Movie Mom

Movie Mom


New Year’s Eve

posted by Nell Minow
C
Lowest Recommended Age:High School
MPAA Rating:Rated PG-13 for language including some sexual references
Profanity:Some strong language (one f-word and some s-words) and some crude words
Nudity/Sex:Sexual references and some crude comments about childbirth
Alcohol/Drugs:Alcohol, scene in a bar, some people get tipsy
Violence/Scariness:Comic peril, car crash
Diversity Issues:Diverse characters
Movie Release Date:December 9, 2011
DVD Release Date:May 1, 2012

Something seemed familiar to me as I watched Garry Marshall’s New York-based follow-up to his multi-star, multi-story LA-set romantic comedy, Valentine’s Day.  It was something that went beyond the predictability of its sitcom-ish formulas and check-list of romantic comedy conventions, and it finally hit me when the wonderful Sofía Vergara appeared on screen.  Part of what makes “Modern Family” so delightful is the way its characters address, tweak, and transcend the usual comedic stereotypes.  But it became sadly clear that all Marshall and screenwriter Katherine Fugate can think of to do with this beautiful and talented actress is make her into a caricatured Latina hot mama.  And that was when I figured it out.  She was Charo and we were on a big budget version of The Love Boat.  Like the television series that ran from the late 1970′s to the mid 1980′s, “New Year’s Eve” is an assortment of stories about love featuring a lot of big stars and with depth and imagination and sincerity that can only be measured with micrometers.

But that doesn’t mean that it is not entertaining, first for the fun of seeing so many stars cross the screen and second because so much is going on that the weakest parts are over before you realize how weak they are.  It would be quicker to list the stars who are not in this movie than those who are.  Oscar-winners Robert De Niro (as a terminally ill patient in the hospital), Halle Berry (as his nurse), and Hillary Swank (as the person in charge of the ball-dropping, Ryan Seacrest-led festivities in Times Square) are joined by Tony-winner Cherry Jones as owner of a music company, plus television luminaries Seth Meyers of “SNL” as an expectant father, Sarah Jessica Parker (as a wardrober who works with the Rockettes), and “Glee’s” Lea Michelle.  Then there’s “Little Miss Sunshine’s” Abigail Breslin in way too much mascara as a young teen who rebels when her mother says she cannot go to Times Square, rom-com princess Katherine Heigel as a caterer at a fancy party, rocker-turned-actor John Bon Jovi as a rock star, rapper-turned actor Common, and “High School Musical’s” Zac Efron as a delivery guy who delivers more than the mousy secretary played by Michelle Pfeiffer expects.  Returning “Valentine’s Day” stars (playing new characters) Ashton Kutcher is a guy who hates New Year’s Eve and gets stuck in an elevator and Jessica Biel is a woman who wants to have the first baby born in 2012 so she can win some money.  And Josh Duhamel is the guy who is trying to get back to Manhattan to find the mystery woman he kissed at midnight a year ago.  And we also get Hector Elizondo, of course, who is for Marshall what John Ratzenberger is to Pixar, a lucky charm who appears in every film and is always welcome.

It benefits from dropping some of the cruder elements that marred “Valentine’s Day” but even as a fairy tale it goes over the top with not one but two characters called on for impromptu televised appearances that has a tired, crowded, over-excited and tipsy New York audience aww-ing and applauding like parents at a kindergarten Christmas pageant.  All these people and situations leave no room for stories or characters, just snippets that barely have time to make an impression and the casting itself becomes a distraction with meaningless “wait, wasn’t that…?” appearances in the briefest of roles.  That’s just as well, as the stalled elevator and race to give birth at 12:01 do not have much to offer and the dialog has some syrupy lines about forgiveness and second chances that got unintended laughs from the audience.  Even at just a few moments, Duhamel’s efforts to get back into the city drag on too long with a pointless segment about an RV ride with a preacher’s family.  But by the time he makes it to his mystery date, though, we are on his side.  (Am I the only one who thought it was not a great match, though?)  As in the last film, there is poignant scene involving military fighting overseas.  Pfeiffer, Berry, and De Niro manage to create some genuinely touching moments out of sheer star power.  The outtakes over the credit sequence at the end are the best part, though they remind us how much more these stars are capable of.  A better title might be “Groundhog Day” because it sure feels like we’ve seen it all before.

Parents should know that this film has some sexual humor including a few crude terms and references to body parts and childbirth and some brief strong language (one f-word).  There is a sad parental death.  Characters drink alcohol.  A strength of this movie is that a first kiss is taken very seriously.

Family discussion: Which couple was the most interesting and why?  Which one surprised you the most?

If you like this, try: “Valentine’s Day” and some of the films featuring these stars like “Hairspray,” “Analyze This,” “Married to the Mob,” “Robots,” and “Transformers”



  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Mike

    I’m glad someone liked this movie because it is getting beat bad on Rotten Tomatoes.

    I enjoyed the music more than anything else, but when you aren’t keeping track of time, or at least trying to, that means something. I think it was pieced together well in terms of giving equal time to all the storylines. For the most part, the characters worked, and it was funny to see Lea Michele playing 90% of her character from “Glee”.

    • Nell Minow

      Thanks, Mike! It’s not a good movie but it is very watchable.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Cuchi cuchi

    Haha, I found this post by googling Sofia Vergara Charo after watching NYE, because she completely reminded me of her in this :D. Anyway, I agree, it’s not great but it is watchable. I found it pleasant fluff, and I really thought Marshall’s last attempt at this, Valentine’s Day, was very poor. It has some genuinely funny lines, which surprised me. :)

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Cuchi cuchi

    PS: your Love Boat comparison is genius :D

    • Nell Minow

      Thanks, Cuchi!

Previous Posts

Exclusive Clip: Alexander and the Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Day
We are thrilled to be the first to release this exclusive clip from next week's "Alexander and the Terrible Horrible No Good Very Bad Day," starring Steve Carell and Jennifer Garner, based on the classic book by Judith Viorst. [iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/Ok771vVu

posted 12:00:26pm Oct. 02, 2014 | read full post »

Join Me at the Hill Center for A Tribute to Mary Wickes -- Including An Exclusive Showing of Her "Mary Poppins"
I am so excited about this!  Steve Taravella, author of the wonderful Mary Wickes: I Know I've Seen That Face Before, and I will host an tribute to Wickes at DC's Hill Center on November 16, 2014. And we will present an exclusive showing of the very first production of "Mary Poppins," with Wickes

posted 8:00:34am Oct. 02, 2014 | read full post »

Trailer -- Exodus: Gods and Kings, The Story of Moses with Christian Bale
[iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/t-8YsulfxVI?rel=0" frameborder="0"] Christian Bale and Sir Ben Kingsley star in "Exodus: Gods and Kings," the story of Moses and the exodus of the Jews from Egypt. It opens this December.

posted 8:00:26pm Oct. 01, 2014 | read full post »

October 2014: Movies This Month
Happy October! This month is when we start to get the big, award-hopeful fall releases. Some of the highlights of what's ahead this month include: October 3: "Gone Girl," with Ben Affle

posted 3:42:45pm Oct. 01, 2014 | read full post »

The Inside Story of "The Princess Bride" by Cary Elwes: As You Wish
Fans of The Princess Bride, which means pretty much everyone, will love the new book from Cary Elwes (Wesley), who takes us behind the scenes for the inside story of the making of the film, from his nervous audition (his imitation of Fat Albert saved the day) to the most dedicated fans (one had "As

posted 8:00:44am Oct. 01, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.