Dream Gates

Dream Gates

When Massachusetts banned Christmas

Puritan.jpgThe Grinch stole Christmas in Massachusetts – for 22 years. The Puritans banned Christmas and its observance was illegal from 1659 until 1681. Their motivation was stated by the Reverend Increase Mather as follows: 

“The early Christians who  first observed the
Nativity on December 25 did not do so thinking that Christ was born in that
Month, but because the Heathens’ Saturnalia was at that time kept in Rome, and
they were willing to have those Pagan Holidays metamorphosed into Christian
ones.” [1]

In other words, the origin of Christmas was pagan. The Puritans of Massachusetts were not the first to come up with this idea; it had long been common knowledge. Nor were they the first to try to take the merry out of Christmas; in 1647, Cromwell’s parliament in England had banned Christmas and made it a crime to bake Christmas puddings (a situation corrected with the Stuart Restoration in 1660).

Wrong about many things – including the infamous Salem witch-hunts – the Puritans of Massachusetts may have been correct in their belief that both the date of Christmas, and many of the best-beloved customs and legends that surround it, have their origins in the old religions that long pre-date the birth of Jesus.

Nobody knows for sure when Jesus was born, but it is rather unlikely that it was on December 25th. The famous early bishop, Clement of Alexandria, who died in 215, wrote that many Christians in his day believed that Jesus was born in April. December 25 was only recognized as the birthday of Jesus by the Church in Rome in the mid-fourth century, and it took centuries for the date to be adopted by Christian congregations elsewhere. The church in Jerusalem only adopted the date in the 7th century. It took England a century longer.

On the other hand, the significance of December 25 in the pagan calendar had long been established. Under The Julian calendar, instituted by command of Julius Caesar in 45 BCE, December 25 was made the date of Bruma, the “shortest” day, meaning the winter solstice. Early European peoples honored the winter solstice as the day of the re-birth of the sun, personified as a god by some, a goddess by others.

 In 274, the soldier-emperor Aurelian proclaimed that December 25 was the birthday of Sol Invictus, the Unconquered Sun. This was a composite deity he hoped would be acceptable to believers of all persuasions, including the old worshippers of Helios-Apollo and the Roman legionaries who had adopted the cult of Mithras, a god from the East whose birth from a cave was already celebrated on December 25. So the day we now celebrate as Christmas became Dies Natalis Solis Invicti, the Day of the Unconquered Son.

Against this backdrop, it seems more likely than not that intelligent leaders of the early Church were inspired to move Jesus’ birthday to December 25 to claim the glamor of the old winter solstice festivals and to match the religious calendar to the celestial calendar in the way that early peoples had always done, making the coming of the Christos coincide with the re-birth of the sun. This, at any rate, was the opinion of a learned Syriac scholiast who wrote in the 12th century:

It was a
custom of the pagans to celebrate on the same 25 December the birthday of the sun, at which they kindled lights in token of festivity. In these solemnities
and revelries the Christians also took part. Accordingly when the doctors of
the Church perceived that the Christians had a leaning to this festival, they
took counsel and resolved that the true Nativity should be solemnized on that
day.” [2]


Syncretism – the bringing together of different strands of belief and custom – was characteristic of the old Roman religions; in the mid-4th century, when the Christian leaders chose to make December 25 the birthday of Jesus, it became an act of Church policy. In a ceiling mosaic in the tomb of the Julii, in the necropolis under St Peter’s, we have an arresting visual image of the convergence of the old solar cult with the new religion. It shows the figure of Sol-Helios, the sun god, riding his chariot. Around 250, his image was touched up, to make the rays around his head resemble a cross.

When we look at the customs and symbols of Christmas that are most loved in our families today, we find that many of them are of pagan origin: the Christmas tree, for starters, but also the holy and the ivy, the mistletoe, the yule log, the giving of gifts, the reindeer that fly through the sky. An early Christian grinch in Britain, Polydor Virgil, thundered that “dancing, masques, mummeries, stageplays, and other
such Christmas disorders now in use with Christians, were derived from these
Roman Saturnalian and Bacchanalian festivals; which should cause all pious
Christians eternally to abominate them.

The happy news is that the grinches will never win (though I’m not so sure about the retailers). The sun returns, and at Christmas all peoples of good heart will share gifts of light and love.]

[1]Increase Mather, A Testimony against Several Prophane and Superstitious Customs, Now Practiced by Some in New England (1687) quoted in Stephen Nissenbaum, The Battle for Christmas: A Cultural History of America’s Most Cherished Holiday, New York: Vintage Books, 1997, p. 2. 

[2] Ramsay MacMullen, Christianity and Paganism in the Fourth to Eighth Centuries, New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997, p. 155 

Puritan Grinch: I found this marvelous image at Without Shoes

  • Cheryl Umberger

    Thanks for this concise clarification of the variety of history that colors our Christmas! I share little bits of all of the mythologies with my children each year. Well done here.

  • Robert Moss

    Cheryl, Thank you. Joyous Solstice and Merry Christmas.

  • Savannah

    That illustration is terrific! The Puritan appears to be missing half an index finger… I wonder if he wore it down pointing fingers at people of good cheer. This is such a fabulous overview Robert, and very illuminating to me. Thank you so much!

  • Wanda Burch

    Great synopsis. The Massachusetts Puritans actually charged a 5 pound fine on those who “impiously celebrated” Christmas, not repealed until Charles II resumed the English throne.
    And of course the real celebrations in 18th century America were Old Christmas, 12th night – January 6 – which evolved from the Roman Saturnalia festival marking the onset of the winter solstice as the sun began its rise toward the longer, warmer days. The festivals were filled with feasting and drinking, Yule logs, the 12th night cake with the hidden bean or ring and my favorite – “wassailing the apple trees.” Spiced cider called “lamb’s wool” was poured ceremonially at the base of apple trees to ensure a bountiful harvest in the coming year.
    There is a fabulous letter from my favorite Mohawk Valley missionary and whiner – Samuel Kirkland – in 1769, complaining that the residents go to church on Christmas day, as they ought, but then spend the rest of the day, after they set the servants free, drinking, fighting, swearing, and frolicking, which “seems essential to the joy of the day!”

  • Robert Moss

    Wanda – ah, yes, Samuel Kirkland. Thanks for reminding me, and for that wickedly funny characterization.

  • Robert Moss

    Thanks, Savannah. I love the Puritan image and have been trying to track the source.

  • Gregory Sams

    Well, I’d have to support the grinches banning Christmas but they might not agree to my suggestion we replace it with Solarmass. Let’s get back to the roots of this celebration which acknowledges the actual ‘light of life,’ our radiant local star, the Sun. Let’s give it some real meaning and celebrate all the harder!
    Gregory Sams, author of “Sun of gOd”

  • Irene

    I’m a bit surprised by the image on the mosaic. I recently fell from my horse (because my left stirup broke in flight) and this is the 3rd image I’ve seen of a horse or horses jumping up on the left side of a person (or another horse) in the past 24 hours. The other two images appear on December of my 2010 calander and on the cover of the book I’m currently reading. Oddly enough, all three images are colored green and yellow-gold. Hmmmmmm…..

  • Robert Moss

    Dear Irene, Hope you are mending well. Life rhymes, and sometimes jumps…

  • http://AddaURLtothiscomment judi

    Fabulous….love the ancient and hidden meanings revealed…

  • Pingback: Grumbling About Greetings « Off the Beaten Path

Previous Posts

In the dream kitchen
In my night dreams, the place of creation is often a kitchen. I don’t do a lot of cooking, but I love the image of the kitchen — where we are fed and nourished and we mix things together and cook things up — as the creative center. I especially like to think of the creative process as being

posted 4:55:30am Mar. 29, 2015 | read full post »

Seven Open Secrets of Imagination
The greatest crisis in our lives is a crisis of imagination. We get stuck and set ourselves up for failure because we buy into a limited or self-defeating version of reality, and refuse to see our situation differently. The answer lies within us, in the power of imagination. We are ruled by image

posted 11:34:19am Mar. 07, 2015 | read full post »

As Lady Sarashina crossed a bridge of dreams
From a thousand years ago, in a slim autobiographical novel gusting with moonlight and desire, we have a dozen dreams of an anonymous Japanese woman wh

posted 10:40:02am Feb. 26, 2015 | read full post »

The first Valentine, from the captive prince
Why the day of Saint Valentine is associated with romantic love is a mystery. A couple of sainted Valentines, both martyred, are known to the early church but what little is known of them has nothing to do with romance. They are so obscure that the feast of St.Valentine was removed from the General

posted 2:17:39am Feb. 14, 2015 | read full post »

The best way to understand a dream
The best way to grasp the meaning of a dream, and to determine what action the dream requires, is to go back inside the dream and recover more of the story. We should never confuse a dream report - what we remember and can say about a dream - with the full experience of the dream itself. Even a very

posted 10:59:39am Jan. 22, 2015 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.