Movie Mom

Movie Mom


Under the Tuscan Sun

posted by rkumar
B+
Lowest Recommended Age:Middle School
Profanity:Some strong language for a PG-13
Nudity/Sex:Sexual references and situations, gay characters
Alcohol/Drugs:Frequent social drinking
Violence/Scariness:Difficult emotional complications
Diversity Issues:Strong female and minority characters
Movie Release Date:2003

Like the crumbling Italian villa at the center of this story, there is a lot wrong with the movie, but it is so enticing — especially for its intended audience — that it is hard to resist.

The best-selling book by Frances Mayes about her restoration of a crumbling villa is beautifully written and wonderfully evocative, but it does not have much of a story. So writer/director Audrey Wells has taken the real Mayes, and thrown a lot of plot at her, just the kind of thing that last year’s Adaptation should have warned her against.

Mayes (played by the exquisite Diane Lane) is now a book critic and would-be novelist who is dumped by the husband she has been supporting. This means that he is entitled to alimony in addition to his half of the house, which he wants to keep. She is financially and emotionally devastated and moves into a depressing furnished apartment complex filled with people who are getting divorced.

When her best friend Patti (the marvelous Sandra Oh) becomes pregnant, she gives Frances her ticket for a tour of Tuscany. It’s a “Gay and Away” tour, which is fine with Frances, who is relieved that there will be no possibility of romantic entanglements.

But she ends up with an entanglement is of a different kind, impulsively buying an ancient house called Bramasole, which translates into “yearning for the sun.”

And yes, it is Frances who is yearning for the sun, and yes, the renovation of the house is a metaphor for renovating her spirits. On this emotional journey, she will meet kind souls who will impart life lessons with a profundity somewhere between fortune cookie and Dr. Phil.

A free-spirited Englishwoman, a kind local realtor, and three Polish construction workers help her get ready to enter back into life again, and a charming Italian man helps her begin by reminding her that she is capable of loving and being loved. Frances makes a wish for a wedding and a family in the house and when at first it seems that the wedding and the family are not the ones she wished for, she begins to understand that they really are just what she wanted. And she learns that she can help others who yearn for the sun, healing herself at the same time.

The problem is that director/screenwriter Wells tells us a lot more than she shows us. She seems to have no understanding of how to translate a story into film. The movie often seems abrupt and unfinished and the characters are superficially drawn. The script tells us how the characters feel about each other but does not make it matter enough for us to believe in or care about the way their relationships are resolved. Lane brings as much to the material as is humanly possible, but is given little to do beyond looking wistful and wounded. But it is all beguilingly pretty to watch and its message of hope and second chances is beguilingly pretty, too.

Parents should know that the movie has some strong language for a PG-13. There are sexual references and situations, including a sexual encounter between two people who barely know each other — portrayed as deeply romantic and healing — and a sexually active young couple. Another character is happily promiscuous. Mayes’ husband leaves her for another woman. The movie does a good job of avoiding stereotypes with a gay Asian character.

Families who see this movie should talk about all of the advice that Mayes gets and what she learns from it, especially the stories about the train tracks, about bad ideas being like playground bullies, and about the ladybugs. How important is “childish enthusiasm?” Why did Frances believe the relationship with Marcello was more than it was? In the book, Mayes says that “the house is a metaphor for the self.” How is that shown throughout the movie?

Families who enjoy this movie will also enjoy Enchanted April and A Room With a View, both part of the rich tradition of movies showing how the sun-dappled vistas and luscious food of Italy can restore souls and open hearts. There’s an almost-as rich tradition of harried home renovations movies (the best is Mister Blandings Builds His Dream House) and of house-as-metaphor movies, most recently Life as a House with Kevin Kline. Families might also like to try some Italian cooking, learn more about the tradition of the flags in Siena, and of course visit Tuscany if they can.



  • Tj

    Does anyone know where I can find a dress like the white day dress that Diane Lane wore during part of the movie. I would greatly appreciate it. Thank you.

  • Nell Minow

    Thanks for the comment, TJ! I’ve sent you a private email with the contact information for the costume designer.

  • Sultana

    Nell Minow, could you also send me the contact information for that designer? I am nearly obsessed over The White Dress. And the Orange Dress she wore in the wedding scenes.
    Thanks!

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    I’ve sent you the information, Sultana. Good luck!

  • Kari

    Nell Minow, could you please send me the information as well. I am in love with the sundress that Diane Lane is wearing in the very end of the movie and I can’t find anything like it! thank you!

  • Molly

    Hello! I am so sorry to jump on this train – but I have been searching for information regarding this dress. Would anyone be able to forward me this information as well?
    Thank you so much!

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    It is a beautiful dress! I will send you the contact info for the costume designer, Nicoletta Ercole, but as the mother of a professional costume designer I must say that this many years later you would be best off trying to get a local seamstress to try to duplicate it for you.

  • B. Davis

    If I could get that contact information for the white dress also I would greatly appreciate it.

  • http://blog.beliefnet.com/moviemom/ Nell Minow

    I sent you the information so you can get in touch with the costume designer. Good luck!

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment Erin

    Likewise! I love that white dress! Who was the costume designer?

  • http://DianeLane'sSundress Lee

    I am trying to surprise my girlfriend w/a dress like or similar to the one used in Under a Tuscan Sun – any chance anyone could pass on information to help me make this happen. Thanks much!

    • Nell Minow

      I have had so many inquires about this dress! Your best bet is to bring a photo of the dress to a local dressmaker. Even if it was available in stores when the movie was made, it would not be any more. But it will not be difficult to duplicate. Good luck!

Previous Posts

Fifty Years of Fiddler on the Roof
The Yiddish-language stories of Sholem Alechim, collected as Tevye the Dairyman and The Railroad Stories (Library of Yiddish Classics), inspired one of the most successful, influential, and widely performed Broadway musicals of all time, "Fiddler on the Roof," which opened fifty years ago this week.

posted 8:00:47am Sep. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Great Cinematographers on Instagram
Indiewire has a gorgeous array of Instagram feeds from Hollywood cinematographers. Be sure to talke a look so you can follow them.

posted 8:00:27am Sep. 19, 2014 | read full post »

De-fictionalizing Products in Movies and Television: Life Imitating Art
Fast Company has an article about Omni Consumer Products, a "de-fictionalizing" company that looks for products in movies and television that do not really exist and makes them available. As the sole proprietor of Omni Consumer Products, [Pete] Hottelet is constantly scanning the pop culture z

posted 8:00:17am Sep. 19, 2014 | read full post »

Tusk
You can make a good movie about slackers, for example "Slackers," from Richard Linklater and "Clerks" from Kevin Smith. But you can't make a good movie by a slacker, and Smith does not seem wi

posted 5:59:40pm Sep. 18, 2014 | read full post »

This is Where I Leave You
A toddler carries his little potty out in front of the house so he can try out his new-found skill in public. Twice. Plus another time when the contents of the potty are first displayed for the

posted 5:59:39pm Sep. 18, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.