O Me of Little Faith

O Me of Little Faith

Conversions: Fundamentalist Christian to Non-Religious Spirituality

Today’s conversion story is from Christy, who due to the nature of her experience and family situation (keep reading) has requested that I not use her last name.

Christy transitioned from a fundamentalist Christian childhood to a socially active, progressive evangelical faith during the college years…and then to a current category she describes as “spiritual but not religious.” In an email, she told me that, in terms of personal theology, she now “could fall quite nicely into the Unitarian Universalist or unprogrammed Quakers camp.”



I live in Los Angeles with my dog Lulu. I’m a freelance grant-writing and fund-development consultant for small and start-up non-profits, with aspirations of writing things that don’t involve asking someone for money.


Please describe your conversion experience or process:

The overview version is that I was raised Christian, of the right-wing fundamentalist variety, in the Bible Belt in a family that went to church three times a week. I became a highly committed, move to the inner city, save-the-world evangelical in college and throughout my twenties. I was an intern for an urban ministry in college, was a youth pastor intern for about three years in a predominantly Mexican immigrant community, worked in a variety of non-profits (faith-based and not), and went to grad school and studied community organizations and urban poverty.

I started moving away from Christianity in my thirties, and for lack of a better term, I’d put myself in the “spiritual but not religious” category now. I feel weird referring to myself as a “non-Christian” because I don’t want to be defined by what I’m not, and it would be disingenuous of me to pretend that I wasn’t formed by three decades of being a Christian, and much of the fourth one engaged in the world’s slowest de-conversion.


However, at this point, I’ve jettisoned original sin, hell, and two members of the Trinity (God the Father and Jesus in case you want to know which two). I don’t even go to church on Christmas and Easter anymore. I still find the Bible alternately fascinating, horrifying and wise, but I don’t think it’s inerrant, infallible or inspired any more than any other sacred text. I don’t even exactly pray — I meditate and “hold things in the Light” because it felt right when the Quakers said it. As far as dogma goes, I’m down to meditation and yoga and trying to be grateful and live with compassion and believing in the Divine — but my conception of that is very different from the Christian idea of a personal God.


The questions I’m interested in right now are these: Do I care about other people and at least try to treat them with respect? Am I making some sort of effort to do some good in the world? Am I trying to live my life with integrity and compassion? Am I connecting with the Divine the best way I know how? Everything else feels peripheral.

What events led to your conversion?

My conversion was more like coming out of the closet than changing my mind. I didn’t “lose my faith” or “fall away” or any of those other terms — it was very slow and intentional and a lot of hard work. I know it will seem like I’m burying the lead here, but I was sexually abused for nine years as a child and adolescent by my father and a youth pastor, and beginning to deal with that was the cataIyst for a new kind of spiritual journey for me.


It wasn’t the sexual abuse itself that made me convert. Actually, the self-hatred that resulted from it was what kept me in the fold for so long. I always felt like I was morally defective and God hated me, and I didn’t have the right to explore other options.

The truth is, evangelical Christianity never worked for me. Even though I’m a lifer, it always felt like there was some secret handshake to get in the club that I didn’t know about. I had an absolutely tortured relationship with church even when I worked at one. I could never find myself in the “Sinner meets Jesus, Hallelujah!” narrative. In Bible studies, I was always the freak who disagreed. I felt awkward praying aloud, and felt guilty that I could never seem to generate the warm and fuzzy love for Jesus that so many worship songs talked about. Mostly, it felt like that path was the only way to connect with God, and I had to keep trying, so my primary spiritual experience was one of feeling alienated from God. (This is why I was always good with the angry kids in youth ministry.)


I was also highly emotionally dysfunctional, miserable and depressed, and expended a tremendous amount of energy trying to hide it, and pretend I was okay. Eventually, I couldn’t pretend anymore and all that stuff I’d locked in my basement started pounding on the door and saying, “Hi, we’re here, and we will not be ignored.”

I started therapy (which I should have done MUCH sooner than I did), and when I had started to do some healing, I realized that it was okay to say, “This is not working. It has never worked, and it’s okay for me to leave and find my path elsewhere.” Everything that helped — yoga, mindfulness, feminist theology, embracing my body and my sexuality, and a lesbian therapist — took me farther away from evangelicalism and Christianity. It was a slow, messy, and excruciating process, but at the end of it, I found myself here — and here is a good place to be.


What kind of impact did your conversion have on your friends and family?

I was working at a Christian college at the time this process really started in earnest, which is one of your more awkward locations to come out of the closet about your heretical tendencies. At one point, near the end, I flunked their statement of faith, and decided to quit my job, which felt very much like officially handing in my evangelical membership card.

Family is a long story with no happy ending, and I have had some awkward reconnections with friends I hadn’t seen in a long time. However, every single one of my evangelical friends who was in my life when I started going through this process is still my friend. Every. Single. One. And they support me. They really like my entirely non-religious boyfriend, and they don’t try to get me to go back to church or see the light or anything. If they are praying for my soul, they aren’t telling me about it. Some of that is because my friends are good people. Some of them have been through their own internal revolutions. Mostly, though, it’s hard to argue with the dramatic transformation in my life over the past 6 or 7 years. I am SO much healthier, happier, and at peace.


I try to respect their spiritual path as well. That’s challenging for me sometimes, because my experience in the church was a very painful one, but it would be poor repayment of their friendship if I didn’t at least try to support them the way they have supported me.

I turn 40 in a few weeks, and I’ve been struck by how radically different 40 is than 30. I’m excited about this next phase of my journey, and so, so grateful to be in this spot. I have bad days and some scars, of course — we all do — but I don’t hate myself anymore. I don’t struggle just to hold it together. All of my close friendships are better than they were. The Divine is there and She doesn’t hate me. To borrow a phrase from the tradition of my youth, I feel born again.


What advice would you give someone going through the same experience or contemplating a similar conversion?

My process was so closely tied to working through the sexual abuse and family dynamics, that I’m not sure what to say to someone else — other than that I sincerely hope your experience is a whole lot less painful than mine.

Particularly if you’re a lifer like me, it can be scary to leave a sub-culture, and maybe even a job that is familiar — not to mention the relationship fallout from family and friends — but you will never go wrong being honest with yourself and others about what you believe — and what you don’t.

However, be selective about who you share your process with. Major internal changes can be disorienting and painful, and you want to make sure that you have safe people to walk with you through the deconstruction and rebuilding process, who will support you rather than judge you. (This is when you find out who your friends really are.)


Once you have a sense of where you’re headed and you feel more solid, you will be better able to handle friends and family’s potential negative reactions. (Although they may surprise you and be more accepting and non-judgmental than you think.)

What are three things you have learned in the process?

1. The deepest truth about me is not that I am broken — it’s that I’m good.
2. Compassion, both for yourself and others, is always a good idea.
3. I was at a conference once where Naomi Wolf spoke, and she said this: “The next time you are tempted to swallow your truth, try speaking it instead. Everything you are afraid of will happen, but eventually you will fall in love with the sound of your own integrity.” I have found that statement to be completely true.



Thank you, Christy. For similar reasons of anonymity, I won’t list any social media links. But I do appreciate her willingness to share her spiritual journey in this forum.

Previous conversion interviews:

Ryan Hadley: Christian to Atheist
David Johndrow: Congregational Church to Charismatic Episcopalian
Jeremy Myers: From Senior Pastor to Church Dropout
Mike Wise: Christian to Agnostic to Christian
Jessica Gavin: Universalist to Seventh-Day Adventist
Torie Brown Hunt: From Southern Baptist to Mormon


Comments read comments(7)
post a comment

posted March 18, 2011 at 8:44 am

Christy, thank you for sharing your story. I’m on a eerily similar road, though a few years behind you. Raised in a right-wing Fundamentalist environment, I did the earnest Evangelical thing in my 20’s. Rather, I tried to do it, but, as you describe, there was always a feeling of alienation and dishonesty. I ended up in a Calvinistic environment for awhile and started to wonder if my problem was that I wasn’t one of the “elect.” I felt so guilty about the dishonesty but was too afraid (and too self-doubting) to do anything about it. However, last year a major life-changing event caused me to lose a lot of the fear that was keeping me quiet.
I’ve used the coming out of the closet comparison many times. It’s been a slow process, and I still have no idea where I’ll end up. Some days I think I’ll fight hard to keep essential Christian beliefs and some days I think that will be impossible. There are days when I’m very, very frightened, but I know that I have to be honest.
Anyway, thanks again for being courageous enough to tell your story. You’ve given me hope this morning.

report abuse


posted March 18, 2011 at 8:57 am

It saddens me greatly how the church (or more directly, the people comprising the church which is basically the same thing but… I digress) has damaged so many people. I am pretty sure it saddens God as well. I am a firm believer in Jesus and His redemption and salvation but I am also a firm believer that whenever we get outside the commandment of “love God, love people” we screw up. If we would just focus on the essentials and not get bogged down in the non-essentials (and, worse, beat each other about the head with our non-essential playbooks) and just love people, we would see Jesus work in a mighty, pure way. Lord, teach me to love…

report abuse

Janet Oberholtzer

posted March 18, 2011 at 9:37 am

Christy … great piece. Like the writing … and your thoughts. Some are similar to mine, but I couldn’t have put them into words like you did.
Sorry for all the pain you’ve gone through – that sucks. So grateful to hear of the joy in your life today. This line says it all, especially the peace part … “I am SO much healthier, happier, and at peace.”
Love this advice … “you will never go wrong being honest with yourself” and “be selective about who you share your process with.”
I’ve gone through one major belief change and now I’m in the middle of another one (seems to be a theme I can’t get away from) Leaving the strict traditional Mennonite boxes of my childhood in my earlier 20’s was confusing and a challenge at first, but then brought freedom and peace … for a time.
In my late 30’s, I got tired of pretending I was okay in the conservative evangelical community I had become a part of and began pulling away a little. Then about 7 years ago (age 38) personal trauma hit … and recovery from that threw everything into a hurricane for a time. Now I finally feel strong enough to be honest with myself and I’m finally asking all the questions I’d stored up for years. I don’t know where my spiritual journey will end up … but I might be fighting you for the “world’s slowest conversion or de-conversion” title.
Happy 40th!
(I’m 5 years ahead of you and glad to see that I’m not the only one over 30 still going through major faith/belief changes)

report abuse


posted March 18, 2011 at 3:14 pm

JK –
I’m glad it helped. I know I wish I could have had someone outside the ‘gellie world to talk to a few years ago. It might have made it easier. I know there was a point in my life where not being a Christian felt unimaginable, but then I got here, and it’s okay. Which is not to say that you will land where I did, but if you keep being honest, you’ll be okay.
Janet –
Personal trauma seems to be a HUGE factor in the lives of both me and people that I know who have made major spiritual shifts – either into or out of Christianity. Something about major pain seems to make all those questions we didn’t ask ourselves impossible to ignore. And I am also glad to see someone else over 30 going through major belief changes – makes me feel less emotionally and spiritually arrested.

report abuse

Pingback: Conversions: From Contemporary Worship to Liturgy - O Me of Little Faith


posted April 6, 2011 at 11:00 pm

Great post. I recently pulled away from the Christian faith, or I guess I should say I’ve tried to pull away from it. Right wing fundamentalism reminds me of the Molasses Swamp in Candy land, it’s hard to get out of. Anyway, I haven’t gone to church in four years, don’t read the bible anymore(small b) and I enjoy a secular lifestyle. I’ve spent alot of time reading and researching to find out just where the bible and the Christian religion comes from. I’m glad I found my way out of it.
Right now I am struggling with going home to visit my family. They are all extreme pentecostal right wingers. I still love them and have not seen them in four years but I still don’t know if I’m ready to go back there quite yet. When I say extreme I mean they believe in prophesying over people, even if it’s inside your local Starbuck’s. I am almost positive that they think I am demon posessed because I’m no longer a Christian. I’m also pretty sure that if I go home they’ll back me into a corner and force prophesy over me and try some kind of excorcism on me.

Sometimes I find myself daydreaming about them and I can see their faces and we’re all talking again and having fun. But I know if I went back now they would just gang up on me and try to manipulate me or try some brainwashing technique to get me to come back. I’m not ready to face them yet. Maybe I’ll just tell them that if they want to see me they can get a plane ticket and come to my house. At least they won’t be able to corner me or bully me into something that I don’t believe in. It breaks my heart to see what religion can do to some people.

report abuse


posted January 1, 2015 at 1:36 pm

Jesus, God, the bible are created by narcisstic male species, the negative dark energy for sex, power, and control.
The real God is a female, her name is Mother Earth, Mother Nature, that has the real ability to create as a plant, as an animal, as a human, she has the power of birth, regenerate, an even virgin birth without being rape or sexual contact with male. The dark energy male ego knows about it, and claim that such virgin birth was Jesus, thats bollocks. Study virgin birth and you will know even the gecko lizards could give birth without a male, It is the egotistic male that created all these contradictory stories for century, for sex, for power, for abuse, for control, there is no such thing as a He Almight God nor The captal H is “son”

report abuse

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to and may be used by in accordance with the agreements.

Previous Posts

More blogs to enjoy!!!
Thank you for visiting O Me Of Little Faith. This blog is no longer being updated. Please enjoy the archives. Here are some other blogs you may also enjoy: Red Letters with Tom Davis Recent prayer post on Prayables Most Recent ...

posted 2:25:22pm Aug. 27, 2012 | read full post »

Farewell, O Me of Little Faith
You said you had a big announcement coming today. What is it? The announcement is this: Right now you are reading the final post on this blog. Ever. Ever? Ever. So you're shutting this blog down? Well, I'm going to stop writing ...

posted 6:11:49am Jun. 01, 2011 | read full post »

My Introvert Interview
On Monday, author Adam McHugh delivered a guest post about the "snarling 8-headed monster" of the writing process. Today I return the favor -- sort of -- via an interview at his blog, Introverted Church. We talk about how my introverted ...

posted 3:05:36pm May. 25, 2011 | read full post »

Harold Camping: "Invisible Judgment Day"
When the rapture didn't occur as predicted on May 21, 2011, Harold Camping had a few options. Here is how he could have responded to the failed prediction, in descending levels of crazy: 1. He could announce that he was wrong. This is the ...

posted 9:06:24am May. 24, 2011 | read full post »

The Phases of Writing (Adam McHugh)
If you've ever felt out of place among all the exciting, expressive, emotional enthusiasm of a contemporary church service...or an evangelist's demands that you need to constantly be sharing your faith boldly to strangers...if it simply wipes ...

posted 7:46:00am May. 23, 2011 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.