Prayer, Plain and Simple

Prayer, Plain and Simple


Who can “Bless” the Bread and Wine?

posted by Mark Herringshaw

Earlier today someone posted a comment on the blog topic I’ve been calling “The Eucharist Diet” – a day to day report of my practice of taking daily communion and the corresponding results on my weight. I thought this question was worth highlighting and addressing:  

“Hi. I’ve been following your efforts with great interest. I recently gained around 5 pounds over the holidays (and would prefer to be 10 pounds lighter, actually, for better blood pressure control) and I’d love to do what you’re doing. But I’m a lay person, not a pastor like you are. (I’m not Roman Catholic so I don’t believe in actual transubstantiation, but I do believe that Christ’s presence enters into the sacrament when it’s blessed in church. I believe this is a pastoral function.) What do you suggest I do instead?”

Yes, the “lay/clergy” question: How can someone not an ordained minister “administer” the sacraments in communion?  

I speak here from my own opinion and theological perspective. I know for many of you my answers will not suffice because your own theologies discourage or forbid partaking of communion in unauthorized settings. So take this with a grain of salt…

I (like the commenter) am not Catholic and I do not hold to a doctrine of transubstantiation. For Catholics there is no real way around this position and celebrating communion outside the sanction of the Church is impossible. For Catholics the option for a “Eucharist Diet” could be 1) go to mass regularly or even every day, or 2) take wine or juice and bread on your own and see it as a symbolic representation (and nothing more) of the real Eucharist, without interpreting it as the actual substance.

The rest of us have other options: As a Lutheran pastor I believe (like the reader) in a “real presence” of Jesus in the bread and the wine. This is not the same as transubstantiation nor is it akin to the representation view of traditional evangelicals, who see communion as a symbol only. Evangelicals might try a “Eucharist Diet” (they should have no issue doing this at home on their own) as a “picture” of what Jesus has done and could invite Jesus at this time to “fill” them with spiritual food accordingly…

That said, again, I do believe in a “real presence” of Jesus in the bread and the wine.  I believe that what brings this power of Jesus into the elements themselves is a combination of faith and the Words of God, specifically the words that Jesus himself spoke at the Last Supper:

For I received from the Lord what I also passed on to you: The Lord Jesus, on the night he was betrayed, took bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke it and said, “This is my body, which is for you; do this in remembrance of me.” In the same way, after supper he took the cup, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood; do this, whenever you drink it, in remembrance of me.” For whenever you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes (I Corinthians 11:23-26).

I believe it isn’t WHO speaks these words that matters, but the words themselves as coming from Jesus, and my faith which takes those words seriously. I think a child could read these words and the bread and wine would still deliver the presence of Jesus.

Relationships metter too. Communion is intended to be shared with other believers. At times I’ll have communion alone, but generally I believe it should be shared. Still. it’s the message not the messenger that matters. There’s nothing special or sacred about ME as an ordained minister, just something special about the WORD I – or anyone else – might speak in relation to the wine and bread…

Again, take this for what it’s worth in your own theological context. If you have “allergy” to doing communion in your own home, then do it simply as a representational event and ask God to make it more for you himself. 



  • Norma

    It is my belief that anyone may administer the Lord’s supper. Many people belief that one must be a minister yet there are those who do not attend a church at all but their hearts are still with God.
    Let’s also remember that the church has suffered a mighty blow from
    people like Jim Jones and have difficulty trusting clergy.
    Jesus said as often as you do this you show forth my death and suffering until I come again. It’s like telling someone how to praise
    God He honors it in sincerity and they’re not praising me so who am I
    to deny anything done to the glory of God.

  • Your Name

    Thank you for so thoughtfully answering my question. I am Episcopalian.
    I like your perspective and the idea of the Eucharist diet. I went on one Catholic person’s website who had a spiritual diet, and although he had some other lovely prayers, one of his recommendations was “Imagine yourself in Purgatory where every unnecessary mouthful of food you have ever taken will be purged from you as flaming vomit. Now reduce the anxiety with relaxation”
    I don’t believe in purgatory anyway, but the idea of NEGATIVE reinforcement of weight loss in this way made me cringe!
    Thank you for your lovely chronicle of your Eucharist Diet. And I totally believe that by enjoying yourself at things like wedding receptions with prime rib, makes one non-deprived, which makes it easier to find something like cheesecake unappealing.
    Thanks again.

  • Steven Tanner

    Thank you for such a wonderful answer. I am new to Christ (6 months actually) and do not have a home Church, in fact I am planning a big move where I intend to simplify my life and live more in the Lord. I do intend to find a Church when moved to take communion when I feel the need to do it in a Church, but due to the nature of the more solitary existance I plan I want to take daily communion myself and wanted to know if that is viable.
    Can you tell me, the prayer mentioned to consecrate the bread and wine, are they the only prayers I would need, or are there any other words that need to be said? As I said, I am a new Christian and have only experienced communion once, but found it so powerful I would love to make it a daily part of my life.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Toni

    Very well said, I could not have said it better myself, as far as being catholic, we are not to go thru any one else to get to God but thru Jesus. So just saying, I do read the Bible also, there are some great prayers to follow. I say the Lords Prayer a lot, and others found for healing.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment L Davis

    what are the words or prayers prayed over the bread and wine (the blessing) prior to the holly communion? please

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Paulo

    Thank you for giving me valuable reassurance on Blessing the Body & Blood of Jesus Christ!

Previous Posts

Learning How to Live in the Moment
"Continue steadfastly in prayer, being watchful in it with thanksgiving."   ~Colossians 4:2 "Mom and Dad," said our son one day last year when we were visiting him in Santa Barbara where he was attending college, "I think you guys are great, but it seems like you're always talking about the futu

posted 8:43:16am Aug. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Search Me. Giving Your Heart a Fresh Start Daily
Search me, Oh God and know my heart. Test me and know my anxious thoughts.  See if there be any offensive way in me, And lead me in the way everlasting. ~King David, Psalm 139 Something was smelly in our fridge the past week, and try as I may, I couldn't find it. Hiding on a shelf in the door

posted 8:19:25am Aug. 20, 2014 | read full post »

A Prayer For Anyone Getting Engaged
Thirty-two years ago today Mark took me to a small lake near my home in Minnesota where he bent on one knee and pulled out a ring and put it on my finger. We were so young and so happy. For many years we experienced much joy in our relationship. Then we hit some bumps and jolting potholes in the

posted 11:59:54am Aug. 12, 2014 | read full post »

The Path of Peace - Taking Steps Toward Intimacy with God
Psalm 95 Come, let us sing to the Lord! Let us shout joyfully to the Rock of our salvation. Let us come to him with thanksgiving. Let us sing psalms of praise to him. For the Lord is a great God, a great King above all gods. He holds in his hands the depths of the earth and the might

posted 12:06:16pm Aug. 11, 2014 | read full post »

A Prayer to Maintain the Mind of Christ
"The Lord knows people's thoughts; he knows they are worthless." Psalm 94:11 A Penny for Your Thoughts... Most of our thoughts aren't worth a nickel. The Lord knows our thoughts, and unfortunately most of the time we must bore Him silly. Our thoughts are often uninspiring; they are often untrue,

posted 10:46:16am Aug. 08, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.