Doing Life Together

Doing Life Together


Grey’s Anatomy Gets Christianity Wrong Again

posted by Linda Mintle

Last night I watched an episode of Grey’s Anatomy, hoping that they would actually write the Christian character right. As in the past, I was sorely disappointed.

Here is what happened. The only virgin of the fifth year residents was staying in a hotel, preparing to take her surgery boards. The night before the boards, everyone was coping in their own way with the stress. April, whose character has refused sex based on her Christian faith, tells us her church was praying for her. The pressure of letting people down was immense. She finds herself with one of the “hottie” surgeons in a bar, drinking. Next thing we know, a man is picking a fight with her because she received his job offer in Cleveland. Clearly having had too much to drink, she physically fights and feels incredible good that she stood up to the guy, goes back to the hotel with her hottie colleague and starts to kiss him at her hotel door. True to the his character, he hesitates, tries to assess whether she really wants to go for sex and continues the sexual encounter. Kepner, drunk, feels good, free and has intercourse as a virgin. As soon as it is over, you can see the regret on her face. She tries to play it off.

The next morning right before the board exams, she is sitting next to the man she slept with and he asks if she is OK. She clearly looks distressed, but then she is about to take her surgical boards. She tells him YES because she loves Jesus. Wow, right out there with the issue. But then is when the writers get it wrong. She says, “Jesus hates me!”The scene ends.

Up til that point, I thought the story line was believable. The pressure to have sex while all her colleagues act out constantly around her has been building. The stress, along with the alcohol, being away from home, create temptations. True to life,  people give in to temptation when they engage versus flee. So far, very realistic.

To be convicted of her behavior because she acted in a way inconsistent with her faith, was really great to show. But to say, “Jesus hates me,” reflects a lack of understanding of our relationship with Christ. Now maybe she felt that in the moment because she was so disappointed with herself, but my fear is that this notion will not be corrected.

Truth is, Jesus didn’t hate her for sinning. A better response would have been, “I have sinned against my God, ” or ” I gave in to something I don’t believe is right,” or “I am so distressed with myself  for going against my beliefs.” Maybe even, “I’ve sinned against my own body.”

Jesus loves her even when she sins and that is the message of the Gospel. Jesus doesn’t condone her sin, hates her sin, but loves her and will never stop loving her. If Grey’s Anatomy will follow up with that correction, I will be OK. But my guess is the writers will get it wrong again like they did with another Christian character they wrote years ago.

This is why we need Christian writers–to thoughtfully deal with real issues like this, but with correct theology.

 



  • Linda Mintle

    I hope I didn’t miss the point of what you are saying. And I do appreciate your comments. That’s what this is about, a conversation.So thanks!

  • Missle11

    You have obviously missed the point of my argument so we will have to agree to disagree.

  • Nia Warouw

    That is reality. You should research your church too. I guarantee not all your church members are perfectly “Christians” even though they believe Jesus. A lot of us still struggle. And the reality as well Christians are made fun of.Thats the truth.
    Also Christians are still humans and we still do think about these things (that sex is so good, etc).

    The character April is what imperfect humans do. Christians are also imperfect humans. This show is not a theology show. Its a show that features a Christian.

    Only God can reach out to people. Not your outreach. Not your show. Not your Christian show. Only God can touch people.

  • Missle11

    I hope you see where I’m coming from. On the show her character is a total joke. They make fun of her and call her a dud. she is wacked out and considered crazy. we are called on this earth to be the difference. So people can see what it’s like to have Christ in your life. I think her character makes a mockery of our Christian faith. it’s even harder to take when you have someone calling themselves a Christian in their real life. As a Christian I could never do that.

  • Missle11

    I agree totally however its hard to reach secular audiences as it is and when you do the portrayal of a Christian is so off. They have sex and then she says I’m going to pray. Isn’t she mocking God’s grace? Is that how you would do it? Its one thing to sin in your personal life but when you are showing that to millions of people where they think you can sin as much as you want and then just ask God for forgiveness that’s what I have a problem with.they are making a mockery of our faith and she is a part of it. people are looking for any excuse to justify their sinful lifestyle. She was even questioning whether Jesus would accept premarital sex since it felt so good. Isn’t that what we call secular humanism?

  • Nia Warouw

    Dont ask me. Ask God how else. No one is righteous except God. So no one can judge. Its as simple as that.

    Why are you looking at Greys Anatomy character as an example of Christian behaviour? You should be looking at Jesus, not Greys Anatomy. Thats messed. Greys Anatomy is a story of human failure – and this applies to all Christians and all non-Christians. And despite all their failures, GOD STILL loves them and blesses them abundantly.

  • Missle11

    The Bible also says you will know them by their fruits. Ignorant christians always pull the we should not judge card however we are to judge with righteous judgement. We are to police ourselves. How else is someone to know what they are doing wrong if they are too blinded?

  • Nia Warouw

    A Christian is simply a person who believes Christ redeems our sins on the cross. No matter how broken and sinful and bad and disturbing and “a joke” they are. Only God can judge. It says in the bible do not judge. I think my comment still stands. The point of being a Christian is how wonderful Christ is – not how wonderful we are.

  • Nia Warouw

    A Christian is simply a person who believes Christ redeems our sins on the cross. No matter how broken and sinful and bad and disturbing and “a joke” they are. Only God can judge. It says in the bible do not judge.

  • Missle11

    I hope you changed your mind on the writing after watching the episodes after. Her character makes Christianity a joke! She is a joke if she thinks she is a Christian. No self respecting christian would portray their faith like that!

  • Nia Warouw

    I think it was exactly the correct way to write it. Yes Jesus does NOT hate us. But WE ourselves oftentimes do not believe He would love us even though we have sinned – exactly like April. We move away from God in shame everytime we sin. Her storyline also says she was blessed with two men who wanted to marry her even after she has sinned and confessed – so it shows Jesus did not hate her.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Hope

    Despite the fact that we know God does not hate us when we sin, I am afraid that the church ( Gods people- believers) may be building a culture in which legalism prevails in our failures. The truth is I know my God hates it when I sin and I also know His conditional love never leaves me but even after many years growing up in church and truly encountering God I am still bombarded with “religion” and I’m afraid April’s comment “Jesus hates me” is a true depiction of many people struggling with the bondage of a ‘works mentality’.

    Off course I 100% agree with you about the fact: that nothing that we do or don’t do could make God love us anymore. I suppose we have to pray for Shonda and have the faith to believe that a true depiction of a born again Christian will be illustrated. Thid maybe the beginning of a great story line. I know God has blessed Shonda with a beautiful gift of story telling. I pray God would have his way :)

    Hope (hopeywopey1990@hotmail.com)

  • Linda Mintle

    I forget her character name but it was the one Katherine Heigel played. They began her character as a Christian and she quickly slid into having sex and other behaviors.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment pamelajaye

    I was also disappointed with her saying “if it feels so good it can’t be bad”
    I guess that while her church was forgetting to teach her that God hates sin (not sinners) they also forgot to teach her that the “if it feels good do it” folks are *wrong.* (Ihave actually never met one of these folks,but they sure mentioned them a lot in my church”)

    As I have noticed Grey’s Anatomy as the only show where going to heaven is mentioned (frequently) I would like to see them resolve this – perhaps in a storyline.

    Also, the guy on Glee would not even get close to Quinn (good call,don’t tempt yourself) due to his faith-but he would not explain to her so she just felt rejected.

    Which earlier character did you mean?

  • Pingback: How to ruin a character in a single line « Claire Hennessy

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment JK

    I agree, with you all. Jesus doesn’t hate April. April is like the rest of us and struggles with her faith. All people can often be misguided, and she had a lot of guilt for what she did. If she reads the bible and understand Jesus, April would know that he forgives, and loves all. Hope she’ll get straightened out, and learn the truth about Jesus.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Tonya

    I agree with this statement and expect that the writers for Grey’s Anatomy will be able to go beyond what “she” feels and incorporate the character of Jesus and how he continues to love her despite the sin, but most importantly– she can repent and ‘ask’ for forgiveness, and God is faithful and just to forgive. (She will be forgiven.) And she can repair her relationship with Christ and pursue salvation.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Jen

    Grey’s didn’t get it wrong and the story is still believable. The character April Kepner and her relationship with and understanding of Jesus and Christianity is written to represent a different understanding and relationship than one you might have. It’s conceivable someone may feel that way after behaving in a way inconsistent with one’s values and beliefs.

    I’m sorry you are unhappy with the way Christianity was represented and that the character’s Jesus isn’t your Jesus. That’s too bad but the writers of the show are not you nor are they writing about how you would feel and react if in that situation.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Nancy

    I completely agree! I am glad I am not the only out there who watched this and thought, REALLY?! Jesus does not feel that way! He loves you anyway. Even if they correct it on the next episode, that is not a topic that should be left “hanging”. I have about had enough with this show.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment aberta

    NO, Gray’s Anatomy didn’t get it wrong. She was expressing her dark fear that the “sin” she had committed would lead to God rejecting her. It’s because she didn’t like herself at that moment. She’s not expressing a truth, only a feeling based in fear. Gray’s was right to portray the scene the way they did, acknowledging the depth and complexity of human emotion and spirituality. For viewers who can’t discern between feeling and fact, let them read owner’s manuals and watch instructional videos. At least they’ll be safe from any messy feelings. Christians are too quick to jump on the “defend your faith” bandwagon. Instead of criticizing the show for its portrayal of momentary Christian doubt, they should embrace those who have made mistakes and allow them to experience forgiveness. Jesus shows his love through other Christians. Let’s hope they can rise to the challenge.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment dean

    get over it

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment dd

    I agree with Rachel, this post, and you all. Jesus doesn’t hate April for messing up. I’m not sure though, if they meant audience to believe that that’s how ‘Christianity’ is, or whether they are just showing us that April doesn’t accurately understand her faith. Young people can often be misguided, and she clearly had a lot of guilt for what she did. If she had a better understanding of Jesus, April would know that he forgives, and loves all. I am hoping against hope that next week she’ll get straightened out, and learn the truth.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Rachel

    I felt the same way. But what made me even more sad is that while Jesus does not hate her, her words held some truth in that they reflected what often gets absorbed by young people in the church. While we may preach grace, it is not often experienced through action and so we end up hearing the sort of performance gospel that April had been struggling with–a gospel that is void of real love and acceptance despite flaws (which is no good news at all).

    I like your point about needing Christian writers to deal with these topics carefully. Otherwise, this inaccurate view of God will continue to plague oru culture

  • Pingback: Grey’s Anatomy Gets Christianity Wrong Again | Dr. Linda Mintle

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Love

    While I am not of faith, I was jarred to hear April say such a thing as “Jesus hates me.” What I admire about Christians and Christianity is when they take Jesus’s teaching about loving all and withholding judgment to heart. Though it was Grey’s writers that made the error, I hope that all Christians who saw this were equally upset, not because April sinned, which is human and she is clearly repentant, but because she could ever believe that Jesus would hate anyone, when he is meant to love all.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Rich

    You are so right Linda – when I heard this on the show last night, I literally screamed out “NO! a thousand times NO!” That is NOT how Jesus feels about her, us and the rest of humanity. “While we were yet sinners, Christ died for us.” One of the most hopeful verses in all of the Bible. But unfortunately how many millions of people heard that last night and it just affirmed the view of God as this old man holding a wooden spoon, jusst waiting to whack people over the head when they do wrong. The evil one must have had a BIG smile on his wicked face last night at that one.

Previous Posts

Fatal Attraction: What You Found Attractive May Now Bother You
When John dated Katie, he was attracted to how book smart she was and how much she loved to learn new things. He is the first to tell you, he's not cut out for academics and loves to play instead of learn. As someone who needed to play more, Katie was attracted to John's outgoing and fun personality

posted 6:00:02am Sep. 30, 2014 | read full post »

Would You Rather Be Shocked Than Bored?
I can remember so many times when my kids would say to me, "I'm bored!" And they didn't like my response, "That's a good thing. Maybe you can listen to your thoughts or think creatively." Truth is, most of us don't like to be bored. At least not in this wired age. Our typical boredom trainers are

posted 6:00:54am Sep. 29, 2014 | read full post »

Kardashian Catwalk Controversy: A Little Sibling Rivalry?
Think drama! NO, think mindless drama. Now who comes to mind? The Kardashians of course. If there is a way to keep their names in the news, they find it. And so it goes with the latest "controversy." Apparently, 18- year- old Kendall Jenner banned sister Kim Kardashian from attending her fashi

posted 7:55:46am Sep. 26, 2014 | read full post »

Lifestyle Changes Now May Prevent Alzheimer's Later
I remember when my grandmother began to have memory loss in her early 80s. It was hard to watch because she knew she was losing it. Eventually, Alzheimer's took its hold on her mind and she ended up in a nursing home not knowing who we were. If you, like me, have a family member who suffers with

posted 6:00:32am Sep. 24, 2014 | read full post »

What is Bipolar Depression?
When academy award winning actress, Catherine Zeta-Jones announced that she suffered from Bipolar II Disorder and checked into a mental health facility for a brief stay in 2011, it made celebrity news. People wondered. What is Bipolar Disorder and how does that differ from depression? The Nat

posted 6:00:15am Sep. 22, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.