Movie Mom

Movie Mom


Nanny McPhee Returns

posted by Nell Minow
C
Lowest Recommended Age:4th - 6th Grades
MPAA Rating:Rated PG for rude homor, some language, and mild thematic elements
Profanity:Some crude schoolyard language
Nudity/Sex:None
Alcohol/Drugs:None
Violence/Scariness:References to wartime violence and apparent tragic death of a father, bomb dropped on home, parental divorce, comic peril and violence
Diversity Issues:None
Movie Release Date:August 20, 2010

For the first half of this movie, the children in the audience were completely on board, laughing when the children on screen were covered with mud and various kinds of animal poop, delighting in seeing them naughtily fighting with each other and then, when Nanny McPhee (screenwriter Emma Thompson) stamps her magical staff on the floor, each fighting himself. By the time the piglets were doing an Esther Williams-style synchronized swim number, the kids in the theater were extremely happy.

And then something happened that took the movie in another direction and the audience enthusiasm evaporated. This sequel to the 2006 original places the character inspired by Christianna Brand’s Nurse Matilda stories in a WWII setting as Isabel Green (Maggie Gyllenhaal) is trying to keep the family farm going with the help of her three children while her husband is fighting in the war. It is quite a struggle, especially because her brother-in-law is doing everything he can to make her fail so she will have to sell the farm. He has to pay his gambling debts or, two female enforcers tell him, they will remove his liver. Isabel also has to care for her niece and nephew, sent out of London to keep them away from the bombing during the Blitz. They are snobbish and selfish and there is an instant war between the cousins.

Enter Nanny McPhee, all in black, with a body like a linebacker, two enormous moles, a snaggletooth, a jowly chinline, and a bulbous nose. She explains she has been sent by the Army and she goes to work, banging her staff and bringing on the magic to teach the children five lessons. When she is not wanted but needed, she must stay. When she is wanted but not needed, she must go.

Nanny McPhee teaches the children to stop fighting and to share and cooperate. But then things get much worse when they get some very bad news and they must show resolve, courage, and faith before she will be no longer needed.

The movie is very uneven in tone and in quality, with charming nonsense colliding with what appears to be devastating tragedy. Children young enough to enjoy the silly pratfalls will be uncomfortable and possibly upset by discussions of death, war, and divorce. There is something jarring, even in a fantasy film, about children having to defuse a bomb as the adults are helpless. The timing is off so that even some of the comic set-pieces fail, like an extended bit about disappearing pens and a gruesome all-female hit squad who wander in like extras from “Sweeny Todd.” Thompson is always magic on screen, but here she is more wanted than needed.



  • Chee

    When she is needed but not wanted, she must go.
    Did you mean to say when she is wanted but not needed? Haha to be honest, Nell, I reread that a few times and scratched my head. Could that count as typo 3 if I wasn’t wrong? :)
    And I’m a bit saddened to see a C for Nanny Mcphee. I loved the first one and was considering the sequel just for Emma Thompson, as she’s always too wonderful to pass up.

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    Yes, Chee, that counts! Only seven more to go. I love Emma Thompson, too, and she is always a pleasure to watch. As you are not likely to be bothered by the plot twists I find too disturbing for kids, you should go — and let me know if you think I was too harsh!

  • granny

    Took my 5yr and 7yr. granddaughters to see Nanny Mc Phee last night. We loved it! I tho’t it moved along better than the first. Finally a good ol’ fashioned family movie! Let their imaginations work with their feet still on the ground. I give it an A.

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    Thanks, granny! Glad to hear you and the kids enjoyed the movie.

  • Tim1974

    My daughters and I had an opportunity to see this and we all enjoyed it. It seemed that the children around us wwere enjoying it and I heard some favorable comments from adults on the way out. I think if you realize going in that this is a movie where anything is possible, you will just enjoy it for what it is- a good, fun family film.
    I do have a question though. Do you know why the title was changed from
    “Nanny McPhee and the Big Bang ?” Thanks

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    Thanks, Tim. I am glad you and your family enjoyed the film. “Nanny McPhee and the Big Bang” was the UK title. I don’t know why they changed it in the US.

Previous Posts

Contest: "Lullaby" -- Family Drama With Amy Adams, Richard Jenkins, and Garrett Hedlund
Garrett Hedlund stars as Jonathan in this uneven but moving drama about a family facing the loss of a husband and father. The performances are excellent, especially Richard Jenkins as the father and "Downton Abbey's" Jessica Brown Findlay as Jonathan's sister. I have two copies of the DVD to give

posted 3:50:33pm Jul. 25, 2014 | read full post »

Comic-Con 2014: Day One
Here's what's at Comic-Con, which means here's what's coming everywhere else: affordable 3D printers with hand-held scanners that transmit 360 degree images to your tablet or laptop instantly. GoPro

posted 11:08:17am Jul. 25, 2014 | read full post »

Remembering the Vietnam War: 10 Movies
As we observe the 50th anniversary of the War in Vietnam, here are ten of the best of the movie and documentary depictions of the war and its impact on history and culture in the United States. The best-known films about Vietnam include "Apocalypse Now," "Full Metal Jacket," "Platoon," "The Deer Hun

posted 8:00:34am Jul. 25, 2014 | read full post »

Lucy
I always enjoy Luc Besson's stylish car chases and shootouts. I like his use of locations, his strong female characters, and unexpected flashes of sentiment in the midst of mayhem.  While

posted 6:00:51pm Jul. 24, 2014 | read full post »

And So It Goes
A second marriage is, as Samuel Johnson famously said, "The triumph of hope over experience." And as lyricist Sammy Cahn wrote in the song Bing Crosby sang in "H

posted 6:00:13pm Jul. 24, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.