Rabbi Shmuley Unleashed

Rabbi Shmuley Unleashed

Open Letter to J-Street after their Attack on Elie Wiesel By Rabbi Shmuley Boteach

Pity Jeremy Ben-Ami, the hapless head of J-Street, the we-condemn-Israel-constantly-because-of-how-much-we-love-it lobby.



In the recent tension between the Obama Administration and the Jewish state over Jews building in Jerusalem, the pro-Israel camp was represented by Elie Wiesel whose full-pages ads in major American newspapers criticized President Obama’s ban on Jews living anywhere in the holy city. The letter, as with everything Wiesel writes, was haunting, stirring, and deeply personal. “For me, the Jew that I am, Jerusalem is above politics.  It is mentioned more than six hundred times in Scripture?and not a single time in the Koran. Its presence in Jewish history is overwhelming. There is no more moving prayer in Jewish history than the one expressing our yearning to return to Jerusalem… The first song I heard was my mother’s lullaby about and for Jerusalem.”





The letter, by one of America’s most celebrated
citizens, caused such angst in the White House that President Obama changed his
schedule to invite the Nobel Peace laureate to a private kosher lunch in order
not to appear out of sync with the Jewish prophet. Like Lyndon Johnson who
panicked when he lost Walter Cronkite over Vietnam, Obama understood that
losing Wiesel over his Middle East policy spelled almost certain doom.



But while the President behaved courteously,
Ben-Ami did precisely the opposite. Not content with Judaism’s greatest living
personality having the last word, the J-Street head quickly went into action
and responded to Wiesel with full page ads of a bizarre editorial by Yossi
Sarid, the former Meretz politician, utterly unknown to the American public whom
Ben-Ami is seeking to influence. The man who Oprah travelled to Auschwitz with
and chose his book Night as a main selection of her book club and whose novels
are studied in the world’s leading Universities was dismissed by Sarid as being
a writer ignorant of current events. “You know much about the heavenly
Jerusalem but less so about its counterpart here on earth.”



Sarid was only getting started. Next he accused
Wiesel of being naïve and easily misled. ‘Someone has deceived you, my dear
friend.’ Sarid’s friendship would intensify two paragraphs later when he
accused the man revered around the world as humanity’s most eloquent voice for
the oppressed as a religious fanatic ‘imbuing our current conflict with
messianic hues.’ Finally, not content with his dismissal of Wiesel as ignorant,
naïve, and fanatical, he couldn’t help himself but conclude that Wiesel is not
only confused but intentionally sought to mislead and misinform others. ‘It is
unfortunate that a man of your standing must confuse fundamental issues and
confound the reader.’



How unfortunate that Ben-Ami and Sarid were not
able to forewarn the gullible American president not to invite the ignorant
holocaust survivor to lunch and to instead send Air Force One to pick up the
encyclopedic, peace-loving, temperate Sarid instead!


Which brings me back to Jeremy Ben-Ami, whom I
would now like to address directly.



“Jeremy, my dear Jewish brother. Since the launch
of J-Street not long ago you have tried hard, like any effective CEO, to make a
name for your organization and capture headlines. The method you have
used, however, appears to involve a cavalcade of insults and attacks. And while
this has worked in the short term, knowing just a little bit about PR myself, I
am fairly certain that it will backfire in the long run.



“Last September I wrote a column commenting on
your quotations in a New York Times Magazine feature where you insulted all
staunch American Jewish supporters of Israel as paranoids who believe that the
world is filled with murderous anti-Semites. Surely that kind of character
assassination is not only unnecessary but, I would argue, indicative of
significant insecurity about your message. Not that I blame you. I realize that
you have the most difficult job of any Jewish organizational head in the world,
namely, running an organization that purports to be pro-Israel but invariably
finds itself in the company of Israel’s worst enemies and critics.



“But even so I never believed that someone as
media-savvy as you would make the mistake of spending your valuable money on
full pages ads attacking Elie Wiesel. That, my brother, is pure suicide.


“I twice hosted Prof. Wiesel at Oxford University
for public lectures where more than 2000 non-Jewish students hung on his every
word. I took him to lecture at the Mormon Church in Utah where thousands more
felt awed to simply stand in the same room as him, and just a few months ago I
hosted him in New York City on a panel with my friends Dr. Mehmet Oz and Mayor
Cory Booker of Newark at a seminar on values where you could hear a pin drop
from the more than one thousand people who stood in line to hear him. In each
of these forums people from all walks of life came to bask in the light of the
man regarded as the most courageous living voice for victims of hatred and
genocide. He is regarded by most as a living saint, and his books, especially
Night, are among the most influential literature of modern times. You might as
well take out full pages ads savaging Nelson Mandela, Mother Theresa, and the
Dalai Lama.



“I suggest that whoever is your PR consultant, my
friend, be fired immediately and that you recalibrate your message to simply
criticize Israel, which J-Street has done with considerable success, rather
than attack the voice of the six million which has, predictably, brought an
avalanche of condemnation of protest both in print and all over the internet.



“And Jeremy, my dear brother, please be advised
that while my advice is free, Wiesel’s words are priceless.”



Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, founder of This World: The
Values Network, is publishing, this week, his new book ‘Renewal: A Guide to the
Values-Filled Life.'(Basic Books). His website is

Comments read comments(9)
post a comment

posted May 12, 2010 at 6:37 am

There is the story of the scorpion and the frog. The scorpion must get to the other side of a rushing river, but being a non-swimmer he can’t manage it by himself. So he asks a frog to ferry him across the river on the frog’s back. The frog is wary of the poisonous scorpion, but the scorpion implores him to do this good deed and earnestly promises not to sting the frog if he will only help the scorpion. Good guy that the frog is, he puts aside his better judgment, let’s the scorpion get on his back, and swims for the other side with his passenger. As soon as they reach the other shore, the scorpion delivers a fatal sting to the frog. The frog can’t believe the treachery with which his kindness has been repaid and as he lies dieing asks why the scorpion did it. The scorpion in turn asks the frog what he expected of him. The frog did know that this was a scorpion he willling took on his back. Did the frog really expect that he the scorpion would behave in a way inconsistent with the way scorpions behave?
Point of the story, if it is not obvious – isn’t it frog-like foolish, perhaps dangerously so, to expect J Street to be other than J Street?
Then, what is the point of telling Ben Ami that attacking Weisel is “pure suicide”? Is it a matter of solicitousness on Weisel’s part? Or is it to caution J Street against doing that which will undermine the organization? If it is the former, I think it unnecessary, since the J Street ad doesn’t diminish or reflect badly on Weisel, it only diminishes and reflects badly on J Street. If it is the latter, why not let J Street, yea encourage J Street, to undermine itself? Have you never heard the advice about what to do when you walk in on an enemy attempting suicide, that being not to interfere?

report abuse

Howard Wolf

posted May 15, 2010 at 3:14 am

I couldn’t agree more. Would I have attempted to interfere with A. Hitler’s suicide? You can bet your life I wouldn’t have.

report abuse

Jewish Ideas Daily

posted May 16, 2010 at 2:42 am

You hit the nail on the head with this one. The saying “Any publicity is good publicity” is only true in the short-term.

report abuse

Aryeh Moshen

posted May 17, 2010 at 12:40 pm

This is perhaps the best and most succinct statement made by Rabbi Boteach.

report abuse

Glenn Tamir

posted May 17, 2010 at 8:15 pm

Dear Rabbi Boteach,
I think you make a grave mistake by your deification of Mr. Wiesel. While he is an amazing man, he is still a man and just because he has a point of view does not make it sacrilidge to criticize that point of view.
I will agree with Sarid on one thing. The Mr. Wiesel and most Jews DO NOT understand the reality of today’s Jerusalem. They have never spent any time in the Arab East Jerusalem neighborhoods and could never even find them on a map.
When Sarid says that Mr. Wiesel has only a spiritual understanding of Jerusalem, he is mostly correct. I think everyone should and could have a better understanding of the realities of current Jerusalem and the problems face by both Jews and Arabs who live there.
Denying one side’s right to express this point of view is ignorant at best.

report abuse

Anan E. Maus

posted May 23, 2010 at 8:38 pm

we have to start concentrating on the points of connection, not the points of difference.
There is that wonderful soccer program that brings Israeli and Arab children together.
We need these kinds of programs all over the entire Middle East, until all the cultural hatred is ended.

report abuse


posted January 26, 2011 at 12:21 pm

Wow. That was awesome. Well done, well written, well said.
“And Jeremy, my dear brother, please be advised that while my advice is free, Wiesel’s words are priceless.”

report abuse

Pingback: J-Street: Not Up Our Alley – Clear, Concise, Collegiate Opinions

Pingback: J Street, Not Up Our Alley « The Georgetown Progressive

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to and may be used by in accordance with the agreements.

Previous Posts

Public Asks for Political Inspiration, but Responds to Negative Attacks
There are two people running against me in the Republican primary for New Jersey’s Ninth district and recently I had an interesting lesson in politics from both. Call me naïve, but I really thought we could have a primary where people ...

posted 2:12:46pm Apr. 24, 2012 | read full post »

Would Hilary Rosen Have Criticized Stay-at-Home Dads as Never Having Worked?
It's good that Hilary Rosen apologized for her comments that Ann Romney, who chose to be a stay-at-home mom to raise her five boys, had 'never worked a day in her life.' It took a day for Rosen to finally acknowledge that her comments were ...

posted 4:22:07pm Apr. 13, 2012 | read full post »

An Ungrateful Karzai Calls American Troops Demons
Hamid Karzai recently called the brave and selfless members of the United States military ‘demons’ who were guilty of perhaps ‘500’ atrocities against the people of the Afghanistan. One would have thought that the American ...

posted 5:21:39pm Mar. 19, 2012 | read full post »

Jews Must Demand Relationship of Equality with Christians
No Holds Barred: It is high time that our warm allies in the Mormon Church cease the posthumous baptizing of any and all Jews. My much-publicized dispute with Canadian TV host Michael Coren last week taught me valuable lessons about the ...

posted 4:39:41pm Feb. 28, 2012 | read full post »

The Michael Coren Christians Who Cowardly Deny Church History
I came on to Michael Coren’s TV show in Canada to simply talk about my new book Kosher Jesus, which has received wide attention throughout the world. I left dazed, having heard from him that Jews refuse to appreciate Christians, depict them ...

posted 4:03:50pm Feb. 24, 2012 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.