Beginner's Heart

Beginner's Heart


teaching for change

via  The New Yorker

via The New Yorker

Warning: the following material may confuse you, or even make your head hurt. Because who knew it was sooo hard to effect change??

Teachers, that’s who. Especially teachers of young adults. Because when you’re little, learning is still FUN. There are cool toys that teach: blocks, puzzles, word games. And there are crayons, scissors, and little books. It’s all a kind of game.

And then testing and GRADES enter the picture. It’s obvious to students that we care far less about learning than grades. At least teachers — and students, and sometimes parents — know this.

But this isn’t a discussion of how misguided standardised testing is. I wish such a conversation would change policy, but I’ve had similar wishes and they don’t come true. There’s far too many $$ at stake (and yes, I’m that cynical…just follow the money, and you will be too).

Instead, I’d like us to look at a new study. One that examines how minds change. And the bad news: most of the time, they don’t.

We seem to have forgotten that the expression

“a liberal education” originally meant

among the Roman one worthy of free men.

                       ~ Henry David Thoreau

Brendan Nyhan, a professor of political science at Dartmouth who conducted the study, is automatically suspect to many neo-cons. I’ve talked recently about why so many neo-cons are anti-university, but suffice to say that a good education should include critical thinking. And if you think critically, you will eventually question all assumptions — including religious beliefs. Note: I know MANY academics who believe in various wisdom traditions, ranging from conservative Christianity to Islam to Hinduism to Buddhism to Unitarianism to Wicca. And more. Belief needn’t be antithetical to critical thinking.

Here’s what Nyhan’s study found, basically: people don’t change their opinions on things because of facts. Almost ever.Pen on journal pageWow. How depressing is THAT??

So what — if anything — can help us bridge the intolerable chasm of hate & distrust that divides the country these days? I’ll give you one guess:

Writing. Teaching writing. NOT to  the test, folks, but to the future. Teaching for change, despite what a certain highly unpleasant radio talk show host says.

If we ask students to affirm their own self-worth, they don’t cavil so at evidence that counters beliefs. It’s only, in other words, when we feel our own selves threatened that we refuse to see reason.

I know this from my own teaching. Offering students readings, and then asking them to write, is one thing. Offer writing that’s fun, that affirms their value as people, then let’s discuss readings that may not go along with what you think you already know.

via google

via google

Take Columbus (please). First slave-taker in the Americas, genocidist, and very bad man. Seriously. Lots of discussion at the time — this isn’t re-making history. But folks don’t like that reading. I was once roundly chastised by a teacher in a workshop for clarifying the ‘history’ of Columbus. He was a hero! my colleague insisted. Weeellll, not so much.

No ‘facts’ I could give her would change her opinion. At least not then. But because she was a very good teacher, and a seed of doubt had been planted (and because I let it go: it wasn’t important to me that she ‘convert,’  but that she possibly listen), she eventually researched this history on her own. And changed her mind.

changing mind2Note: I don’t think that I changed her mind. But I didn’t make it up for her, either: I didn’t challenge her, call her dumb, or anything. I just let it go. (True confessions time: I can’t always be that smart or dispassionate, unfortunately!) So she didn’t have any of her own self tied up w/ the information/ facts/ decision to update what she had been taught.

That’s what writing and good teaching can do, y’all. CHANGE MINDS. If we let students write, explore their own self-value and  values, we can teach them love, compassion, and all the various necessary components for a peaceful world.

And right now? We seriously need to work on that.



Previous Posts

a happy birthday for my beloved
If you've been following the blog, you know that my beloved broke his ankle about 6 weeks ago. He was unable to walk these past weeks, since the accident and the surgery. Noooo load-bearing on that foot, the doc said. And believe me: we were NOT happy about it. It's amazing what you can't do when yo

posted 5:50:32pm Oct. 21, 2014 | read full post »

the healing comfort of quiet
When it's noisy, I can't think. My mother used to say -- I can't hear myself think!! Now, these many years later, I get it. When the dogs are barking (frequent!), and the phone is ringing, and someone (or 2 someones

posted 5:11:19pm Oct. 20, 2014 | read full post »

sitting with suffering
"Instead of asking ourselves, “How can I find security and happiness?” we could ask ourselves, “Can I touch the center of my pain? Can I sit with suffering, both yours and mine, without trying to make it go away

posted 6:27:09pm Oct. 18, 2014 | read full post »

the rock of the multiplication, and feeding the hungry
If I were a Christian, I would be a member of a small church. A very small church indeed, in Tabgha, a small village on the Sea of Galilee. The Church of the Multiplication, where the miracle of the loaves &

posted 3:57:43pm Oct. 17, 2014 | read full post »

ch-ch-changes
Ben Franklin is on record as having said, "When you are finished changing, you're finished." I LOVE that. And I heartily agree, although I confess: there are all kinds of change I resist fiercely. I don't like ANY  kind of changes to my schedule -- if it interferes w/'my' time, it's a pain. I'm

posted 9:21:07pm Oct. 15, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.