Meanwhile, campaign managers and journalists imply, often ominously, that religion is a wild card that can decide winners and losers by meting out rewards and punishments to candidates who either agree or disagree with various religious positions. Among the issues most often mentioned as carrying political weight in the current campaign, for example, are gay marriage and abortion.
Yet this is a faulty conclusion built upon a facile analysis. America may be brimming with religion, but it is a kind that generally has little to do with the traditions and teachings that underlie it. It has become, for the most part, yet another servant of the economic and social order that sets the real priorities: success and material comfort. The prophets Jeremiah and Amos, who regularly scolded ancient Israel for crushing the poor, have been sent to the woodshed.
In the process, Christianity has become a private concern, a rescue squad to revive those crippled in free enterprise combat. It has taken on the functions of therapy and self-help, preaching its own version of self-centeredness that leaves political matters such as "justice" far behind. Religion hasn't been booted out of the public arena by mean-spirited secularists; it has largely quit going out in public to bring the full message of its heritage.
Rather than looking critically at social policy, in the manner of the prophets, Christians ignore or passively accept it at a time when prophets are so urgently needed. Examples abound. Prominent CEOs sing in the choir on Sunday and rob their corporations on Monday; physicians say their morning prayers and bilk Medicare for unnecessary surgery; Fellowship of Christian Athletes huddle in worship in locker rooms before breaking the bones of their foes. Many American Christians simply find ways to feel good in Sunday pews and then get on with the real business the next day.
This monumental collapse of public religion into individualism and self-seeking was dramatized two decades ago by Robert Bellah in Habits of the Heart. Bellah claimed that among Americans, commitment to concepts of the common good--the welfare of others and the community--was being undermined in the face of a growing consumer mentality that increasingly used religion to attain personal ends. God had been increasingly cast as Therapist, for example, giving harried Americans "permission" to do most anything. The trend was so vast and deep, he said, that it was virtually unstoppable. Many would argue now that, if anything, Bellah's analysis might even have been understated.
As the land of freedom and opportunity, America has always been a nation of people bent on success and improvement. No period of the nation's history was governed purely by religious precepts. But it could be argued that before the industrial revolution dawned in the 19th century, religion provided a frame of reference for public policy, a canopy over its proceedings. This mindset was undoubtedly flouted more often than it was honored, perhaps, but it was at least a set of standards deemed worthy of serious consideration.
Christianity has always been prone to captivity by the culture since it fell to the lures of the Roman Empire and began to benefit from its position as the official state religion. But the church has not always ignored its message for the sake of gaining favor. Two examples: One was the religious uprising against a segregated America, led by Martin Luther King Jr., when large numbers of church people marched into the teeth of armed defenders of racial bigotry. Their actions came with a price--for some, their lives--and made an enormous difference with the passage of civil rights laws.
So Christianity can be practiced in the public square and obviously has, though rarely.