Religion & Public Life With Mark Silk

Religion & Public Life With Mark Silk

Elena Kagan, religion clause conservative

It’s starting to look as though Elena Kagan may be the kind of Supreme Court justice who fits in very nicely with the post-separationist ideology of the Rehnquist and Roberts courts. In her confirmation hearings to be solicitor general, she threw under the bus the interpretation favored by her then boss, Thurgood Marshall, and his fellow separationists in Bowen v. Kendrick, a case that challenged the Adolescent Family Life Act.

The act
authorizes Federal funds for religious organizations designed to
discourage teen pregnancy and provide care to pregnant teens. The separationist minority’s position was that the act violated
the First Amendment’s ban on religious establishments because, as law clerk Kagan had put it in a memo, “when the government funding is to be used for projects so close to the
central concerns of religion, all religious organizations should be off
limits.” Solicitor General-nominee Kagan called that “the dumbest thing I have ever heard.”


Now comes Kagan’s view, as legal adviser in the Clinton White House, on a case in which the California Supreme Court ruled that a landlord illegally violated a state fair housing law by refusing on religious grounds to rent an apartment to an unwed couple. The landlord, Kagan indicated in a newly released memo, had a free exercise right not to rent:

The plurality’s reasoning seems to me quite outrageous — almost as if a
court were to hold that a state law does not impose a substantial burden
on religion because the complainant is free to move to another state.

One might argue that, in her earlier confirmation hearing, Kagan was just, ah, cozying up to Senate Republicans. But the internal memo is different matter. Permitting free exercise to trump anti-discrimination laws–which could include a refusal to rent to a legally married  same-sex couple–is a very big deal. It will be interesting to see whether conservative religious legal outfits like the Becket Fund and the American Center for Law and Justice decide to embrace Kagan. And whether the other side–the ACLU and Americans United–begins having serious doubts.

Update: Memo and the amicus brief it relates to: Kagan on RFRA.pdf

Comments read comments(1)
post a comment

Pingback: Kagan’s Free Exercise Clause - Religion & Public Life With Mark Silk

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to and may be used by in accordance with the agreements.

Previous Posts

Another Blog To Enjoy!!!
Thank you for visiting Religion and Public Life. This blog is no longer being updated. Please enjoy the archives. Here are some other blogs you may also enjoy: Latest News Story on Beliefnet Happy Reading!   ...

posted 3:10:11pm Aug. 27, 2012 | read full post »

The Ayn Rand Republicans
I confess to feeling a little bit queasy about the American Values Network's new video hoisting Rep. Paul Ryan, Sen. Rand Paul, Rush Limbaugh, and other GOP luminaries on the petard of Ayn Rand and her atheistic philosophy of objectivism. Take a ...

posted 7:13:30pm May. 24, 2011 | read full post »

Whither evangelicals?
I'm fully prepared to believe that Mitch Daniels' family proved to be the unleapable hurdle in his abortive run-up to the GOP presidential race. Imagine yourself as wife Cheri, having split for the coast to marry on old flame, your husband and ...

posted 9:19:56am May. 23, 2011 | read full post »

No more "social conservatives"
With the presidential election cycle getting up to speed, it's time for reporters and yakkers like me to stop writing about "social conservatives" as if they were an identifiable segment of the voting population. I say this as someone who has ...

posted 8:25:11am May. 20, 2011 | read full post »

So clerical celibacy was not the problem?
Those on the Catholic left are not very happy that the Jay Report declines in no uncertain terms to blame clerical celibacy for the sexual abuse crisis. As the report puts it: Factors that remained consistent over this time period, such as ...

posted 9:50:34am May. 19, 2011 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.