Beliefnet
  
advertisement

Bring Back the A-Word

Why conservatives shouldn't be shy about citing the 'abomination' Bible verse when objecting to gay marriage.
By David Klinghoffer



Print Page

Just as homosexuality was once the love that dare not speak its name, there is a Bible verse that opponents of gay marriage rarely speak. It is Leviticus 18:22, which reads: "You shall not lie with a man as one lies with a woman, it is an abomination." These ancient words, the Bible's most direct statement on homosexuality, need to be rehabilitated. Why? Because American security and prosperity are linked with the sexual norms we sanction.

A rabbinic interpretive tradition (one which goes back at least to the fourth century C.E. and is found in the midrashic book Sifra) understands another verse in Leviticus 18 to mean that the locals in Canaan actually conducted same-sex marriages, among other forbidden sexual practices the Canaanite peoples had sanctioned. It was for this that God ejected them from the holy land: "Do not become contaminated through any of these [acts]; for through all of these the nations that I expel before you became contaminated. The land became contaminated and I recalled its iniquity upon it; and the land disgorged it inhabitants" (vv. 24-25). The Canaanites suffered national defeat, invasion, humiliation. Finally, they disappeared from history. (Did you ever meet a "Canaanite"?)

The Bible doesn't frown on gay sex uniquely. In the first five books of the Bible (the Torah), homosexual intercourse isn't the only act called an "abomination." The book of Deuteronomy applies the terms to certain unethical business practices, which in Leviticus are denounced as a "perversion" (see Deut. 25:16, Lev. 19:35).

But same-sex intimacy is unique (along with incest and sex with animals) in being pointed to as among the failings of a non-Jewish people, the Canaanites, that brought about that group's final moral dissolution. I don't know of another category of sin that, in the biblical context, is both a) explicitly made applicable to gentiles and b) is spoken of in such emphatic terms as leading to societal breakdown, whether the society in question is Jewish or not.

Basic moral principles apply not only to Jews, in other words, but to all people, even those that don't follow Jewish dietary laws. If any country defies them, it will suffer a fate akin to the Canaanites'. The men and women of Canaan were not held responsible for not observing the Jewish Sabbath--to pick another example of a practice asked only of Jews; but they were held responsible for rejecting the fundamental moral tenet that marriage is between a man and a woman.

Related Features


« Prev Page Next Page »
Page  | 2 

Print Page
David Klinghoffer is a columnist for the Forward and the author, most recently, of The Discovery of God: Abraham and the Birth of Monotheism (Doubleday).

advertisement
Poll
Should committed same-sex relationships be recognized by the government?
Yes, with full-fledged marriage equal in all ways to heterosexual marriage
Yes, with a "civil union" that gives some legal benefits, but not as many as marriage
No official or legal recognition
I don't know

vote       View Results
Talk About It

Related Features

Related Features
Citing Leviticus 18 Isn't Kosher
It refers to temple prostitution, some maintain.

'My Blessed Gay Marriage'
A gay man says his marriage may not be legal, but is a union in God's eyes.

Homosexuality in Leviticus, Romans & More
A conservative and liberal scholar face off on controversial Bible passages.

The Spiritual Side of Gay Marriage
An Episcopal priest on the evolution of a sacrament

The Sin of Sodom Wasn't Sodomy
It may have been indifference to the poor.

Liberal Christian Views on the Bible & Gays
Features
Gay Marriage: the Complete Debate
News, opinion articles, and more
Faiths & Practices | Inspiration | Health | Entertainment | Comfort & Support | Family & Home
Relationships | News & Blogs | Audio/Video | Discussions | Ecards | Prayer Circles | Meditations | Quizzes
Copyright © 2008 Beliefnet, Inc. and/or its licensors. All rights reserved.
Use of this site is subject to Terms of Service
and to our Privacy Policy. Constructed by Beliefnet.