Everyday Ethics

Everyday Ethics


Should We Be Judged by the Bad Behavior of Our Friends?

posted by Padmini Mangunta

Well, friends, I hope you’ll bear with me for some good ol’ Monday angsting. As we all know, it’s tempting to navel-gaze, but I think that my questions for you just manage to miss the self-indulgent mark (I hope?)…

Some would say you’re only as good as the company you keep. If that’s truly the case, would that mean our moral or ethical report card gets a poor mark when our friends act against our personal standards of  “righteous” behavior? Or are we meant only to accept, not judge, our friends for their different opinions and actions?

For the most part (the 99.99% mark that is), I’m happy to be held by the standard of the company I keep. I am incredibly proud of my friends, not only because of their success, intelligence or charm, but also because of what I would consider their high ethical and/or moral standard.

That said….I don’t have any overtly racist friends, or for that matter, covertly racist friends. But at times, there have been remarks about race, joking or otherwise, that I feel supremely uncomfortable simply overhearing. While I don’t laugh or encourage such remarks, I also rarely do more than pooh-pooh them.

Another personal example, I have a friend who routinely runs down others, far more than the occasional pettiness. We’re talking nasty remarks, judgmental remarks, back-handed compliments and front-handed insults. By not correcting his/her behavior, am I condoning it? Or am I simply minding my own business?

For so long I’ve adopted a type of laissez-faire attitude to my judgment (or non-judgment) of those around me. “To each their own,” I’d shrug. “Who am I to judge?” is my internal reminder when I hear or see someone acting in a way I find reprehensible.

To be honest, I often fail myself in upholding this attitude. I admit to occaaasionally ranting over dinner or drinks to my closest friends when others fail to meet my standards of behavior – though a part of me is flinching with each smug, self-righteous word.

Yet most of us would agree that there is some type of universally understood definition of bad behavior, wouldn’t we? Calling someone fat and ugly to their face = bad. Attributing criminal behavior to a person purely based on the color of skin = bad.

Is my personal ethical credit report tarnished when I tolerate such behavior, or is it actually the opposite (which is what my instinct seems to maintain) and I tarnish myself when I judge other people by my own beliefs?



Advertisement
Comments read comments(5)
post a comment
Paul Sheneman

posted September 15, 2009 at 12:01 am


It seems like there is a mixing of relational proximity in your ethical investigation. At one point you present an example relating to a “friend” and then after that you talk about your politic regarding “people around you”. I think that the distinction needs to be made because we have a different set of responsibilities to these two groups of people.
For friends, I would say that we have a responsibility to carry on a meaningful dialogue on our behavior in order to edify and improve one another. In a “Facebook culture”, where “friendship” is determined by a sharing of some digital information, I think that we might be hard pressed to have a meaningful dialogue concerning our responsibility to one another. However, Aristotle’s view of friendship might be an oddly fresh and desired perspective in our day. Concerning friendship he wrote: “Friends are an aid to the young, to guard them from error; to the elderly, to attend to their wants and to supplement their failing power of action; to those in the prime of life, to assist them to noble deeds.”
Concerning our interaction with “people around you”, I think that we need to constantly discern the moments where our voice will correct an injustice to another person (examples: racisim, sexism, age discrimination, etc.) and when our comments are just pushing a personal agenda. The one who stands up for injustice should get some virtue street cred. The one who pushes their own views onto others should have their ethical credit report tarnished.



report abuse
 

Hillary Fields

posted September 15, 2009 at 11:36 am


Paul – I love what you’ve said here. A million years ago I read Aristotle on friendship, but all I recall off the top of my head was the three types of friendship: Friends of utility, convenience, and true friends, I think it was? In any case, I think your comment was spot on – especially the part about ‘to those in the prime of life, to assist them to noble deeds’. Thanks for making me think.
–Hillary



report abuse
 

Steve Allen

posted September 16, 2009 at 1:53 am


Hi Padmini. I found your article very helpful. So helpful, in fact, that I’m planning to use it as a discussion started for a small-group Bible study I’ll be leading later this week. I hope that’s OK, but it fits in well with the story we’ll be looking at about Jesus being criticized for hanging around with disreputable types. I think your article will kick things off nicely. Thanks.



report abuse
 

Padmini

posted September 16, 2009 at 10:42 pm


Hi Steve, I should thank you, it thrills me to know my thoughts will serve a useful purpose. I hope you’ll let us know how your discussion goes!



report abuse
 

Steve Allen

posted September 18, 2009 at 5:40 pm


Hi again Padmini. We had our bible study last night, and your article worked really well as a discussion starter. After reading it out, I followed it up by asking “So…does it matter who we hang around with?”
Then we looked at the story in Mark Ch 2 of Jesus copping criticism for eating with undesirables, and I asked “does it matter who JESUS hung around with?” We noted from the thrust of the story in its context is that Jesus is not like the rest of us. He pictured himself as the doctor, and the rest of us as the patients in need of “hanging around” with him.
So thanks again for some thought provoking material. I’ll be lurking here for more.



report abuse
 

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the beliefnet.com terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to beliefnet.com and may be used by beliefnet.com in accordance with the agreements.



Previous Posts

More Blogs To Enjoy!
Thank you for visiting Everyday Ethics. This blog is no longer being updated. Please enjoy the archives. Here are some other blogs you may also enjoy: Idol Chatter Most Recent Inspiration blog post Happy Reading!

posted 3:53:05pm Sep. 07, 2012 | read full post »

Coding Ethics...
Internet activist and New York Times bestselling author of The Filter Bubble: What the Internet Is Hiding from You, Eli Pariser is concerned that information gatekeepers of the past (i.e. editors/reporters) have been replaced by algorithms that individually tailor information based upon a host of v

posted 2:49:15pm Jan. 22, 2012 | read full post »

Can Ethical Companies Do Business With Unethical Leaders?
Coca-cola has been accused of "propping up a notorious Swaziland dictator" whose human rights abuses and bilking of the national wealth has long been criticized by human rights activists. According to Guardian UK reporter David Smith**, Swaziland's King Mswati III is Africa's last absolute monarch w

posted 3:49:39pm Jan. 02, 2012 | read full post »

New Years Resolutions: Are We Lying to Ourselves?
I know it's become popular, but I've become suspect of using traditional goal-setting strategies and business process techniques to change personal habits and pursue a meaningful life. While I can admit that there's something invigorating--even exciting--about casting a new vision, writing that list

posted 10:51:42pm Jan. 01, 2012 | read full post »

Is Craigslist Who We Really Are?
Raise your hand if you're familiar with Craigslist.org.  Chances are, there's one that serves your community.  And it's extremely handy for job listings, housing, dating, selling your old crap or buying new old crap.Really, it's ingenious. But why's it also so darn discouraging?  

posted 9:15:55am Dec. 18, 2009 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.