Movie Mom

Movie Mom


Hollywood’s Inaccurate Portrayal of Religious Practice

posted by Nell Minow

E! Online has a column about Hollywood’s inaccurate portrayal of religious practice. A reader wrote in to complain about the treatment of Mr. Eko, who pretends to be a priest in “Lost.”
According to E!, Tod Tamberg, communications director of the Los Angeles Archdiocese is the man who usually answers Hollywood’s questions about Catholicism ritual, belief, and practice, but no one checked with him about Mr. Eko.
Pretty much every religion offers at least one consultant to keep pertinent films honest. One of them happens to have served as Hebrew coach for an A-list star…But unless Hollywood actively reaches out to such people–and not at the last minute, either–there’s little that religious consultants can do to ensure authenticity.
It was heartening to see the faith-group-produced “Fireproof” do modestly well last weekend, but accurate portrayal of religious practice and sincere faith is rare in Hollywood movies. I was pleased to that in this week’s light teen romantic comedy, “Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist,” a character briefly but movingly explains the Jewish tradition of tikkun olam (“healing the world”) as the spiritual purpose of life. It is nice to see something Jewish in a movie that is not bagels, oy vey, or guilt!
For more about the portrayal of religion in the movies, see this bibliography and this religious studies syllabus.



  • jestrfyl

    It is comical what Hollywood does with rituals. I have been known to suggest couples waiting to be married watch some of the great wedding movies – just to see how Hollywood writers wish their weddings had gone. This is another one of those worms, where art reflects life, which in turn tries to include art, which then reflects life, etc… Writers and producers have grand or lurid images of what is often fairly mundane. But then, mundane is rarely film-worthy.

  • Nell Minow

    I once took a “trial techniques” course with one of the greatest trial lawyers in the country and he told us that we needed to be aware of how courtrooms were portrayed on television and in the movies because even if it wasn’t real, it had to become real because that was what juries expected and they would think we didn’t know how to practice law if we didn’t behave like the lawyers they had seen. Art imitates life and as you say, vice versa.
    And despite relying on experts in just about every category from military operations to restaurants, most people know of huge mistakes made in the onscreen portrayal of their own professions. I was sitting next to a doctor friend in a very sad, serious movie once and she started to laugh in a tense scene because the doctor in the movie was peering at a character’s x-ray on the light box — without turning the light on!

  • Greenman

    I was raised in the Mormon (LDS) Church. I always found the depictions of Mormons and church services really weird. In 1947 there was a movie made called “Brigham Young”. The depiction of Mormon pioneers and leaders made them look like wild eyed fanatics and Brigham Young came across more like John Brown than the charming man his contemporaries knew. .I learned early on not to expect much accuracy from Hollywood and to be pleasently surprised when we get it.

Previous Posts

Thursdays in September on Turner Classic Movies: The Jewish Experience on Film
This month, TCM has an excellent series of films about the Jewish experience, every Thursday. TCM proudly presents The Projected Image: The Jewish Experience on Film, a weekly showcase of movies focusing on Jewish history and heritage as portrayed onscreen. Co-hosting the films each Thursday is D

posted 9:21:56pm Sep. 01, 2014 | read full post »

Start the School Year With a No-Screen Week
A new study shows another good reason to detox from all screen time now and then, especially for kids.  Children who take a five-day break from all screens are better at reading real-life facial expressions to understand the emotions of the people around them.  Psyblog described the study, which s

posted 3:56:33pm Sep. 01, 2014 | read full post »

COMING THIS MONTH: September 2014 Movies
Happy September!  There isn't much new in theaters this Friday, but next week things start to pick up. Here's the best of what's coming in theaters this month: September 12: "Dolphin Tale 2"  This sequel to the endearing fact-based "Dolphin Tale" brings back stars Harry Connick, Jr., Morgan Fr

posted 8:00:52am Sep. 01, 2014 | read full post »

Labor Day 2014: Movies About Unions
Today we pay tribute to workers, especially those who worked for better conditions for everyone. Sally Field won an Oscar for this real-life story about a courageous woman who helped mill workers form a union. [youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45CX8W9peTs[/youtube] Doris Day plays

posted 7:00:42am Sep. 01, 2014 | read full post »

Summer Summer-y: The Summer Movies of 2014
A few concluding thoughts on the summer movies of 2014: A good summer for food movies: "The Chef," "The 100-Foot Journey," and "The Trip to Italy" had some big-time actors but the real stars were the luscious meals. Special mention of the delicious French comedy "Le Chef," starring Jean Reno, as

posted 3:46:47pm Aug. 31, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.