City of Brass

City of Brass

a Chinese-American reader comments on the Uyghur

The following was a comment left by reader Gerald of Atlanta on my previous post. I am reproducing it in its entirety.

UPDATE: I misidentified the reader as an Uyghur, actually he is descended from Chinese Hui muslims. I apologise for the mistake. I think his commentary is very valuable regardless of his background, which is why I shared it here.

I am a third generation American citizen and I have visited Xinjiang 5 times in the past decade, spending about 1 year there total. My grandfather – may God have mercy on him – was a Hui who left China more than sixty years ago. I speak mandarin and understand Islamic faith, history, culture and practices. I have studied political philosophy and comparative government.


This article is spot on in its description of the PRC government’s active religious persecution of Uighurs. Because Islam is also central to the Uighur culture, the persecution is also cultural. Forcing kids at school to eat oranges during Ramadan, banning the youth from entering masjids, locking up middle schoolers in jail for trying to learn how to read Quran, prohibiting Uighurs from international travel and domestic movement by confiscating passports and refusing hu kou changes, blatant ethnic discrimination by police and government intimidation of those who wear scarf and those who grow beards are all actions that I have heard – if not seen – first hand. The PRC fears separatism and dissent; like many other governments it prefers a stability imposed by brutal force over the perception that an indigenous people can somehow have legitimate grievances.


To its credit, the PRC does have affirmative action programs for higher education as well as more lax childbirth policies for minorities, including Uighurs. The PRC wants to help Uighurs become literate in han language so that they may be enfranchised, empowered and integrated into greater han society. The PRC correctly boasts that since it has taken the reins on controlling economic development in Xinjiang for the past thirty years, residents of all ethnicities have benefited greatly in terms of standard of life, even if Hans have enjoyed greater economic prosperity than Uighurs. There are new roads being paved, highrises being built and infrastructure being developed where Uighurs once saw dirt roads and mud houses. But then again, this type of improvement in the standard of living is by no measure extraordinary when compared with other countries around the world.


One has to view PRC’s ‘well-intentioned’ efforts in the proper context. The PRC is an authoritarian government with an atheist – if no longer Marxist – view of religion. A predominantly materialist / economic approach to the development of a society, as we are seeing in the PRC today, necessitates that preservation of heterogenous culture or religion take a backseat to maintaining the stability that the PRC believes economic development requires. Needless to say many Uighurs find preserving their religion and culture to be more important than the pursuit of money and economic development. It is with this clash of philosophy and modus operandi that the PRC has approached and governed the indigenous Uighurs in Xinjiang. In laymen’s terms, the PRC has taken on what we westerners call the “white man’s burden.”


Civilizing a ‘backwards’ people who are naturally resistant to being pacified is no easy task. In the case of the Uighurs, they have a dogmatic attachment to Islam; they want to pray, fast, read a holy book in a foreign language and spend their life savings on performing a pilgramage. This contrasts sharply with the culture and aspirations of your average Han today: the pursuit of money and material wealth. The PRC has found that most – if not all – of the Uighur resistance to PRC pacification comes from those who espouse a deep faith in Islam. These are people who do not fear imprisonment nor death and therefore will speak out and even fight against what they rightly view as injustice. As a result, the PRC feels threatened by all religious Uighurs and redouble their efforts to suppress them by all means. It is unfortunate because while it is true that most resisters are religious, most religious people are not resisters. Currently, the PRC is rounding up young Uighurs all across Xinjiang. Those shown in a court of law to have been involved in the riots and deaths in Urumqi will be sentenced and put to death. Thousands more will be summarily and indefinitely detained. If the PRC does like it did in 1997, hundreds if not thousands of young Uighur males will just be disappeared.


There is much doublespeak in PRC. There is talk of protecting and supporting minorities by subsidizing mosques and putting imams on the PRC payroll. But the Uighurs see this as the government interfering and controlling Muslim institutions. Go to a mosque in Xinjiang and try to get him to teach you about Islam between prayers. The imam will refuse to engage you. His role by PRC mandate is only to lead the five prayers in the mosque and preside over the friday prayer. The PRC ensures that most friday prayer sermons at large masjids are substantially void of substance. Ask a PRC official why praying or fasting is prohibited in school and the most intelligent reply you will hear is that students and their studies must be protected from the interruptions of prayer and the weakness that comes from fasting. Actually, on second thought, DON’T ask a PRC official. Snoop around a little in Xinjiang and you will quickly become persona non grata, because in case you have yet concluded, there is no freedom of speech there. PRC involvement in the institutions of Islam are not for the purpose of protecting nor propagating Islam but to rather gradually smother out the elements it finds disagreeable – essentially gutting it.


With regards to Chinese patriotism and nationalism:

Most Chinese nationals today will quickly come to the defense of the PRC government whenever it is criticized. There are many issues and currents at play here. Among them: the natural tendency to view international criticism of a domestic policy as a deconstructive attack, the complete lack of understanding of the situation in Xinjiang (because society and government in Xinjiang and Tibet are so different from other provinces), an ethnocentric approach to problem, the complete lack of dissent culture in China and just plain ignorance. By ethnocentric approach I mean that to the majority of Chinese citizens, little is more important than making money and helping their children get into the best college possible. By this rubric, han citizens feel the Uighurs are unappreciative of the extra points they get for college entrance exams and the substantial economic and industrial development in Xinjiang at the hands of the PRC. By plain ignorance, I mean that there is a whole generation of twenty to thirty somethings in China that never studied and know nothing about the history of the arbitrary, brutal and authoritarian nature of their government. For example, they do not know that fifty years ago, Mao had no idea what he was doing and that millions of people starved for it. They do not understand that while the PRC is gradually reforming itself, it can at a moment’s notice unleash a very brutal authoritarian action upon its own citizens (as has happened many times in Xinjiang and Tibet over the decades).


While there have been forced abortions and sterilizations, I have not seen a level of violence against the Uighurs in the past decade that warrant using the word genocide. The word – except when used figuratively (e.g. cultural genocide) – should be respectfully reserved for the Armenians and the Jews; its use here by those defending the PRC’s actions is a red herring and or some type of polemic digression from the reality that Uighurs are being repressed and oppressed in their own land.

According to several Uighurs and Huis I have spoken to recently, there has been substantial improvement in the past decade in Xinjiang (but the recent riots will set back progress for months if not years). For the sake of all Chinese citizens, I hope the PRC finds more just ways to govern its people and its land.

Comments read comments(4)
post a comment
Andrew James

posted July 24, 2009 at 7:15 pm
The western media is extremely biased and took all the face value of the Chinese Media, who is trying to do coverup an ongoing genocide going on towards Uyghurs ( Uighur ) and they don’t cover news like this at all!!! We must stop this!!! Is it possible for western media to send a team person to the Uyghur families in Urumqi and other parts of East Turkistan and do some statistics from them(not from Chinese Media) and check whether any Uyghur men left in the family? Even the 6 year old Uyghur kids are in jail as shown on the above images and are being genocided now!!!
Don’t think you are innocent or tell me this is not related to you or none of your business as you are also indirectly responsible for this, by buying Chinese stuff, by taking all the things that Chinese media says at its face value, by having a relationship with the most brutal, autocratic country in the world and supplying them with your countries resources!!! Boycott Chinese goods now and put an economic sanction against China who are genociding its minorities with the heinous crimes and crimes against humanity!!!
Until you take actions, everything you eat, drink or do has a blood of Uyghurs and Uyghur Children as you implicitly sponsoring the open genocide going on China, by not speaking up, by buying their stuff and by having economical and political relations with China.
There are probably hundreds of thousands of them are in jail and being genocided!!! It is your responsibility to have all of those arrested innocent kids, Uyghurs released and stop the genocide that is going on now!!!
Act now by boycotting Chinese goods, put sanctions against China and putting pressure on them to release all the arrested innocent Uyghur Childen and the Uyghurs!! We can do it and we must do it!!
I also have attached the link and video and pictures of a heinous crime and crimes against humanity which are going on in China even now! The video is shot on July 7th, 2009 as shown on the video time. This is only tip of the iceberg as such genocide is going on everday, every hour behind the closed doors since the Chinese occupation of East Turkistan!!!
The two lying are arrested two Uyghur college students and the people killing them are Chinese Paramilitary forces?It was leaked out to Chinese media at first and I came across to it on youtube, but it is no longer there anymore. This is all related to the July 5th demonstration in Urumqi and as reported by the Chinese Media, there are thousands of Uyghur students were arrested.(Probably much, much more as Chinese Media is not reliable at all). There are possibly hundreds of thousands Uyghurs are arrested by now and there are already reports mass execution of Uyghurs(196 Uyghurs executed at one time):
This is going on for a very long time as hundreds of thousands of Uyghur College kids were brutally murdered in the similar way for the 1997 Yili Uprising and Chinese is doing it behind the screen for many, many years. This is a total genocide against the Uyghurs and you will be shocked by the extent. Western Media will never know as most things are kept behind the door. Go and visit any Uyghur family in Ghulja(Yining) or any other town where the Uyghurs live and ask them about their sons, daughters. You will be shocked that most families children at the age 14-35 were absent as they are rounded up by the police and brutally murdered.
Also look at the link from New York Times where it reports that Uyghur families sons, some of them are barely teens were rounded up and no one knows their whereabouts after their arrest and their families are extremely concerned as this is going on for a very long time and the attached images.
The FinancialTimes is also reporting massive arrests of Uyghurs and since the prisons are full, they held at army warehouses now.
According to the statistics provided by Soviet Union and relevant Turkish sources, the Uyghurs are 35 million back in 1949 and now after more than 60 years of Chinese occupation, it dropped to mere 8 million. The red Chinese stoned to death more than 27 million Uyghurs during those years and no one in the west know about or heard about it!
I also sent another link where the Chinese Mob killing the Uyghur factory workers in Guangdong!
We must stop this atrocity and crimes against humanity as Uyghurs nowhere to turn and Chinese are truly genociding them in their own homeland in order to make sure that East Turkistan is theirs forever and get rid of all the Uyghurs. They have already destroyed the Uyghurs culture and the ancient cities like Kashgar in order to wipe them out from earth…
Thanks for your support!

report abuse


posted July 25, 2009 at 12:24 pm

I applaud your call to action for the rights of the Uyghurs in China. However, I humbly and respectfully suggest that this is a hollow request if you are not also willing to make a similar call to action for religious freedom to Muslim countries that directly and intentionally oppress Christians within their countries. For example, Kyrgyzstan just passed an anti-conversion law. Why cannot individuals freely choose how they can express their spiritual life? Why are Muslims afraid of allowing people this basic human right?
To have any integrity, your call must also be to those countries of the Arabian Peninsula, Central Asia, Indonesia, etc. As you know, here in the USA you are free to worship as you please. This right to choose your spiritual expression should be universal, not just when oppression is expressed against the Muslim community.

report abuse

Iqbal M. Tufail

posted July 27, 2009 at 12:19 pm

Dear Christian writer,
I will agree with you that one should be allowed to choose a religious belief, however most of the Christian institutions are highly funded and have organized programs to convert poor and under classes and under privileged with deceptive tactics and tools such as : food, medicine and providing immigration to new converts to western countries and many more psychological enticements ….people in rural and poor Ares do not understand these tactics therefore they are enticed towards Christianity …to illustrate my point is Christians are utterly unsuccessful in western hemisphere to either convert or bring non church going to church….the moment an average person sees a Christian propagating or convincing one to come to church I assure one have to see the expression on their faces that here he or she comes !!! Most people do not even open their doors.
However Muslims should use same tactics to propagate their point of view, not by deception but with real and genuine concern for humanity and governments should not use laws to deter such conversion however should provide incentives like western Christians are provided and this can not be accomplished till we have kingdoms and authorization governments and week leaders who have no concern for their own people or are western puppets.

report abuse

oyun oyna

posted July 31, 2009 at 3:56 am

Thanks for you for article..
oyun oyna

report abuse

Previous Posts

Deen and Mohabbat: There is no faith without love
This is a guest post by Yusuf Zakir. My religion--Islam--is discussed and portrayed in the media quite a lot these days, much to my chagrin. The American public is, generally, fearful of Muslims. Anti-Islamic sentiment is at an all-time ...

posted 10:10:30pm Oct. 07, 2015 | read full post »

nationwide hate rallies planned at mosques Oct 9-10, Homeland Security conf call
This weekend, there is a planned, armed protest "in every country, at every mosque" by a group called the "Global Rally for Humanity". So far, the protests are falling short of global, but they do have 21 mosques, community centers and ...

posted 1:40:08pm Oct. 06, 2015 | read full post »

why don't they condemn?
Ever since 9-11, and well before it, this is the litany of accusation that ordinary Muslim Americans have had to endure: Muslims do not condemn - there is no million Muslim march against terrorism. Islam is an inherently violent ...

posted 1:47:45pm Oct. 02, 2015 | read full post »

a Republican, Muslim Mayor of St Louis?
Umar Lee is many things - a native ...

posted 1:09:57am Sep. 30, 2015 | read full post »

Abrahamic Convergence - inspiration, forgiveness, and tragedy
This week is a truly portentous one for Muslims, Jews, and Catholics. In one week, we have Yom Kippur, the Day of Arafat and Eid ul Adha, and Pope Francis' first visit to the United States. I like the term "Abrahamic Convergence" for this sort ...

posted 3:08:38pm Sep. 24, 2015 | read full post »


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.