Advertisement

Deepak Chopra and Intent

Deepak Chopra and Intent

Good Enough For God? (by Deepak Chopra)

I’ve been pondering the belief that good people go to heaven while bad people go to hell. “Good” can be defined by absolutist rules pertaining to sin, like the Ten Commandments and much of the Koran, painting a clear map of what it takes to be good enough for God. Or “good” can be left to a person’s own moral values, in which case relativism prevails: terrorists in Iraq, for example, feel that they are doing good for God and expect heaven for actions that horrify people outside their sequestered belief system.


A great deal of harm has resulted from both approaches. Trying to be good enough for God isn’t a realistic basis for action unless we are content to divide into separate moral communities with little or no contact between them.
Since every person wants to lead a moral life–and a large majority say they believe in heaven and hell–what is the connection of right and wrong to Nature, or the universe? What kind of God wouldn’t want us to be good?
India already has an amoral religious tradition; the universe was not created to lead to a moral conclusion–a day of judgment when sinners will all be eternally punished and the righteous eternally rewarded. I am not espousing this tradition, only pointing out that the amorality of modern science, which sees no purpose to creation, has a religious equivalent. Leela, the dance of creation, is a pure phenomenon like the Big Bang, only seen in projected human terms as the play of gods and goddesses.
A God who doesn’t want us to be good may want us to be free instead. In my experience, free people wind up being as moral, and usually much more moral, than people bound by strictures and rules. In an amoral universe, free choice already seems like a truism, because there are no natural limitations to prevent the human race from pursuing any course of action it desires, including highly self-destructive ones. Even the instinct for self-preservation is not an absolute in human nature.
The idea of a God who wants us to be free is an evolving idea. It frightens many religionists and leads to violent opposition. But the history of modern life has moved toward personal freedom inexorably, and a God who evolves at the same time makes sense, given that we see God evolve continuously throughout the Old and New Testaments. “God: A biography” by Jack Miles gives a fascinating textual account of God’s many faces and changes in scripture.
A God who wants us to be free is the next evolved stage after a God who forgives and a God who redeems. These are non-punishing versions of God, and they can be found all over the world–not in mass religion, perhaps, but in many divinity schools and various reform and liberal sects.
Religion can be an ally of reason in this regard, because both can adapt to an amoral universe without accusing each other of breach of faith. The religionist doesn’t have to deny scientific fact, while science doesn’t have to dismiss faith as sentimental morality-based projection. Science already believes in freedom of the mind, and it’s time religion did, too.

Advertisement
Comments read comments(1)
post a comment
jim fitzgerald

posted February 14, 2008 at 9:50 am


Very thought provoking! I can see why this concept may be threatening to many folks. I think it is the contrast between an ‘external’ religion and an ‘internal’ religion. External religions look to the rules for life guidance. Internal ones make it clear that spirituality is inside of ones ‘self’ and you look inward to find it using the techniques described in the religious texts. The drive to do what’s right comes from within! A rather foreign concept to the external religions. No guilt! what a concept. Do whats right for your fellow human beings, not because if you don’t follow the rules you are doomed to an afterlife in hell,just to promote harmony in the world and thus your own world.- Thank You for being courageous and bringing this thought to life. Love and Peace



report abuse
 

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Previous Posts

A New Hot Button: Consciousness-Driven Evolution
Science is meant to be the opposite of a belief system. No one underlined this point more securely than Charles Darwin, who devised a theory of evolution that defied the strongest belief of his time, the all but universal belief in the bible ...

posted 11:12:21am Jul. 06, 2015 | read full post »

How to Make Quantum Reality Our Reality: Looking for a Better Deal
  By Deepak Chopra, MD and Ruth E. Kastner, PhD   If you ask a scientist to talk about quantum mechanics, it’s predictable that the first thing he or she is likely to say is that this is the most successful theory in the ...

posted 11:08:03am Jun. 29, 2015 | read full post »

Self-Compassion: Tips for loving yourself just as you are
  Do you love yourself just as you are? The way that people answer this question reveals a great deal about their upbringing. Well-loved children absorb from their parents a sense of self-worth that lasts a lifetime. But receiving mixed ...

posted 5:59:38am Jun. 22, 2015 | read full post »

The Health Benefits of Practicing Compassion
  Compassion is changing before our eyes. A religious concept associated with Jesus and Buddha (known as “the Compassionate One”) is being researched today through brain scans and positive psychology. In positive psychology your aim ...

posted 11:37:21am Jun. 15, 2015 | read full post »

How to Overcome the Fear of Death--Two Possibilities
The fear of death always comes at or near the top of people's worst fears. Some psychologists believe that this is such a potent fear, we push it down into the subconscious in order to avoid it. Yet from its hiding place the fear remains active, ...

posted 10:10:56am Jun. 08, 2015 | read full post »

Advertisement


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.