Movie Mom

Movie Mom

New In Town

posted by Nell Minow
Lowest Recommended Age:Middle School
MPAA Rating:PG for language and some suggestive material
Profanity:Strong language for a PG including b-word and other insults
Nudity/Sex:Some crude humor
Alcohol/Drugs:Comic drunkenness, drinking game, drinking to deal with stress, jokes about drinking
Violence/Scariness:Hunting, guns, gun accident but no one seriously hurt
Diversity Issues:A theme of the movie
Movie Release Date:January 30, 2009
DVD Release Date:May 26, 2009
Lowest Recommended Age: Middle School
MPAA Rating: PG for language and some suggestive material
Profanity: Strong language for a PG including b-word and other insults
Nudity/Sex: Some crude humor
Alcohol/Drugs: Comic drunkenness, drinking game, drinking to deal with stress, jokes about drinking
Violence/Scariness: Hunting, guns, gun accident but no one seriously hurt
Diversity Issues: A theme of the movie
Movie Release Date: January 30, 2009
DVD Release Date: May 26, 2009

Despite the title, there is nothing at all new about this romantic comedy, but it manages to endear itself anyway.

Renée Zellweger plays uptight and ambitious Lucy Hill, an ambitious, stiletto heel-wearing executive based in Miami who thinks she can get a promotion by taking on a new assignment to oversee the retrofitting and downsizing of a manufacturing plant in Minnesota. As she discovers over and over, she is clearer on the theory than the reality, starting with concepts like “cold” and “snow.” And “factory” and “downsizing.” Casual decisions about eliminating jobs are a lot easier when looking at budgets and bar charts, not people.


The people Lucy meets in the small town of New Ulm are straight from the Ma and Pa Kettle school of movie country folk: cute, quirky, corny, colorful, and sometimes cantankerous. They are given to expressions like “Oh, cry in my cheese-beer soup!” And of course there is the handsome single dad (Harry Connick, Jr. as Ted) with whom Lucy will have to get off on the wrong (stiletto-clad) foot before discovering an unexpected (only to her) connection.

What works here is the easy chemistry between the two leads (despite the distraction of whatever Zellweger has done to her face). While it may seem at first as though the film is making fun of the locals, it is Lucy who takes most of the literal and metaphoric pratfalls. The film shows an unusual level of respect in a mainstream film for the New Ulmers’ religious faith, sense of community, generosity, and resilience. Both sides have to adjust their assumptions and discard their prejudices, but making Lucy’s journey the steeper climb gives the story some added sweetness. There may be nothing new here, but like one character’s favorite recipe, sometimes bland can still be tasty.

  • Mike

    I was surprised this got a PG and I was wondering when I saw it two weeks ago if it was PG then. The kissing scene was slightly heavy for a PG, but you are right, kids don’t need to see this. This is directed at adults that want to laugh at a romantic comedy.

  • Michael

    Hi Nell,
    I know this has nothing to do with this movie but do you have reviews or comments for Slumdog Millionare and The Reader? Thanks.

  • Nell Minow

    Not yet, Michael. I am not always able to post reviews of all the movies I’d like to. I’ve seen both and thought they were outstanding and hope to be able to write something about them before the Oscars.

  • AKenjiB

    B? Seems way too easy. In my opinion, I thought this film was horrible. Worst film of 2009 that I’ve seen frankly. It’s so cliched, so dull, nothing interesting. Not very funny, not very fun, just boring and predictable.
    Although, i gotta say this is probably the most inappropriate PG film that I’ve seen.

  • Nell Minow

    Thanks, AKenjiB. I agree that the PG rating was not appropriate — I recommended it for middle schoolers and up. And I noted in the review that it was predictable. But I thought it was far from the worst film I saw this year. (Consider yourself very lucky you did not see “Miss March” or “Beth Cooper, I Love You.”) I liked the chemistry between the leads and the rare respectful portrayal of country people, especially people of faith. But I appreciate your comment, which will be very helpful to people who are looking for guidance about whether this film is right for them and their families.

  • AKenjiB

    Well, i have mostly avoided horrible films this year and i do agree that the chemistry was decent, but it was just too cliched to keep my interest.
    Fortunately I didn’t see Miss March or I love you, Beth Cooper.
    i wonder if the director was expecting a PG rating.

  • Nell Minow

    I strongly suspect they make a few edits to the film to get a PG when they saw that the movie was not good enough to get a significant audience at a PG-13. Always a bad sign! And there was material in the film that was inappropriate for a PG, but then the MPAA’s rating system is never reliable.

Previous Posts

Trailer: A Bigger Splash with Ralph Fiennes, Tilda Swinton, and Dakota Johnson
[youtube][/youtube] The lives of a famous rock star and a filmmaker, (Tilda Swinton and Matthias Schoenaerts) vacationing on the idyllic sun-drenched and remote Italian island of Pantelleria are ...

posted 8:00:25am Oct. 03, 2015 | read full post »

Interview: Adam LaVorgna of "Masterless"
Adam LaVorgna became an actor very young and was in the cast of the television series "Brooklyn Bridge" and "7th Heaven" before he was out of his teens. He loved the cast but he felt lost. He tried to use drugs to feel better and tried rehab ...

posted 2:58:01pm Oct. 02, 2015 | read full post »

Lauren Bradshaw's "Martian"-inspired Google Searches
I love this wonderful article by my friend and fellow critic, Lauren Bradshaw, about the ten Google searches she made after viewing "The Martian." ...

posted 10:13:33am Oct. 02, 2015 | read full post »

Interview: Goran Visnjic of "The Journey Home"
Goran Visnjic stars in the family movie adventure The Journey Home, with Dakota Goyo as an Canadian boy who is determined to bring a polar bear cub back to its mother. The scenery is spectacular and the story is heartwarming and exciting. I ...

posted 8:17:43am Oct. 02, 2015 | read full post »

Exclusive Clip: Golden Shoes
[jwvideo vid='KiRrH2Wm' pid='GvkPWNBE'] We are delighted to present an exclusive clip from the new family movie about soccer, "Golden Shoes." As long as he could remember, eight-year-old Christian Larou (Christian Koza) dreamed of being a ...

posted 8:00:46am Oct. 02, 2015 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.