Idol Chatter

Idol Chatter


‘Milk’ Celebrates a Gay Martyr, Maybe Too Soon

posted by Paul O'Donnell

milkpicseanpenn.jpgIn “Milk,” Gus Van Sant’s new political bio-pic starring Sean Penn, there are frames within frames, some of them intended by the filmmaker, some the accidents of history.
There is Harvey Milk, played by Penn, talking into a tape deck at his kitchen table, narrating the story we’re watching. Wrapped around that story are the real-world events that created Harvey Milk’s place in history as a gay activist and martyr: archival footage of men being arrested in gay bars and loaded into paddy wagons, colorful news video of Milk’s nemesis, the evangelical Christian and anti-gay campaigner Anita Bryant, as well as vintage street scenes from the Castro, San Francisco’s first gay enclave and Milk’s adopted home.
There is, finally, the election of 2008, with its elevation of an African-American president on the same day that Californians ratified Proposition 8, banning gay marriage in their state. “Milk” comes at a perfect time to remind us that we’re all more free when some of us become more free.


The film isn’t always up to the task. Among all these frames is a pretty standard film biography, with characters spouting unlikely summaries of the action so far or telegraphing their fates–“What’s all this activism in politics?” asks Harvey Milk’s boyfriend Scott from bed one morning, letting us know early on that Milk will have to sacrifice everything, even Scott, for the cause.
At times I found myself wishing Van Sant would give up and simply let us luxuriate in the contemporary shots of bell-bottomed marchers and Bryant crooning about Jesus. But that would deprive us, and “Milk,” of two outstanding performances from Penn and his co-star, the increasingly impressive Josh Brolin.
“Milk” begins to trace its hero’s life in the mid-1970s. By then roundups of gay men had become rare and in Greenwich Village in New York and the Castro, homosexuals could congregate openly and offer each other mutual protection. But when Harvey Milk (Penn) arrives in the Castro with Scott (James Franco), he sees there is much more to be done before he and his fellow gay men can call themselves free.
Charismatic and courageous, Milk decides to change the system from the inside. First he must change himself, cutting off his hippie hair and exchanging his ratty jeans for a three-piece suit, and trading an idealistic stridency for slogans and pragmatic politics. Even then, he suffers repeated defeats before finally gaining a seat on the city’s legislature, with a big assist from George Mosconi, the mayor who engineered a redistricting measure that gave San Francisco’s neighborhoods like the Castro more power to elect their own. After less than a year in office, Milk, along with Mayor Mosconi, was gunned down in City Hall, felled by a fellow city supervisor.
Penn portrays Milk at once convincingly and as if experimenting with a new set of parameters for building a character. Penn stretches as Milk stretches, giving the nuts and bolts of Milk’s political rise the pulse of personal discovery. Milk watches amazed as his political clout grows as he becomes more openly and truthfully who he is inside.
Brolin, as Milk’s assassin, Dan White, is the brooding, macho presence that we saw in “No Country for Old Men” but here his character is led to commit violence by his own uncertainty. White, a stalwart city fireman and cop, resents Milk’s natural skills as a legislator. Milk suspects that White is gay himself, and can’t deal with his feelings. But Brolin’s performance is more subtle, communicating White’s inability to process how Milk–someone who he’s been raised to think of as less than a man–outshines him in the art of political horse trading.
Subtlety does not otherwise abound in “Milk.” Screenwriter Dustin Lance Black documents too much and too rarely allows his historical figures to breathe. While Brolin and Penn are granted the screen time to establish their characters, secondary players are left to struggle to make their overdetermined lines sound natural–Emile Hirsch in particular adds a much needed pinch of salt to the movie as Cleve Jones, one of Milk’s closest lieutenants. For Black, this movie was a mission to change hearts and minds, and it shows.
There are some terrible ironies in Milk’s story. One is that Milk’s victory over Bryant’s anti-homosexual campaign–his one achievement celebrated in the movie–was a Pyrrhic one, in that it helped rouse the religious right that would bedevil gay politics for years to come. The movie ends with the massive candlelight march through San Francisco to protest Milk’s murder. In lionizing Milk this way, the movie doesn’t give us any clue why the same Californians we see defeating Bryant’s agenda would vote, again with conservative religious backing, to undo gay marriages already on the books 30 years later.
As a result “Milk” feels like a big pat on the back for its natural audience, which probably won’t include many hardcore evangelical Christians. Thanks to people like Harvey Milk, it tells the enlightened, we’ve won. If he could see us now, Harvey Milk probably wouldn’t agree.
Sean Penn at LocateTV.com



  • JudyO

    Filthy.

  • JonAtFaithUCC

    What’s filthy?

  • Charles Cosimano

    Ok, leaving aside the probability that the film will not attract enough viewers to pay for the cameraman, one wonders if it might not turn into one of those, “This is why it really is cool to hate gays,” sort of movies. In other words, so overdone and preachy as to turn people in the opposite direction, sort of like back in the 80s when a friend of mine told me that he never watched anything on television about the Holocaust because he always ended up rooting for the Nazis.

  • Your Name

    Wierd comments from all above it seems…..I went to a very large old theatre in Minneapolis to see the film and it was so packed that we had to sit in the balcony. Milk encouraged gay people to come out; that and the effect of AIDS has enlightened the population on the whole that homosexuality isn’t wrong…it’s their friends, children, siblings etc. And so it goes…”Milk” brought a standing ovation in the theatre at a 4:00 pm showing and it was far from only gay people there.

  • JonAtFaithUCC

    Unfortunately, it hasn’t been shown in my community yet. I’ll definitely be there.

  • Bob- Long time reader of the daily jokes

    Just a few nights ago I saw the Charlie Rose program with conversation about ‘Milk’ with Sean,Gus, and Josh which was another of the excellent examples of Charlie’s wide experience in giving his viewers real insights to the thinking of his guests.
    It is one of the few gems among the ‘interviews’ and ‘news’
    reports which we are subjected to far too often.

Previous Posts

Blasting Off in an Imperfect World
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HodFzcJHIYI 23 Blast is a touching film about Travis Freeman (Mark Hapka) who was a high school football player for the Corbin High School Redhounds in Kentucky and was stricken with Cavernous Sinus Thrombosis, which  destroyed his optical nerves. But Coach Ferris

posted 9:14:00am Oct. 21, 2014 | read full post »

Author Ted Dekker Wows Us Again With A.D. 30: A Novel
Critics are raving about Ted Dekker's new book A.D. 30: A Novel. Readers will experience the story of Jesus as they never have before. Publisher's Weekly said, "The reigning king of Christian thrillers...kicks down the door of biblical fiction." Booklist said, "This is the kind of book term 'sweepin

posted 3:42:39pm Oct. 20, 2014 | read full post »

#IAMUnbroken Campaign Celebrates Louis Zamperini’s Unbroken Spirit
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZeGuTYHuI4&feature=share[/youtube] Do you have a story of perseverance, triumph or the power of God delivering you from a trial? UNBROKEN, a powerful faith-revitalizing film, chronicles the life of former Olympian, WWII veteran and POW Survivor, Louis Z

posted 9:50:55am Oct. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Jennifer Garner Discusses Film, Dirty Diapers, and Husband’s Secret Talent
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_dideF5qvk   Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day is based on the children’s book of the same title, follows Alexander and his family’s crazy and brutal day. Whether it is baby Trevor eating a dark green highlighter since his p

posted 9:57:51am Oct. 17, 2014 | read full post »

The Rise of ISIS
“It’s past time for American to hear this truth. By minimizing the challenge,” Jay Sekulow (American Center Law Justice) wrote in his September opinion piece on FoxNews.com. The world is facing a serious threat in the Middle East with ISIS, a group of terrorists dedicated to mass executions

posted 10:16:20am Oct. 14, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.