Movie Mom

Movie Mom


Monte Carlo

posted by Nell Minow
B
Lowest Recommended Age:4th - 6th Grades
MPAA Rating:Rated PG for brief mild language
Profanity:Brief mild language ("hoochie," etc.)
Nudity/Sex:Kisses, brief reference to body image issues, college-age boy and girl travel together, oblique references to bad behavior
Alcohol/Drugs:Social drinking
Violence/Scariness:Some comic peril
Diversity Issues:None
Movie Release Date:July 1, 2011

It’s the Princess and the Pauper with Disney star Selena Gomez and two Gossip Girls in a story about a Texas waitress who takes the place of a selfish heiress in the glamorous title city. There’s also a touch of Cinderella (though the fairy godmother is unwitting). And it is filled with flouncy pretty dresses and bouncy pop songs to delight tween Disney channel fangirls.

Gomez plays Grace, a high school senior in Texas. She and her best friend Emma (Katie Cassidy) have been saving the tips from their waitress jobs and finally have enough to go to Paris. At the last minute, her mother and her new step-father insist that her step-sister Meg (Leighton Meester) go along. Grace and Meg have a strained relationship that quickly gets much more strained once they arrive. The hotel is dingy and cramped and the tour is brusque and rushed.

The girls are enjoying the top of the Eiffel Tower when they miss the tour bus and get caught in a downpour. When they duck into a luxury hotel for shelter, Grace is mistaken for a spoiled British heiress named Cordelia Winthrop Scott (also Gomez, clearly having much more fun as the imperious young woman with an accent like a “mean Mary Poppins”). Cordelia is supposed to be on her way to Monte Carlo for a fund-raiser to repair her reputation as a party girl. The girls overhear her telling a friend she will leave the hotel without checking out and decide Grace should take her place for one night, rationalizing that the room is already paid for. But one thing leads to another and soon the girls are in Monte Carlo, selecting designer clothes from Cordelia’s luggage so they can go to the ball and meeting charming princes.  Well, one is a prince and two are charming.

There’s also a zillion-dollar diamond and sapphire necklace that is not always where it is supposed to be.  And it turns out that Cordelia is scheduled to play polo.

“I like the way they come down the stairs,” sighed the 9-year old girl sitting next to me.  It doesn’t take much more to enchant the target audience than seeing the girls in their party dresses coming down the steps in slow motion on the way to the ball.  But this movie, thankfully gives us a little bit more. The girls each have enough of a personality and story to keep it from getting too silly but not enough to keep it from being a fairy tale, at least the kind that will make dreams come true for some tweens who are too often neglected by the people who make movies.

 

Parents should know that this film includes some bad behavior by teens (lying, stealing, leaving with a boy the girl does not know) with no real consequences.  It also has rare mild language, kisses, and a brief discussion of some body image issues.
Family discussion:  Would you do what Grace did?  What would be the best and worst parts?  Each of the girls learned a different lesson: what were they?  Did Cordelia learn anything?
If you like this, try: “What a Girl Wants” and older audience members should watch the classic Monte Carlo film glimpsed in the girls’ hotel room, “To Catch a Thief.”  And families will enjoy the original “Prince and the Pauper” with Errol Flynn.


  • http://www.dustinputman.com/reviews/m/11_montecarlo.htm Dustin Putman

    I am a little surprised by your review, Nell. I thought this film was appalling in the kinds of messages it sent out to its target audience. For me, it suggested that boys are the most important thing in a girl’s life. And the girls..my lord…the crimes they commit throughout without any sort of consequence at the end. Tying someone up in a chair and lodging an apple in their mouth might have been played for a laugh, but it was just creepy to me. I could go on, but my review expands on the topic. There was some really troublesome stuff going on that went beyond frothiness and the pleasure of watching girls in stolen ball gowns walking in slow-motion down the stairs.

    • Nell Minow

      Good points, Dustin, though Emma’s decision to go on the trip when her boyfriend didn’t want her to and Grace’s volunteer work made it clear, I thought, that while boys are important it was at least equally important to have a sense of independence, adventure, and purpose. I liked Emma’s response to the prince and Grace’s decision to come clean as well.

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment emerald

    Monte Carlo 2 please.

Previous Posts

Join Me at Ebertfest!
I'll be at Ebertfest through Sunday and will update when I can.  Tonight I'll be at the opening event, a screening of "Life Itself," the crowd-funded documentary about festival founder, Roger Ebert. [youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWLVD9g4SZU[/youtube]

posted 3:59:08pm Apr. 23, 2014 | read full post »

Trailer: The Normal Heart
Larry Kramer's searing, Tony award-winning play "The Normal Heart" is coming to HBO with an all-star cast. [iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/XMN75Opf1_A" frameborder="0"]

posted 8:00:57am Apr. 23, 2014 | read full post »

The Top 100 Animated Films of All Time: The Animators Pick
Time Out New York asked top animators to pick the greatest 100 animated films of all time.  All the Disney, Pixar, and Miyazaki classics are there, plus some surprises.  I have some disagreements, but am entirely in favor of the #1 pick. [youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iAykOz1gWi4[/you

posted 3:59:23pm Apr. 22, 2014 | read full post »

Interview: Daniel Licht, Composer of "Dexter"
Daniel Licht composed the music for "Dexter" as well as two of the "Silent Hill" video games and films including "Permanent Midnight" and "Stephen King's Thinner."  He talked to me about the difference between composing for thrillers and comedy and why he hit his guitar with a frying pan. Tell m

posted 8:00:40am Apr. 22, 2014 | read full post »

Happy Earth Day! Movies About Our Planet
Celebrate Earth Day with some of these great films about our planet, its beauties and its challenges: 1. An Inconvenient Truth Al Gore's Oscar-winning documentary makes a powerful case for the dire effects of climate change -- and an even more powerful case for our ability to prevent more damage

posted 7:00:55am Apr. 22, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.