Steven Waldman

Steven Waldman

Obama & the Holocaust: The Strange Agreement Among & Arabs Jews

Tarek Hefni, a Cairo college student, response to Obama’s speech:

“I did not feel very comfortable regarding the two state solution and regarding treating the Holocaust as a fact. It is still a debatable issue and should not be taken as granted….I also don’t see any relevance between people being killed by other nation and building a homeland in a different land.”

In other words, a genocide doesn’t make a case for Israel’s right to exist.
Ironically, the Jewish Anti-Defamation League made a similar point:

“While he made strong statements against anti-Semitism and Holocaust denial, it should have been made clear that Israel’s right to statehood is not a result of anti-Semitism and the Holocaust. “


Similarly, both sides objected to an implied equivalence between the treatment of Jews and the treatment of Palestinians — with Palestinians objecting that it minimized the suffering of Palestinians and Jews saying it minimized the suffering of Jews.
On the first point, I actually would argue that the Holocaust, and historical persecution in general, is the most universally persuasive argument for Israel’s right to existence. If you base it on Biblical justifications, then Palestinians can argue that at various other points in history they were the primary population in the land. The Holocaust added a new fact to the discussion — the reality that anti-semiticism is so virulent and pervasive that only a separate state could possibly protect Jews.
But i find it fascinating that it’s an argument that seems to be unpersuasive to many Jews, and depressing that it’s unpersuasive to Arabs.
On the second point, the idea that Obama dissed one or the other of them by equating Pallestinian suffering with the Holocaust, I have to admit, I didn’t hear the speech that way. Yes, he followed the Holocaust passage with the phrase, “on the other hand,” and then discussed Palestinian suffering — and I definitely can see how both sides would view an implied equivalence.
But read again that controversial sentence: “On the other hand, it is also undeniable that the Palestinian people – Muslims and Christians – have suffered in pursuit of a homeland.” He did not say “suffered equally” or “suffered just as much.” He just said they suffered, too, and that that’s a very important factor. I’m not sure I agree that saying both historical realities are crucial to the discussion means that they were equally egregious problems.
I also believe that any risk to that formulation was greatly out-weighed by the crucial importance of Obama standing in Cairo, telling the Arab world that it is a “fact” that six million Jews died. For many young Arabs, Obama may be the most credible person they’ve ever heard say that.

Comments read comments(2)
post a comment

posted June 5, 2009 at 7:25 pm

It’s certainly true that six million Jews died in the Holocaust. But it’s also true that nine million others also died in the Holocaust, Gypsies, gays, Communists, Poles, etc. So shouldn’t we also set up a homeland for gays and lesbians somewhere? A homeland for Gypsies might be a contradiction in terms, but what about them? Aren’t they still suffering persecution?
I personally believe a better approach is to make a world free of persecution, not individual states free of persecution for certain groups.

report abuse


posted June 6, 2009 at 11:01 am

“both sides objected to an implied equivalence between the treatment of Jews and the treatment of Palestinians — with Palestinians objecting that it minimized the suffering of Palestinians and Jews saying it minimized the suffering of Jews.”
The same thing happens when couples come into therapy–often they literally cannot tolerate their partner being validated. The both have a “I am the victim, not my partner!” stance. Until they can both view themselves as victims to a common enemy (e.g. the negativity) they will probably continue to be stuck.

report abuse

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to and may be used by in accordance with the agreements.

Previous Posts

More Blogs To Enjoy!
Thank you for visiting this page. This blog is no longer being updated. Please enjoy the archives. Here are some other blogs you may also enjoy: Top Religious News Most Recent Inspiration Post Happy Reading! ...

posted 6:00:22pm Apr. 20, 2012 | read full post »

Good Bye
Today is my last day at Beliefnet (which I co-founded in 1999). The swirling emotions: sadness, relief, love, humility, pride, anxiety. But mostly deep, deep gratitude. How many people get to come up with an idea and have rich people invest ...

posted 8:37:24am Nov. 20, 2009 | read full post »

"Steven Waldman Named To Lead Commission Effort on Future of Media In a Changing Technological Landscape" (FCC Press Release)
STEVEN WALDMAN NAMED TO LEAD COMMISSION EFFORT ON FUTURE OF MEDIA IN A CHANGING TECHNOLOGICAL LANDSCAPE FCC chairman Julius Genachowski announced today the appointment of Steven Waldman, a highly respected internet entrepreneur and journalist, ...

posted 11:46:42am Oct. 29, 2009 | read full post »

My Big News
Dear Readers, This is the most difficult (and surreal) post I've had to write. I'm leaving Beliefnet, the company I co-founded in 1999. In mid November, I'll be stepping down as President and Editor in Chief to lead a project on the future of ...

posted 1:10:11pm Oct. 28, 2009 | read full post »

"Beliefnet Co-Founder and Editor-in-Chief Steps Down to Lead FCC Future of the Media Initiative" (Beliefnet Press Release)
October 28, 2009 BELIEFNET CO-FOUNDER AND EDITOR-IN-CHIEF STEPS DOWN TO LEAD FCC FUTURE OF THE MEDIA INITIATIVE New York, NY - October 28, 2009 - Beliefnet, the leading online community for inspiration and faith, announced today that Steven ...

posted 1:05:43pm Oct. 28, 2009 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.