On the Doorposts of My House

On the Doorposts of My House


The cost of a CT Scan (or why we value being out of debt more than our own health)

posted by Malachi Kosanovich

X-Ray: $800

CT Scan: $4,300

Emergency Room visit: $1,200

Total: $6,300

These are just estimates. And they don’t cover the IV fluids, the two injections of morphine, the anti-nausea medicine, or the urine testing. They don’t include the five to seven minutes that the doctor was in the room poking to see if he could feel something wrong. Let’s add those in as another estimated $4,000. That puts the total for a four hour visit to the ER at $10,300. Bills like that can take years, and often decades to pay off—it’s not particularly surprising that over 60% of U.S. bankruptcies are prompted by medical debt.

Perhaps I also shouldn’t be surprised that so many people choose to live with pain rather than go to the doctor. As the healthcare debate rages on, I have to wonder: How did Americans come to value being out of debt more than our own health? How did we come to live in a society where people must routinely choose between living in financial ruin or crippling pain?

Judaism teaches us that the preservation and nurturing of human life is among the highest moral obligations a person has. This is inscribed as the principle of Pikuach Nefesh (saving of human life), which overrides virtually all other religious considerations. Indeed, we are commanded to break Shabbat if it is necessary to heal the sick or otherwise protect life.

I doubt that there are many of us who would ignore this principle if someone else was involved. If we were to see a child in danger, we would certainly break Shabbat to save her. And our culture accords high status to police officers, firefighters, and other professionals who put themselves at risk in order to save the lives of others. Why then, are we so reluctant to save our own lives? Why are our own lives worth risking in order to avoid the crushing debt of medical bills? I don’t know the answers to these questions. What I do know is that I am deeply ashamed. I am ashamed to live in a society where people are more concerned about medical bankruptcy than about their most basic healthcare needs. I am ashamed to live in the only industrialized society that does not provide basic healthcare for all its citizens—a society in which there is such a thing as medical bankruptcy.

We are commanded to care for each other. Again and again, the Torah teaches us that we must feed the hungry, dress the poor, and care for widows and children. How can we pretend to be living into the will of God when we are fighting over who should pay for healthcare while people suffer in order to avoid the burden of medical bills?

I ask these questions because this was the situation I found myself in early Monday morning. I work more than full-time. I pay my taxes. And I am also one of the 50 million Americans who are uninsured (90 million if you count those with inadequate insurance). So, when I woke up in excruciating pain, I tried to wait it out. When my throat got sore from screaming, I was faced with a choice: ruin my finances by going to the hospital, or stay home and hope that I did not become one of the nearly 100,000 people that die each year from lack of medical care (more than from AIDS and breast cancer combined) in the U.S. Over the last few days, I have experienced the worst physical pain of my life, but that pain is nothing compared with the knowledge that so many others in my situation view lying in bed and “toughing it out” as their best option.

God calls us to be partners in the creation of a just and compassionate world.God calls us to care for the widow, the needy, the bereaved, and the poor. God calls us to care for ourselves, as we are each a piece of the Divine image in the world. How can we even begin to live out this calling, when we cannot value of the health of our neighbor? How can we value the Divine image of God when we cannot even value our own health?



Advertisement
Comments read comments(4)
post a comment
Malachi Kosanovich

posted November 30, 2011 at 9:26 pm


Thank you for asking. I am doing well.



report abuse
 

Zebulun

posted November 29, 2011 at 3:45 pm


How are you doing now, Malachi?

I won’t pretend to understand the cult of individuality of this culture we live in. I prefer to be “left alone” as much as any libertarian, but at the same time, I think it is inhumane to place any economic issue above the need for universal healthcare.



report abuse
 

Malachi Kosanovich

posted November 2, 2011 at 2:57 am


CX — I am not ignoring all of those things. They are very real concerns. But i think they are all concerns that come out of the same problem. If I go to the hospital and rack up a 10,000$ bill, then I can’t eat; I can’t buy Hanukkah presents for the people I love; I can’t have electricity, or heat, or air conditioning. I believe they all stem out of the same concern. If a person is uninsured, then the choice is between pain and medical bills — and if one opts for medical bills, then one may have to sacrifice all of the things you mentioned.



report abuse
 

cx

posted October 30, 2011 at 11:24 am


I’m sorry to hear of your pain. I hope you find health again.

However, you’re looking at the problem a little bit wrong.

It’s not “medical bankruptcy”.

Rather, it’s not being able to afford enough food.
It’s not having semi-dependable transportation to get to work in.
It’s not having a place of your own.
It’s not having the money to afford a Christmas present for your spouse, or worse, your children.
It’s not having electricity, or heat, or air conditioning.
It’s falling farther and farther down the hell that separates you from the people who do no work on TV, yet apparently have $200,000 incomes.
How much pain would you willingly suffer for those issues?

As I keep pointing out to friends who don’t seem to have the capacity to care for the less-fortunate among us, the US is the only civilized, industrialized nation who hates its citizens sufficiently to deny them effective medical care, who prefers to see them die or become impoverished, rather than assist in keeping them healthy and whole.



report abuse
 

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Previous Posts

Another blog to enjoy!!!
Thank you for visiting On The Doorposts of My House. This blog is no longer being updated. Please enjoy the archives. Here is another blog you may also enjoy: Tattooed Jew Happy Reading!!!

posted 6:48:10pm Jul. 06, 2012 | read full post »

Minyan
So I'm having this conversation on Facebook with a very dear friend. It started with his news that he no longer counted as a Jew for the purposes of a minyan. For those who don't know, a minyan is a group of ten Jews who have gathered for the purposes of prayer. Issues surrounding who is eligible

posted 3:54:03am Dec. 18, 2011 | read full post »

Dear Mitt Romney
Dear Mitt Romney, I’ve heard you are having money troubles. After all, if the best thing you can think of to do with 10,000 dollars is make a bet with someone on television, then clearly you aren’t getting creative with ways to invest your money. I thought perhaps you could use a little help

posted 3:57:35pm Dec. 12, 2011 | read full post »

Prayers for healing
One of the strangest parts of my job is the completely transitory nature of the relationships I build. Sure, every bar has it's regulars. They keep the bar going. But for the most part, people come in and out. You see them once or twice, while they are in town, and then they disappear. Because of wh

posted 9:00:00pm Nov. 30, 2011 | read full post »

A reading list for the rest of us
Recently, the Huffington Post ran an article on the 18 texts every Jew should read. While it was a fascinating article and filled with wonderful texts, it had a few flaws that should not be overlooked. Most of the authors were men. Almost all of the books are religious in nature. Few of the books me

posted 9:52:49pm Nov. 02, 2011 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.