Movie Mom

Movie Mom


The Lovely Bones

posted by Nell Minow
C
Lowest Recommended Age:High School
MPAA Rating:Rated PG-13 for mature thematic material involving disturbing violent content and images, and some language
Profanity:Brief strong language
Nudity/Sex:Non-explicit marital sexual situation
Alcohol/Drugs:Drinking, smoking, character drinks and smokes too much
Violence/Scariness:Plot concerns a serial killer who preys on young girls, some violent and disturbing images
Diversity Issues:None
Movie Release Date:December 11, 2009
DVD Release Date:April 20, 2010

Peter Jackson, whose film versions of the “Lord of the Rings” trilogy could be a textbook example of how to adapt a literary work for screen, could find his latest film, “The Lovely Bones” as the example on the next page of how not to. His sincerity and artistry are there, but unlike Tolkien’s triology, Alice Sebold’s book-club favorite is not essentially cinematic. What made the book successful with critics and the public was not the story but the language. Jackson’s efforts to translate the graceful, lucid prose into images loses all of the story’s delicacy and becomes cloying and dissonant. Instead of a poetic meditation on life and the human spirit it becomes more like “CSI” if one of the detectives was dead.

As in the book, we know right from the beginning that Susie Salmon (Saoirse Ronan of “Atonement” and “I Could Never Be Your Woman”) is dead and telling us her story in a tone of calm, slightly distant regret. She was 14, the oldest daughter in a happy, loving family. She had a crush on a boy named Ray (Reece Ritchie). She and her father made meticulously constructed boats in bottles. And then, one night, walking home from school , a neighbor invites her to see a cool clubhouse he dug beneath the cornfields, filled with candles and snacks and board games. And he kills her.

In the movie’s best scene we and Susie both think that she has escaped the killer (Stanley Tucci) as she bursts out of the underground room and races through the streets. But then we realize just before she does that it is only her spirit that survives. Susie has been murdered. She will watch the rest of her story from a personal heaven, an in-between place for a soul that is not ready to let go.

But the lyricism of the book translates on screen into under-imagined images that look like stock photos used for screen savers or the discreet artwork of a mid-range hotel. Leafy trees, aquamarine skies, fluttering fields, and of course spa music (from Brian Eno) and quavery voice-overs.

Ronen is breathtaking, and Susan Sarandon adds some life as the boozy grandmother who steps in when the parents are devastated by Susie’s loss. The script softens the brutality of the story and irons out some of the sub-plots. But it gives us too much information about the less interesting parts of the story and not enough about what we really care about. But we are never sure whether we are there to see justice done or to put Susie’s soul to rest and by the time Susie meets up with her murderer’s other victims and returns to fulfill one last human longing, it feels more like a campfire ghost story than a meditation on love, loss and the enduring human spirit.



  • Concerned Mom

    Is it worth allowing an 11 and 13-year-old to see this movie to prevent this type of situation from happening to them or is it too graphic?

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    I do not think this film has any value as a cautionary tale for children. It is much more important for you to let them know that they do not have to be polite or do what adults say if it makes them uncomfortable.

  • monkie

    Based on your review, I don’t think I’d be interested in seeing the movie, but your description of the book sounded promising. I was wondering if you’d recommend it?

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    Yes, I would recommend the book, which is beautifully written and not maudlin.

  • blah

    Dear Nell,
    I appreciate your take on the film as both a mother and a critic.
    As a man who is neither (and who never read the source material), I thought “The Lovely Bones” was intensely moving, beautiful, tragic, and ultimately uplifting. My girlfriend and I watched it twice in a single sitting and found the story of her father and sister’s devotion, her friends’ belief and trust, and her killers’ comeuppance brilliantly rendered.
    Compared to “What Dreams May Come,” “Bones” comes off for us as less contrived, though both are delicious eye candy :)
    Thanks for your review!
    Blah.

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    I love this comment, blah! I am always glad to hear from someone who sees more in a movie than I do and a comment as thoughtful as this one will encourage me to give this film another chance. I agree that both movies are eye candy! All best to you and your girlfriend and I hope you will let me know what you think about the movies you see.

Previous Posts

Smile of the Week: The Dancing Traffic Light
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SB_0vRnkeOk[/youtube]

posted 8:00:15am Sep. 22, 2014 | read full post »

TrueSpark: Teaching Children and Teens About Character With Quality Films
I am honored to serve on the advisory committee for TrueSpark, which provides quality films and curricula for schools at no cost to use in teaching character. [iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/akEWIRfjnxk?rel=0" frameborder="0"] Parents and teachers who want to lear

posted 8:22:33pm Sep. 21, 2014 | read full post »

Interview: Genevieve Bailey of "I Am Eleven"
There's a reason that so many heroes and heroines of classic literature are eleven years old. It is that last magical moment at the cusp of childhood and adolescence, which is what makes it so fascinating and delightful. Genevieve Bailey remembered the year she was 11 as one of the happiest of her l

posted 8:09:47pm Sep. 21, 2014 | read full post »

Exclusive Clip -- Alpha and Omega: The Legend of the Saw Tooth Cave
Alpha and Omega are back! And we are lucky to have an exclusive clip. Runt, Kate and Humphrey's Omega wolf cub, sneaks off to explore the haunted Saw Tooth Cave. When Runt finds a wolf who's been driven from her pack for being different, he musters all his courage to help her, and learns the joys

posted 10:11:29am Sep. 21, 2014 | read full post »

The Best TV for Kids May Be Online
Children have more choices than ever on television, but some of the best viewing for kids is online. Common Sense Media has a great list of family-friendly YouTube stars. I'd add EvanTube to the list. Newsweek calls him The Most Popular Kid You've Never Heard Of, with 272 million views of his engagi

posted 3:59:29pm Sep. 20, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.