Movie Mom

Movie Mom


Parents fret over appropriateness of movies for kids (Appleton Post-Crescent)

posted by Nell Minow

Cheryl Sherry’s column in the Appleton Post-Crescent discusses a new survey showing that PG movies with strong language sell fewer tickets than those with other kinds of parental concerns like violence or sex.

“The reality is that profanity, within PG, is the big demarcation between box office winner and box office loser,” research and marketing director Dan O’Toole told attendees at ShoWest, a conference where studios unveil upcoming movie lineups. “Parents are choosing PG films for their kids that have very, very low levels of profanity. We’re talking one-third the level of the average PG film,” he said.

Sherry called me for comment, and her column describes my background and approach and some of my thoughts on the rating system:

Minow, who has testified before the Federal Trade Commission on the MPAA’s rating system, said “overwhelmingly its biggest failing is they will give material a pass in a comedy they’d give a much higher rating to in a drama. So you have these movies like the Austin Powers movies getting a PG-13 rating, which have really, really raunchy humor. … Just because the MPAA is ratcheting down it’s system, doesn’t mean I have to follow suit.”

PG-13 has become the no-man’s land of the rating system, [Minow] added. “Many parents will shrug their shoulders and say, my 10-year-old is bright and can handle a PG-13. … But you do not know what you are getting. There can be PG-13s that are almost PG and there can be PG-13s that should be Rs.”



  • jestrfyl

    It is all subjective anyway. Personally I am appalled at the lack of creativity that writers show when having characters utter curses and epithets. Both Shakespeare and Twain were so much more creative, and their lines have endured much longer than the constant repitition of the same word over and over. Creativity in art can lead to creativity in life, even as we try to make each other angry or defensive.

  • Cindi

    What an interesting point! I am glad I don’t have to worry about it anymore! Thanks, Cindi

  • monkie

    “… But you do not know what you are getting. There can be PG-13s that are almost PG and there can be PG-13s that should be Rs.”
    …which is why so many of us rely on you :)
    Honestly, it’s the violence that gets to me in kids’ movies. I could handle explaining profanity and sexuality, but I have yet to find a plausible explanation for why people hurt one another.

  • Nell Minow

    Thanks to all three of you for great comments! As my mom always said, bad language usually reveals a lack of imagination and specificity.
    Thanks for the kind words, Monkie! It’s the casual nature of so much of the violence that is especially upsetting. Just as with the language, it’s a lack of imagination on the part of moviemaker and audience.

  • Cheryl

    I agree language is my main concern right now. I have very young children and in our experience so far, language is what they pick up on…. they do not understand or may not be interested in the sexual content or scenes with violence but if the characters use a word or phrase they are not familiar with my kids tune right in and ask about it or sometimes just try to use it. I unfortunantely discovered Movie Mom after letting my 3 yr. old watch Zathura bases on another ‘family- oriented’ reviewer that rated it as appropriate for all ages! Boy did we have some deprogramming to do of his growing vocabulary!

Previous Posts

What Happened to All the Great Quotable Movie Lines?
Michael Cieply has a fascinating piece in the New York Times about the movie lines we love to quote and why there don't seem to be any new ones. Look through all of the top ten lists of the year, and see if you can think of one quotable line from any of them. That doesn't mean they aren't well wri

posted 3:58:57pm Dec. 20, 2014 | read full post »

George Clooney and the Cast of Downton Abbey
You don't have to be a fan of "Downton Abbey" (or "Mr. Selfridge") to love this hilarious spoof, with guest appearances by Jeremy Piven, George Clooney and the Absolutely Fabulous Joanna Lumley. [iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/ryo7fqdmcGQ?rel=0" frameborder="0"] [

posted 1:43:50pm Dec. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Ask Amy Says: A Book on Every Bed
I love to remind people about Amy Dickinson's wonderful "Book on Every Bed" proposal: Here’s how it happens: You take a book (it can be new or a favorite from your own childhood). You wrap it. On Christmas Eve (or whatever holiday you celebrate), you leave the book in a place where Santa is

posted 12:00:42pm Dec. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Interview: Matthew Llewellyn, Composer for Wally Lamb's "Wishin' and Hopin'"
Wishin' and Hopin' is Lifetime movie airing December 21, 2014, based on the novel by Wally Lamb. It stars Molly Ringwald and Meat Loaf with narration by Chevy Chase. Composer Matthew Llewellyn was kind enough to answer my questions about creating a score for this nostalgic holiday story. How d

posted 9:40:56am Dec. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Wild's Cheryl Strayed Has a New Advice Podcast
Before Wild, Cheryl Strayed was the pseudonymous "Dear Sugar" advice columnist for The Rumpus. Her columns were collected in Tiny Beautiful Things: Advice on Love and Life from Dear Sugar. Writer Steve Almond (Candyfreak: A Journey through the Chocolate Underbelly of America) also wrote as Dear Su

posted 3:59:40pm Dec. 19, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.