(Here’s my McLaren interview consolidated)
Recently, I interviewed Brian McLaren about his new book, A New Kind of Christianity: Ten Questions That Are Transforming The Faith
. McLaren is author of over a dozen books and among Time magazine “25 Most influential Evangelicals” (2005). The interview covers a number of pertinent subjects for faith in the 21st century, for the next week here at Jazz Theologian we’ll consider one item each day.
What’s wrong with the old kind of Christianity?
Jazz Theologian: Brian, How does, A New Kind of Christianity, build upon your past works and what’s wrong with the old kind of Christianity?
McLaren: Several people have said that NKoCy summarizes my work to date and extends it into new territory, and I think there’s a lot of truth to that, although it is less directly engaged with contemporary crises than Everything Must Change, or with spiritual formation than Finding Our Way Again. Instead of saying what’s wrong with the old kind of Christianity, I’d simply say that as the Christian faith matures over the centuries, we are ready for new challenges, new learnings, and it would be a shame to fail to keep maturing. So older kinds of Christianity were appropriate to their times and our maturity, but we need to keep growing, learning, and maturing.
Read on and see what he said about horse buggies, Malcolm X, Martin Luther King Jr., and (of course) a jazz-shaped faith…
Jazz Theologian: In your previous book, A New Kind of Christian: A Tale of Two Friends on a Spiritual Journey, you draw an analogy between modern churches that look like everything is fine with being like “horse buggies” that were built right when they were becoming obsolete, is that who your new book is for, Christians who are bought into a form of Christianity that is fading?
McLaren: Nobody has asked me that question yet, and it forces me to face something that I probably haven’t really faced so far, namely, that the folks who are thoroughly bought into current forms of Christian faith are unlikely to change. They’ll be likely to interpret this new book as an attack on what they hold dear, which really isn’t what I intend at all. I’d say this book is more for Christians who have tried and tried to buy into the dominant forms of Christianity today … traditionalism, the religious right, the prosperity gospel, and so on – and who simply can’t give their hearts to those forms of Christian living. They feel there’s something more calling them, and they’re on a quest for that something more. That’s more, I think, who I’m writing for, although I’m glad to have any of the others come along who are willing.
Jazz Theologian: I’m assuming that you agree that the emerging church is not just a renewal movement for young middle-class Caucasian Christians. So here are a few questions so that we can see how emergent Christianity addresses the issues of following Jesus within the urban context.
How does A New Kind of Christianity help urban Christians address issues such as high incarceration rate among young men, substandard schools and fatherlessness while at the same time there is a the proliferation of churches preaching a prosperity gospel?
McLaren: In NKoCy, I’m trying to help us get a deeper and broader vision of the gospel. The gospel that many people believe in says very little about issues of justice and peace in this life; it focuses on personal morality in this life and salvation from hell after this life. It would be very concerned about, say, homosexuality, but not very concerned about systemic racism and economic exclusion and oppression. It would say a lot about personal morality but not so much about social morality. I’m proposing that the gospel of the kingdom of God – the gospel Jesus preached (and Paul too, I propose) – is about God’s will being done on earth as in heaven, and so that has everything to do with the city, with racism, with incarceration, with unemployment, with equity in education, and so on. I’m also suggesting that the eschatologies that many of us were taught – eschatologies that predict the world will get worse and worse and then be destroyed – work against working for the healing of this world, including our cities. So I would say that this book, along with Everything Must Change, would be of real interest to folks engaged with urban issues.
The Bible Question
Jazz Theologian: You argue that, A New Kind of Christianity will require that we ask, “What is the overarching story line of the Bible? How will this answer to this question help African-American churches that often read the Bible through an Exodus or Exile narrative?
McLaren: Actually, in this book I’m saying that those African-American churches that read the Bible through an Exodus narrative have been right all along, and that the white churches that tended to read the Bible exclusively through an atonement and evacuation narrative are missing something tremendously important. Sadly, in my experience, quite a few of our African-American churches are switching over to the more traditional white narrative, which says that it’s only about Jesus and me (and maybe my family, or my religion), with little concern for the more social dimensions of the gospel for the poor, oppressed, excluded, marginalized and forgotten, not to mention our enemies. I’m recommending that we take that Exodus narrative that African American theology has cherished, and then set the narrative of creation as its prequel, and the narrative of reconciliation as its sequel … and in that way, I think we’ll have a three-dimensional narrative that has room for us to live, serve, and breathe.
The King Question
Jazz Theologian: Not long after telling our nation about his dream, Martin Luther King Jr. said that his dream had turned into a “nightmare.” One of the reasons for this can be found in his, “Letter from Birmingham City Jail,” in which he expressed his love for the church while at the same time he pled with pastors to reject the “fear of being non-conformists.” Do you ever feel like that? What do you do?
McLaren: The pressure to conform really is great, and the punishment for stepping out of line can be harsh. For a lot of years, I did what a lot of people do: tried to conform and stay out of trouble! But eventually, I just couldn’t do so any longer. In part, the Bible drove me out of conformity, because the Bible didn’t fit in the narrow framework I was given. In part, people drove me out – when I met people who were experiencing injustice, and when I took seriously my call to love them as I love myself, their burdens and concerns became my own and I had to take some risks.
Knowing how much to risk when is a real matter for spiritual discernment. Some of us are liable to be too timid, and others of us to be too rash, so I think there aren’t one-size-fits-all answers to this, except to say that we need to be prayerful and open to the Spirit’s guidance, and we need to have a circle of soul-friends with whom we can process our lives and our work.
The X Question
Jazz Theologian: Malcolm X’s main critique of Christianity in America had to do with how race seemed to determine our habits more than Jesus. Which of your questions in A New Kind of Christianity can lead us closer to the unity that Christ prayed for in Jn. 17 and why?
McLaren: The first of the ten questions probably is key here [the narrative question]. I suggest that what many of us take to be the biblical narrative is actually the Greco-Roman narrative, and that narrative is inherently dualistic. It creates us vs. them, civilized vs. barbarians, insiders vs. outsiders, and that dualism easily gets translated into racism and related -isms, white versus black, settlers versus native peoples, Americans versus immigrants, whatever.
I’d also say that the third question is really key, the God question: Is God violent? If we believe that God plays favorites – loves some, hates others – chooses some, rejects others – makes some rich, lets others be poor – then it becomes very easy to see our race (or nation, or denomination) as blessed and everyone else as cursed. That connects us quickly with the fourth question, the Jesus question, because if we believe that God is like Jesus, and we see Jesus constantly crossing boundaries to show love to the other, then we see God as being the God who breaks boundaries too, rather than the one who creates boundaries.
Then I think about the sixth question, the church question … because we need to ask how we manifest and embody our view of the biblical narrative, our view of God, our view of Jesus, in our local churches. All of our theology needs to be translated into real life in local faith communities … that’s where it makes a difference, especially in our cities, where it is needed so much!