Movie Mom

Movie Mom

The Spirit

posted by Nell Minow
Lowest Recommended Age:High School
MPAA Rating:Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of stylized violence and action, some sexual content and brief nudity
Profanity:Some strong language
Nudity/Sex:Brief nudity, sexual references
Alcohol/Drugs:Drug use
Violence/Scariness:Intense comic book violence including knives, guns, and explosions, suicide
Diversity Issues:Diverse characters
Movie Release Date:December 25, 2008
DVD Release Date:April 14, 2009

If there is ever an Oscar category for best performance by an article of clothing, the red tie worn by the title character in this film would be the clear winner and the rain coat would most likely be the runner-up.

This film version of the innovative and influential comic book owes much more to writer/director Frank Miller than to the man who created the character, Will Eisner. Miller, who revitalized Batman as The Dark Knight and co-directed “Sin City,” based on his own comic book series, itself in part inspired by Eisner’s subversive noir stories.

The Spirit is is something more than a man but something less than a superhero. Once he was Denny Colt, a cop, but something has happened that gives him special power and special responsibility. His great love is the city and he serves as its masked and mysterious protector. But there are also women, many of them and all utterly captivating and utterly captivated by him — his childhood sweetheart, the doctor who patches him up, a rookie cop. And there is a super villain, Octopus (Samuel L. Jackson), a guy who has developed a potion for giving him something on the brink of immortality. He has the same kind of special powers of healing that The Spirit does. And he wants something that will give him everything he needs to become all-powerful but it was in a box that got mixed up with something also very valuable but much more mundane.

Miller misses the forest for the trees here with luscious, insouciant images that sizzle and tantalize but finally detract from any sense of story, purpose, or character. I’ve seen lava lamps with more of a plot. And for an action movie it all seems very posed and static. Comic books, with their panel-bound drawings, provide a more muscular sense of motion than Miller does here. He pays more attention to the sole of The Spirit’s shoe than he does to anything that would connect us with the character or even connect the characters do each other. Everyone is arch. Everyone just poses. They might as well be trying out for “America’s Next Top Model.”

And Jackson is not just over the top. He is over whatever is over the top. As his sidekick, Scarlett Johansson is completely out of her depth and it is uncomfortable to see her floundering to try to look predatory. In the title role, Gabriel Macht is outdone by his clothes. The only watchable performance is from Eva Mendes as Sand Serif, the bad girl who could only have a heart of gold if she stole one.

Eye candy can only go so far. Archness is not the same as irony. Style is not the same as substance. Miller captures the letter, but what this film is lacking, in every sense of the word, is the Spirit.

  • Bob Westal

    I actually think you come down a bit easy on this film, including on aspects of it’s violence.
    First of all, as a point of fact, it’s not even in any way close to Will Eisner’s conception of the character, who was pointedly not a superhero in any way, shape, or form. He is simply a “criminologist” who is mistaken for dead and decides to go undercover — it was basically an excuse to give the character a mask for more or less strictly commercial reasons. In any case, Eisner’s worldview was far gentler, and more upbeat and humanistic than Miller, an occasionally outspoken neoconservative who owes a lot to Eisner in terms of visuals as a cartoonist but a lot more to Mickey Spillane in terms of storylines, content, and, increasingly, politics.
    As for the violence, while it certainly is cartoonish, there is a vicious, brutal, even fascistic streak here as the Spirit — who rarely used anything more lethal than his fists during the comic’s prime — decides to assassinate the Octopus because he is mean to a kitty. (I’m wondering if this is some sort of offhand tribute to Robert Altman brilliantly strange version of Chandler’s “The Long Goodbye.”)
    In any case, the worst violence on screen is being done to Will Eisner’s memory. It was inevitable that changes were going to be made to the Spirit, of course, but, apart from a brief and actually sweet and romantic interlude involving the young Denny Colt and his teen girlfriend, Sand Sared, taken surprisingly directly from the comic, Miller has left not even a hint of what the made this great comic book so special and singular. Not in the slightest.

  • Nell Minow

    Bob, thanks so much for a wonderful comment. I am thrilled to hear from another fan of Will Eisner and the original Spirit comics. And I think your comparison of the Miller version to Spillane is very apt. I still hope that some day someone will make a Spirit movie true to Eisner’s version. I remember in the 70’s there was some speculation James Garner might star — he would have been great.

  • jestrfyl

    I am crushed and dispirited. I have been looking froward to this movie for a long time. To learn that there has been a violation of the very core of Eisner’s work disturbs me! The humor (I love the puns in the names like “Sands Serif” or “Legs Akimbo”) and the energy of the relationships between the Spirit and the people he sought to help were the best parts of the books – aside from the visuals (he could really draw women!) and creative titles. I will see the movie – but perhpas I will not pay the premium price. Perhpas I will wait – sadly – for it to appear at the cheap theater – which may not take long given these reviews. This is making me all the more concerned for what may happen with “The Watchmen”. Will that get butchered, too? Stay tuned and see!

  • Vince

    The people who didn’t like this film made the mistake of taking it seriously. This is not a serious superhero film. It’s a parody of the cliches of the genre and it is hilarious (Samuel L. Jackson is especially funny and you can tell he had a lot of fun). I hope that in the years to come, this film will be reevaluated and perhaps become a cult classic.

  • Nell Minow

    Thanks, Vince! I took another look at it on cable recently. I’m always glad to hear from someone who sees more in a movie than I do, but even as a parody (which would have been true to the Eisner comic), it didn’t work for me. I did love the visuals!

Previous Posts

Tribute: Leonard Nimoy
We mourn the loss of Leonard Nimoy, who created one of the most iconic characters of all time, "Star Trek's" half-Vulcan, half-human Mr. Spock, with pointed ears and angled eyebrows perfectly designed to convey a wry sense of irony.  The storylines of the original "Star Trek" were provocative polit

posted 12:00:09pm Feb. 28, 2015 | read full post »

New from Daniele Watts: Muted
Actress Daniele Watts stars as missing teenager Crystal Gladwell in Muted, winner of the 18th annual American Black Film Festival short film competition, showing on HBO throughout March 2015. Muted fol

posted 8:00:46am Feb. 28, 2015 | read full post »

Smile of the Week: Uptown Funk from Alex Boye and the Dancing Grannies
[iframe width="560" height="315" src="" frameborder="0"] "Uptown Funk," from Mark Ronson and Bruno Mars, is covered in a sensational new video from longtime Mormon Tabernacle Choir member Alex Boyé and back-up performers ranging in age from 65-92.

posted 9:16:46am Feb. 27, 2015 | read full post »

Trailer: Like Sunday, Like Rain with Debra Messing and Leighton Meester
[iframe width="560" height="315" src="" frameborder="0"]

posted 8:00:29am Feb. 27, 2015 | read full post »

List: The Best Movie Con Games and Grifters
In honor of this week's release of "Focus," here are some of my favorite movies about con games and grifters. Remember that "con" comes from "confidence." A con man (or woman) makes you believe in them and have confidence in their schemes. And cons make great movies. If you haven't seen these, crank

posted 3:45:21pm Feb. 26, 2015 | read full post »

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.