I remember about eight years ago when then presidential candidate George W. Bush repeatedly claimed that he would restore honor to the presidency, soiled as it had been by our previous president’s infamous affair. I remember hoping he would succeed. But a new kind of shame has come to the office and to our nation as reports surface about our government’s secret authorization of torture. We all share in this shame.
Conservative columnist and blogger Andrew Sullivan expresses what many of us feel. He reminds his readers:
… my first response to reports of abuse and torture at Gitmo was to accuse the accusers of exaggeration or deliberate deception … It struck me as a no-brainer that this stuff was being invented by the far left or was part of al Qaeda propaganda. After all, they train captives to lie about this stuff. Bottom line: I trusted this president in a time of war to obey the rule of law that we were and are defending.
Sadly, he laments, that trust was betrayed:
And then I was forced to confront the evidence. He betrayed all of us. He lied. He authorized torture in secret, and then, when busted after Abu Ghraib, blamed it on low-level grunts. This was not a mistake. It was a betrayal.
The word “betrayal,” of course, recalls Moveon.org’s Sept. 26 ad. Many considered the pun childish at best, politically unsavvy at least, or worse. There was a rush to condemn anyone who failed to condemn the ad. But Sullivan’s use of the word strikes me as anything but childish.
Our nation’s reputation, not to mention that of the presidency, has been dishonored by this betrayal of trust. Honorable people – conservative and liberal, Republican and Democrat – need to follow Andrew Sullivan’s example, coming together to express our grief and outrage about the political hypocrisy and betrayal to which we have been subjected by people we elected.
Brian McLaren’s new book, Everything Must Change: Jesus, Global Crises, and a Revolution of Hope, was released last Tuesday.