Doing Life Together

Doing Life Together


Move Over Wimbledon, Casey Anthony’s Closing Arguments

posted by Linda Mintle

I am a huge tennis fan and deeply disappointed in the lack of exciting American men on the tennis singles front. In the Wimbledon finals tomorrow, I will be routing for Nadal but where is the next McEnroe or Sampras? Since the Americans aren’t contenders, I’m probably switching to the Casey Anthony trial which, yes, is having closing arguments on a Sunday of a holiday weekend! What a bizarre case! I ‘m only sort of following it  because my 90 year old father was here for a month and watched the coverage every day. Evenings were spend processing the trial–who is the child’s real father, did the grandfather cover up the death, why would Casey party like a rock star when her child was missing….you get the drift!

So curiosity got the best of me and I decided to take a look at why mothers would kill their children. Here is what I found:

Psychiatrist Susan Friedman at the University Hospitals of Cleveland/Case Western identified five motives that might lead a mom to kill her child:

1) Maltreatment or chronic abuse
2) Mental illness that includes thoughts that killing a child is a type of mercy killing; the child is better off in heaven so killing is a deed of love
3) The child is unwanted
4) The mom is psychotic
5) The “Medea syndrome” -a parent kills the child as revenge against a partner.

Moms who kill their offspring may think they themselves need to be punished, or the children must be eliminated to preserve a relationship. Geoffrey McKee, a forensic psychologist who has studied homicidal mothers, adds to the above list:

1) Detached moms who may suffer from postpartum depression or fail to bond with their infants
2) Abusive and neglectful moms who act out rage and fail to meet their babies needs.

Michelle Oberman and Cheryl Meyer, coauthors of the book, Mothers Who Kill Children, agree that mental illness accounts for the majority of mother-child killings—depression, post partum depression, and other mental health afflictions but notes that the category of mothers who kill children is not homogenous. For example, the teen who kills her newborn baby may be motivated differently than the mom who drove herself and her children into the river to drown.  The authors also discuss common social factors such as isolation, a spilt with the father of the children, and lack of emotional support. A study in the Journal of the National Medical Association (Vol 95, No. 1, 2003) noted a high frequency of substance abuse and intellectual impairment among parents who kill their children.

At this point, we don’t  know if Casey Anthony  murdered her child and we may never know the full story. But following the case and looking at why a mom would do such a thing leaves you with chills. Come to think of it, maybe it would be better to watch the Wimbledon final, with or without an American man!

Or maybe the best thing to do is go to church like I always do and pray for this family. A child is dead and that is so sad. Perhaps somewhere in the middle of all this media frenzy, a revelation of our desperate need for God would be evident.

 



  • http://www.clinicalforensicpsychology.org Forensic Psychology

    Many thanks you for this blog which you have made by your patient and thinking power. You really know so much about this matter. You’ve covered so many bases Forensic Psychology. Great substance from this part of the internet.

Previous Posts

Mariah Carey and Nick Cannon Split: Telling All May Have Been Too Much
The gossip train is all a buzz with what looks like a split between pop diva, Mariah Carey and her husband, America's Got Talent host, Nick Cannon. The usual suspects, TMZ, People, Hollywood Life and others are reporting the spilt, saying divorce is a done deal. The six-year marriage that produced

posted 7:51:12am Aug. 22, 2014 | read full post »

Withholding Friendship as a Weapon
I'll never forget the day my five-year-old came home and said, "No one will play with 'Sandy' because she doesn't do what they say!" I was upset and thankfully, my daughter thought it was mean. But the other girls excluded little Sandy and rejected her from their friendship circle. Would you be

posted 7:00:24am Aug. 20, 2014 | read full post »

Look Before You Lock: Leaving Kids in Hot Cars
It's August. It's hot! You just need to run into the store for a few minutes to grab a few groceries. Your six-month-old is sleeping soundly and he really needs a nap. Should you leave him be and run in to the store? With all the news about children dying in hot cars, the Dr. Linda Mintle radio sh

posted 7:00:03am Aug. 18, 2014 | read full post »

More Bad News for Pot Smokers
As the legalization of marijuana gains momentum, more data pours in that is NOT good news. Here are some of the findings: Sometimes, marijuana is addictive. If you begin as a teen, you have a higher chance of developing an addiction. According to the National Institute of Drug Use, about 9% who

posted 7:00:03am Aug. 14, 2014 | read full post »

Robin Williams: Laughter and Sadness
The news that Robin Williams had died, hit me hard. This incredible funny man was introduced to me as an alien on Mork and Mindy. Immediately, one could see the quick wit of a comedian destined for stardom. He made us laugh! Then he broadened his stage to movies and made us cry, cheer and feel i

posted 6:19:47am Aug. 12, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.