Bush Okays Limited Stem-Cell Funding
As Pro-Life As Presidents Get
By Richard Land
Behind Bush's decision
Behind Bush's decision
The text of Bush's speech
Beliefnet's complete coverage
What do you think?Join a Science & Religion discussion
Join a Catholic Church teaching discussion
The classic pro-life view says, in effect, that "a life is a life is a life." But most Americans make far more distinctions about "life."
Almost everyone considers plant life less sacred than animal life. Even vegetarians kill asparagus plants, though they had an active life system that took in nutrients, secreted waste and emitted energy. Most of us also distinguish between forms of animal life. Few think it murder to step on a bug; most view it as horrendous to eat a stallion.
Kosher Jews and Muslims who follow laws of halal are implicitly creating yet another class of animal--those that are precious enough to require a compassionate death (unlike, say, a mosquito), and yet not so noble as to be off-limits (like humans).
Most important, we make distinctions about human life. Though there are some who believe that if one opposes abortion, one must also oppose the death penalty, most Americans separate the issues and deem executing a murderer to be, in the abstract, permissible. The reason, of course, is that that particular life is not "innocent."
Even when we decide to execute someone, we have rules about what the best way of killing is--our version of kosher laws. Just as a cow must be killed swiftly and with a minimum of pain, a human must be executed by lethal injection.
Helping someone to die (through euthanasia) is also looked upon with favor by many Americans, but it's obviously not proper to "help" them against their will. Sending soldiers to die is acceptable if the war is appropriate.
In short, we hold different standards for different types of human life in different situations. In all these cases--the death penalty, euthanasia, and war--we are saying it is okay to take a life if it's for a just cause.
And then there is life within the womb. Activists on both sides of the abortion debate avoid viewing life on a continuum. Pro-life activists do not believe there is a difference between the life in a fertilized egg and the life that exists seconds before birth.