Mindfulness Matters

Mindfulness Matters


Book Review: The Book of Mu: Essential Writings on Zen’s Most Important Koan edited by James Ishmael Ford & Melissa Moyzen Blacker

posted by Dr. Arnie Kozak

mu.jpgMu is Zen’s most famous and challenging koan. 

The Book of Mu (Wisdom Publications) is a collection of essays, contemporary and classic on this ancient mind puzzle and a wonderful introduction to the practice of Zen.
I have had little exposure to the Rinzai and koan traditions of Zen. I have practiced Soto Zen and Zazen, but never koans. After reading through the thoughtfully collected and contributed essays by James Ishmael Ford and Melissa Moyzen Blacker, I feel that I now have.
Mu is under my skin, working on me, whether I like it or not!
The koan proceeds something like this: A peasant asks the Zen master Joshu (or Chau-Chou, or Zhaozhou), “does a dog have buddha nature?” To this query Joshu replies, “Mu.” This seems to be a contradiction. “Mu” translates to “no” or by extension “emptiness.” It seems that Joshu is saying the dog does not have buddhanature, but the Buddha was clear that all sentient beings have buddhanature. What gives?
Read on to find out. If the koan is interpreted literally it does not make sense, but as a Zen master, Joshu would not have meant it literally. 
This is the type of book that you don’t have to read cover-to-cover; you can skip around reading essays out of sequence, each circling around the truth of Mu. This truth can’t be grasped at an intellectual level. 
If metaphor is understanding one thing in terms of another, koans are our most basic metaphors. We use koans to understand one thing — ultimate reality — in terms of another–the words, images, and feelings inspired by the koan. And, as the authors suggest, Mu is the koan of all koans. Thus, Mu is the metaphor of all metaphors.

Here is an excerpt from Melissa Myozen Blacker’s essay, “No is Not the Opposite of Anything.”

We are truly cultivating an empty field in which seeds of reality, through hearing teachings and experiencing life as directly as we can, beginning to take root at the deepest place, eventually to blossom into wakefulness–into the opening of the minds’e eye. Nothing but Mu, at every moment, filling our conscious and then our unconscious minds–every thought accompanied by this one word, which functions as a stand-in for a reality that is essentially nameless.  (emphasis added). 

This “standing in” is the metaphor of all metaphors. The transmission point between lived experience and understood experience; between reality and thought. It’s the very point where we begin to construct our experience and Mu brings back to this moment just before that construction arises giving us a glimpse of the unconstructed, unadulterated reality that we are. 


Pre-order The Book of Mu now on Amazon and read an excerpt from the detailed review in the magazine Buddhadharma: The Practitioner’s Quarterly. 




  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment James Hegarty

    Sorry pal! Mu is not a metaphor.

    Keep going.

    Jim

    • Dr. Arnie Kozak

      Thanks for your comment, Jim. I’d like to hear more on how Mu is not a metaphor vis-a-vis what I said in my post. If we understand metaphor as understanding one thing (less familiar) in terms of something more familiar can you then see it as a metaphor?

Previous Posts

Transitions, Attachments, and Hope
It's been a long winter here in Northern Vermont and elsewhere around the country. The mountain is still frozen and buried in snow. In the valley, the long buried grass, brown and tired, is emerging from under the receding glacier, yet my yard is still buried in snow. The calendar reads April but

posted 3:02:56pm Apr. 07, 2014 | read full post »

A Special Opportunity for Opening Your Heart in Relationship with Tara Brach
I'd like to let you know about a special opportunity with my charma friend Tara Brach who is one of the more authentic and beloved mindfulness teachers. She is author of the bestsellers Radical Acceptance and more recently, True Refuge. Please read about this special program below. It’s often

posted 8:12:05pm Mar. 26, 2014 | read full post »

Equanimity in the Face of Adversity, Controversy, and Memory
The Dalai Lama recently visited with President Obama. Not such an unusual event since they have visited before, but the Chinese Government used this as an opportunity to complain, threaten, and

posted 7:24:11pm Mar. 14, 2014 | read full post »

Sit Still
If you listen carefully to my meditation instructions, you might detect a contradiction. On the one hand, I de-emphasize the posture because I don't want people to get deterred by the physical difficulties of sitting. On the other hand, I encourage everyone to sit still and to resist the reflexive t

posted 7:48:21am Feb. 11, 2014 | read full post »

P is for Perfectionism; M is for Mindfulness
The February Kripalu Compass Newsletter featured an article I wrote on perfectionism and mindfulness. You can read it here. "My basement was a disaster for months, a dumping ground for junk: empty boxes, retired appliances and gadgets, books, old LPs, outdoor gear. Each time I walked through the cl

posted 7:34:32pm Feb. 03, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.