Is it the End of the World?

Is it the End of the World?

The Gingrich Who Stole the Palestinian Christmas

The current surging Republican candidate for president, Newt Gingrich, generated a firestorm of criticism today when he asserted in an interview that the Palestinians are “invented.” In answering a question about Zionism, he said:

“Remember, there was no Palestine as a state. It was part of the Ottoman Empire.”

This is factually true. Yet it has caused the Palestinians and their supporters around the world to bash Gingrich. In particular—not surprisingly—Palestinian “negotiators” Saeb Erekat and Hanan Ashrawi decried the former Speaker’s remarks.

Ashrawi trotted-out the usual diatribe against anyone calling Palestinian history into question: “This is certainly an invitation to further conflict rather than any contribution to peace.”

The Israel/Palestinian issue has become one of the chief flashpoints for the entire global community (hard to explain apart from biblical prophecies indicating just such a scenario, but that’s a separate subject). Each “side” has its own narrative, but Israel’s tends to be buttressed by facts.

The Palestinians tend to rely on emotional stories (“the IDF marched my family at gunpoint from their homes”), obfuscation, and outright denial of historical reality, among other things. Their long media campaign against Israel is enhanced by the fact that huge numbers of people hate Jews.

What Gingrich said is true. Why then the extreme reaction from the Palestinians and their supporters?

Because anyone who departs from the Palestinian narrative must be demonized and marginalized.

When I heard about the flap over Gingrich’s remarks, I thought about the many times that the Palestinians have gotten a pass over outrageous claims against the Jews and their history.

In the frenzied final months of Bill Clinton’s time in the Oval Office, the gifted communicator raced the clock to bring a final peace solution to the Arabs and Israelis. Incredibly—even Clinton was incredulous—PLO chieftain Yasser Arafat claimed the two Jewish temples of antiquity never stood on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. Erekat echoed this outrageous claim, as this excerpt from a recent article in The American Interest shows:

“Most Israelis were first exposed to the Palestinian denial of history in July 2000. According to U.S. negotiator Dennis Ross, when Jerusalem was discussed during the second Camp David summit, Palestinian Authority leader Yasir Arafat asserted that ‘the Temple never existed in Jerusalem, but rather in Nablus.’ Another senior Palestinian negotiator, Saeb Erekat, asserted, the ‘Jerusalem Temple is a Jewish invention.’ President Bill Clinton was astonished: ‘Not only do all of the world’s Jews believe that the Temple was located on the Temple Mount, but most Christians believe it, too.’”

The Arab story of a distinct Palestinian Arab people springs from an agenda to marginalize Israel. And they get away with it. It was after Camp David of 2000 that the Palestinians began the attempt to literally wipe away Jewish history, starting with the Temple Mount. Truckloads of dirt and artifact-filled debris were hauled away from the Mount and unceremoniously dumped. Two mosques were constructed underneath.

New mosque construction that destroyed part of the Temple Mount

I’ve been there and seen the desecration of perhaps the world’s most famous archaeological site. Newly cut paving stones, replacing the ancient ones there in biblical times, lead to underground mosques. Yet the Palestinians are allowed to get away with it; no one raises questions. However, Newt Gingrich (who knows history) makes a simple, factual statement, and he’s roundly denounced!

In the ‘90s, the official website for the Palestinian Authority cobbled together what I can only describe as a painfully thin “Palestinian history,” with the intention of convincing the world that there was once a nation of Palestine, with an indigenous population separate from the surrounding pan-Arab nation. Among the evidences displayed were pieces of Palestinian “currency,” and a few “Palestinian” dresses.

Upon close examination, the currency for “Palestine” was issued during the British Mandate, and contained characters in English, Arabic, and…Hebrew.

Oops. The currency was simply money created by the British for the region. It wasn’t currency backed by any sort of Palestinian authority, simply because there had never been one.

As for the dresses, they looked just like those sewn in Iraq, Lebanon, Jordan…well, you get the picture.

After these discrepancies were pointed out, the PA took them off the website.

Newt Gingrich merely stated the fact that there has never been a distinct nation of Palestine. If there had been one, may we see the evidence?

In her 1994 autobiography, Hanan Ashrawi, a shrewd propagandist, goes to great lengths to maintain the view opposite the one Gingrich presented. In an account of an IDF raid on Birzeit University in Ramallah, Ashrawi used her gift for narrative to describe seeing through the smoke of teargas “phantoms” emerging “from the mist,” these being Palestinian students. They had decided—in the middle of an allegedly brutal attack—to break out in a “primeval dance of survival,” described by Ashrawi as “the dabke, our ancient dance/ritual.”

The dabke is certainly an ancient dance, but one practiced by the pan-Arab nation. It is not distinctly “Palestinian.”

In a 1977 interview with the Dutch newspaper, Trouw, Zohair Mohsin said:

“It is only for tactical reasons that we carefully stress our Palestinian identity, for it is in the national interest of the Arabs to encourage a separate Palestinian identity to counter Zionism: the founding of a Palestinian state is a new tool in the ongoing battle against Israel.”

There is a diabolical dimension to this tension between Israel and the Arabs, because in the end, someone is in large measure not telling the truth.

Erekat and Ashrawi are held in high esteem by many, yet they support the Palestinian Authority, which can deny history and get away with it.


Gingrich states an historical fact and is demonized.


  • Bob

    You hit the issues right on the proverbial heads, re: Gingrich’s Palestinian snafu.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Donna

    Now, now, don’t confuse the world with facts–they already have their minds made up. Cool thing is, so does our God. NO ONE will EVER take that land from Israel. Pity the fool who tries!

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Myles

    And with all deceivableness of unrighteousness in them that perish; because they received not the love of the truth, that they might be saved.
    And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie:
    That they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness. 2 Thessalonians 2:10-12

    Man will not love the truth when a lie is more far more convenience to them to gain what they want; as in this case a land that history say that the Jew was there in the land long before the world ever heard of the word “Palestine”!

    It is born out of hate by one for another as in this case the descendents of Esau (Palestinian) and Jacob (Jew) born out of the same womb (Rachel) and have been a war with each other over this piece of land from the very moment they were born !

    This war between two brothers and their descendents will not go away until the Son of God Yeshua/Jesus steps into the affairs of men once again and makes right the lie that the world would rather believe, and the truth will finally be known to the world!

Previous Posts

Rebels Without a Cause
Those who dismiss the late James Dean as merely a brooding, self-absorbed young actor miss the point, I think. Dean, who evidently suffered both from the early loss of his mother and from abuse at the hands of a trusted clergyman, really was Jim Stark in many respects. The Nicholas Ray-directed f

posted 2:08:36pm Feb. 05, 2015 | read full post »

The King of Zionism
Each year, various groups and individuals seek to politicize the memory of Martin Luther King, on the national holiday in his honor. So I will, too. Perhaps a little-known fact about “MLK” is that he was a strong supporter of the Jewish state. In Israel, he saw hope for the future, and a s

posted 10:24:46am Jan. 19, 2015 | read full post »

Kay Wilson—Choosing Life
Today marks the fourth anniversary of the horrific Palestinian terror attack on my friend, Kay Wilson, and her friend, Kristine Luken. Kay survived, somehow; Kristine, a Christian, did not. Their attackers targeted them because they were looking to kill Jews. Ironically, Kristine was a person who

posted 11:49:49am Dec. 18, 2014 | read full post »

Jesus Unmasked
Jesus Christ…the most famous figure in world history. According to the apostle John: “Jesus did many other things as well. If every one of them were written down, I suppose that even the whole world would not have room for the books that would be written.” (John 21:25) Yet, for all Hi

posted 11:21:27am Dec. 15, 2014 | read full post »

Rewarding the Innovators
Untold News, an Israel advocacy group based in New York, is making headway explaining the marvelous innovations produced by the Jewish state. To add a fine point to the popularity of the Untold News platform (now with more than 350,000 “likes” on Facebook), founder Marcella Rosen has announced t

posted 4:42:20pm Sep. 30, 2014 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.