Advertisement

City of Brass

City of Brass

muslim pseudoscience: prostration

It took a profound atheist like Douglas Adams to recognize and succinctly state what should be obvious to any believer: “proof denies faith“. The essence of faith is to believe, and proof essentially makes the process of belief irrelevant. Thus I have a history of arguing with others, muslim or otherwise, who purport to have proved the unprovable.

pseudoscience is a closely related endeavour – instead of proving God, it seeks to wrap religion in th elegitimacy of science. In doing so, the very essence of religion is again denied, implying that it needs science to be valid. Unfortunately, the quality of the science itself is so poor as to be nonsensical, invariably. Thus I am doubly offended by such efforts, as a man of faith and as a scientist.

Advertisement

Unfortunately I tend to get most of this kind of thing from my friends and family, via email. Rather than annoy them with my snotty attitude about why its all wrong, I’m using the blog as an outlet. So, consider this the inauguration of a series of sorts.

This is a slideshow I have received from multiple sources, purporting to explain how the act of protration (sajda) in the muslim prayer is actually beneficial from a health perspective, because it spposedly discharges harmful electromagnetic energy built up in our bodies, harmlessly into the ground.

Advertisement

The flaws in the argument are numerous but let’s start with some of the most egregious: the human body does not accumulate charge internally like a capacitor, though we can acumulate some (much lower voltage) of charge on our outer surfaces. In other words, the normal static shock that we all get from walking across a shag rug. The ambient electric field from our myriad gadgets and neon lights and whatnot do not contribute any charge to our bodies in the slightest, however. Let’s also note for the record that on teh surface of a sphere like teh Earth, ANY point on the surface is technically and literally the “center”, so the point about Mecca being the “true” center of the world is also essentially meaningless (though not exactly untrue).

Anyway there is surely a LOT more I could nitpick with this one but I’ll leave it at that.

  • http://amuslimanon.blogspot.com A Not Yet Woolen Muslim

    Succintly put. I agree.
    But some people could point to other benefits of prostration. I.e. gastrointestinal alignment, mental effect of prostrating while proclaiming the greatness of Allah, or effect of daily repetitive motion. You could actually make mildly more logical arguments for those (a lot more in the case of the second). Do those offend you as much?

  • Lukmahn

    You do have a good point there brother…rather strong, but a point none the less! So science agrees with Islam, so what…in the science of its inception, many would have written off the prophet (SAW) as a mad man, and there’s no evidence that the discoveries of the future may/ may not take a slight twist from today’s!!
    But on the other hand, as a scientist, I’m sure you too must be intrigued by the wealth of knowledge, especially of scientific bias that can be found in Qur’anic text. Especially since there is alot of criticism against Islam and its scripture form non-believers and here we have their most reputed/ celebrated body of knowledge in constant agreement with the same religion. Further more, since almost all other scriptural text only seem to garner inconsistency!! It smacks of full back-handed sarcasm.
    I can personally can vouch that even though I was born and raised in a Muslim family and never doubted my faith till then, but it was until I began to have some interest in academics (and sciences in particularly) and reading the Qur’an more contemplatively that my conviction and confidence in Islam really started to grow. I mean these are both bodies of knowledge and to find corroborative growth in both must be a source of great encouragement to anyone on a truth quest.
    It is rather irritating to see people derive inspiration in faith from scientific progress (proofs), but if they just happen to be true … where’s the harm in having a perspective?

  • Doubt the Doubter

    I don’t know if Mecca is the center or not, but Earth is certainly not a Sphere. So NO, any point on the surface cannot be taken as the ‘center’ as mentioned in your article.

  • http://authenticatevideo.blogspot.com Meredith Lam

    Very interesting writing. Truely.

Previous Posts

Ramadan Pearls 05 - objective
As for the men of knowledge of the hereafter, what they mean by the correctness of fasting is its acceptability; and the acceptability of the fast is whether or not it has enabled one to reach one's objective. They understand the objective of ...

posted 7:26:32am Jul. 05, 2015 | read full post »

The Fourth and the First
This evening, just prior to sunrise, members of my mosque in Los Angeles gathered round to raise the flag of the United States of America. Due to fortuitous timing, just as the flag was unfurled, a squadron of planes flew overhead in formation, ...

posted 12:38:00am Jul. 05, 2015 | read full post »

Ramadan Pearls 04 - angels
He who has fasted for Allah, the Glorious and Mighty, and is in the discomfort of heat and struck by thirst, will have his face wiped and be given the good news by a thousand angels whom Allah has entrusted to him until he breaks his fast; at ...

posted 8:16:29am Jul. 03, 2015 | read full post »

ibadat in Ramadan - process as piety
There are a lot of articles written during Ramadan about what Ramadan means, about what we as Muslims should be "getting out" of Ramadan, what the benefits of Ramadan should be. But I think that these sorts of articles miss the point of ibadat. ...

posted 10:20:36am Jul. 02, 2015 | read full post »

Ramadan Pearls 03 - mystery
Know that the goal in fasting is for the veil of appetite and anger to be lifted from the heart's eye so that the heart may see the mystery of the dominion of heaven and earth. (The Easy Roads of Sayf al-Din, as translated by William Chittick ...

posted 8:57:01am Jul. 01, 2015 | read full post »

Advertisement


Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.