The Deacon's Bench

The Deacon's Bench

Egan and Rudy, Part Deux

The controversy swirling around Rudy Giuliani receiving communion at St. Patrick’s just won’t stop.

The latest to weigh in is Phil Lawler at CWN, who notes:

In his public rebuke to Rudy Giuliani for improperly receiving Communion during Pope Benedict’s visit to New York, Cardinal Edward Egan raised two subtle but very interesting points. First, the cardinal says that Giuliani should not receive the Eucharist because of his support for legal abortion; he does not base his argument on Giuliani’s irregular marital status. Second, the cardinal reveals that he had reached a quiet agreement with Giuliani. The former New York mayor violated that agreement– apparently for his own political purposes.


But before discussing those rather subtle aspects of Cardinal Egan’s message, let’s begin with the obvious. Cardinal Egan deserves praise and thanks for his public statement, in which he shows himself to be a leader, a teacher, and a pastor of souls.

He goes on in that vein. You’ll want to read the rest. But I’m left with a curious feeling of dissatisfaction over this whole mess.

The simple fact is: Egan could indeed be considered a “leader, a teacher, and a pastor of souls” — if he had addressed this issue more than a week ago, when it happened. He didn’t. The event was widely noted (and seen on national television, with Rudy chomping on the Body of Christ as he wandered down the aisle) and the good Cardinal said nothing. He only responded after he was challenged on the issue by a nationally syndicated columnist.


If Robert Novak had never written on the subject, would Egan have said anything?

I have to wonder.

UPDATE: The Anchoress has some remarkably sensible thoughts on this matter:

There are lots of ways to scandalize a church or to desecrate the Holy Eucharist, and many people who are not public figures commune “unworthilly.” As near as I could tell Giuliani was the only one of the recipient pols caught on television cameras. I have to be honest, when I saw it, I thought, “he’s not supposed to be doing that…” but I also thought his mien and demeanor, his whole attitude was serious, thoughtful and yes, reverent – moreso than some of the others participating. I knew I was right smack dab in the middle of an abiding Mystery.


In the Apostles Creed, we’re told that Jesus “descended into hell” before he rose. In communion He descends into the hell of our own lives – all of our confusion, all of our sins those declared and those unfaced, all of our doubt, all of our love and our hate, all of our fear, our conscience, our deepest longings and our conscious and sub-conscious minds; our very souls – Jesus descends into it, and then we rise with Him. His very Blood courses through our veins.

This cannot leave us unchanged. Even if outwardly, we seem the same, inwardly, we have been penetrated. Some of us are very, very thick-walled; some of us have built astounding fortresses and battlements within us, and Jesus may very well want to go head-to-head, one-on-one so to speak, to tumble them. To descend into our personal “hells” in order to help us rise from them. He is, after all, the Divine Physician. Paul gave us an ideal and a basis for law. But Jesus has always been – ultimately – bigger than all of it.

And so, no…for all that I accept the validity of those crying “scandal,” I cannot cry it myself.

Check out the rest of her post and see what you think.

Comments read comments(3)
post a comment

posted April 29, 2008 at 1:52 pm

If you read the comments after the web edition of the New York Post article, you get an incite into what people in general (many of whom are non-Catholic)think about this Giuliani-Egan tift. From the comments left by many, many people, it seems that quite a few people think that Egan has surrendered his moral leadership authority in this matter by virtue of his involvement in the pedophilia scandal during his tenure with the Diocese of Bridgeport. To paraphrase many of the comments: “If you harbored or moved priests with pedophilia tendencies from one parish to another while you were the bishop of the Bridgeport diocese, who are you to tell Rudy Giuliani that he can’t receive the Eucharist?”

report abuse

Brian P. Craig

posted April 29, 2008 at 2:24 pm

Very interesting point, Scott, and one I think the pro-abortion politicians always have at the ready. On the other hand, at some point someone has to stand up and defend publicly the Church’s teachings on abortion, human sexuality, and the overall dignity of the human person, as well as enforce the Church’s canon law. Even if that person risks his or friendship with members of the power elite.But sadly, I think the Cardinal invited this fine mess on himself by allowing Giuliani to take his VIP seat at Mass and not reminding the former mayor of their so-called agreement. My heart hopes and prays that the timing of Cardinal Egan’s rebuke was merely coincidental with the appearance of Novak’s article, but my head suggests otherwise.

report abuse


posted April 29, 2008 at 2:47 pm

I agree with you, Craig, about the Cardinal inviting this situation himself. Surely Archbishop Wuerl in Washington and Cardinal Egan in New York knew that reception of the Eucharist by pro-abortion politicians at the two Masses would be a hot issue. Yet, politicians such as Kennedy, Pelosi, Kerry, & Giuliani were invited to the Masses. As guardian of the invitation list in New York, why did Egan invite Guiliani in the first place? It was obvious that the media were prepped and ready for the glimpse of Giuliani receiving Communion.

report abuse

Post a Comment

By submitting these comments, I agree to the terms of service, rules of conduct and privacy policy (the "agreements"). I understand and agree that any content I post is licensed to and may be used by in accordance with the agreements.

Previous Posts

This blog is no longer active
This blog is no longer being actively updated. Please feel free to browse the archives or: Read our most popular inspiration blog See our most popular inspirational video Take our most popular quiz ...

posted 10:42:40pm Dec. 12, 2010 | read full post »

One day more
A reminder: "The Deacon's Bench" is closed! Please enjoy the archives! ...

posted 11:26:20pm Dec. 11, 2010 | read full post »

Meet Montana's married priest
Earlier this week, I posted an item about Montana getting its first married priest. Now a local TV station has hopped on the bandwagon. Take a look, below. ...

posted 10:29:55pm Dec. 11, 2010 | read full post »

Big day in the Big Easy: 10 new deacons
Deacon Mike Talbot has the scoop: 10 men today were ordained as Permanent Deacons for the Archdiocese of New Orleans. This group of men was formally selected on the day the evacuation of New Orleans began as Hurricane Katrina approached. The ...

posted 6:55:42pm Dec. 11, 2010 | read full post »

Gaudete! And let's break out a carol or two...
"Gesu Bambino," anyone? This is one of my favorites, and nobody does it better than these gals: Kathleen Battle and Frederica von Staade. Enjoy. ...

posted 1:04:10pm Dec. 11, 2010 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.