizing parishioners and filing a formal appeal with the diocese.

“The biggest struggle was to keep it from becoming adversarial,” he said. “And so many people wanted to be adversarial. Thank God it didn’t come to that. I would have gotten fired and they would have had to evict me from the rectory.”

On the brink of taking it to the streets again, Begin sought the guidance of retired Bishop Anthony Pilla, who advised him to work patiently through the diocese’s appeals process.

“I told him to keep a cool head and trust in the Holy Spirit,” said Pilla.

Begin obeyed.

And after two meetings with Lennon, Begin convinced the bishop that St. Colman’s social services were vital lifelines to the neighborhood’s poor people and that the church was capable of operating in the black.

Last month, Lennon rescinded his order and kept St. Colman’s open. Two weeks ago, a congregation filling the church to the back burst into applause during a Mass of celebration.

“We’re so thankful, we’re serving ice cream and pizza in the church hall after Mass,” Begin told the happy gathering from the altar. He then led them in a chant, “The church is the people! The church is the people! . . . ”

For Begin, it was the people who saved St. Colman’s, but without his leadership, his followers say, the people would have been lost.

“He had the right tone, despite his reputation as the rebel priest,” said Eileen Kelly, outreach minister at St. Colman’s. “He was calm, not confrontational.

“It takes courage to speak to authority – truth to power. Bob has that courage and he has the experience. He was the right person for leading us.”


Join the Discussion
comments powered by Disqus