Jay Sekulow

Faith & Justice

Constitutional Concerns About ObamaCare

posted by Jay Sekulow

May 16, 2011

There’s virtually total agreement in the legal community that the constitutionality of ObamaCare – the government-run health care law passed by Congress and signed into law by President Obama – will be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Where’s the plenty of disagreement:  what will the nation’s highest determine?

At the center of the issue is the individual mandate provision, which forces Americans – under penalty of law – to purchase health insurance.

That is where most of the legal challenges originate, including one from the ACLJ.  Today, we filed a brief at a federal appeals court in Washington, DC urging the court to reinstate our federal lawsuit and declare the entire health care law unconstitutional.

Our lawsuit, along with a number of others – including separate legal challenges by Virginia and Florida – focus on the assertion that the individual mandate violates the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Nothing more than a brazen power-grab by Congress.  A move that is not only wrong, but unconstitutional.

That’s what we argued in our brief filed on behalf of four U.S. residents and taxpayers in at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

“The individual mandate is unconstitutional because it exceeds even the outermost bounds of Congress’s Article I authority and is inconsistent with the constitutional system of dual sovereignty that divides power between the federal and State governments,” the brief contends. “Under the Commerce Clause, Congress cannot ‘regulate’ inactivity by requiring individuals to buy a good or service as a condition of their lawful residence in the United States. . . .”   Our brief is posted here

And, that’s exactly what the Commonwealth of Virginia argued just days ago – before the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals – at a hearing where the federal government tried to convince a three-judge panel (two judges appointed by Obama, one by Clinton) that a lower court got it wrong when it declared that the individual mandate had to go.

You can listen to the oral arguments here

And, in an interview with Fox News, Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli correctly concluded that this case is about liberty, not health care.  As he put it, if the federal government can order you to purchase health insurance, it can order you to buy anything.

Watch the interview here.

As these challenges move forward, one thing is certain:  all legal roads end up at the Supreme Court.  Our case is before the DC court of appeals.  The Virginia case at the 4th circuit.  And, the Florida case before the 11th circuit.

You will certainly hear more about these legal challenges in the weeks and months ahead.  But the real media attention will begin when these appeals arrive at the U.S. Supreme Court.

You’re already hearing a lot of talk about 2012 – especially when it comes to presidential hopefuls.  Put 2012 on your calendar for another reason, too.  That’s when the nation’s highest court is likely to render its decision – either declaring ObamaCare constitutional – or striking it down.  Just in time for the election.

Stay tuned.

Previous Posts

Jay Sekulow: Will the State Department finally speak out for Pastor Saeed Abedini?
Last Friday’s standing-room only hearing before the Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission was among the most dramatic I’ve witnessed.  There was outrage – outrage not just from me as I declared the State Department “AWOL” in our quest to free an American Pastor, Saeed Abedini -- a U.S. citiz

posted 11:50:49am Mar. 19, 2013 | read full post »

Jay Sekulow: Help Us Tell the Story of American Pastor Saeed, Imprisoned in Iran
One of the most important things we can do is keep the story of Pastor Saeed Abedini in the spotlight. This U.S. citizen is facing eight years in a deadly Iranian prison, convicted for his Christian faith. We know that the situation he faces gets worse day by day. He remains cut-off from speaking

posted 3:30:16pm Feb. 06, 2013 | read full post »

Jay Sekulow: American Pastor Saeed Barred From His Trial in Iran
It's unlike any judicial system in the world. On Monday, American Pastor Saeed Abedini went to court in Iran with his attorney to address charges of attempting to undermine the Iranian government. The real problem: he converted from Islam to Christianity 13 years ago and started working with house-c

posted 11:13:19am Jan. 24, 2013 | read full post »

Jay Sekulow: American Pastor to Face Trial in Iranian Prison
An American Pastor is being held in Iran’s most notorious prison – Pastor Saeed, a U.S. citizen, has been told that he “will hang” because of his Christian faith. And, now the Iranian government has put this case on the fast track – and scheduled a trial that’s just days away. After s

posted 3:11:54pm Jan. 15, 2013 | read full post »

Jay Sekulow: HHS Fines for Challenging Mandate? Not So Fast
We are on the front lines when it comes to challenging the HHS mandate which requires employers to provide health insurance for employees that include paying for abortion-producing drugs - or face still penalties including significant fines. To date, we have secured injunctions – putting the ma

posted 11:47:06am Jan. 09, 2013 | read full post »

Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.