At the Intersection of Faith and Culture

At the Intersection of Faith and Culture


The Pope and the Injustice of Social Justice

posted by Jack Kerwick

Cardinal Jorge Mario Bergoglio is now Pope Francis. 

This son of Italians who emigrated to Argentine became all of the rage on Wednesday when he was elected Pope.  To be sure, for as ardently as its enemies wish its demise, the eagerness with which the world greeted Pope Francis proves that the Church, with its 1.2 billion members, shows zero signs of going anywhere anytime soon.    

The Pope’s namesake is the thirteenth century Italian saint, Francis of Assisi.  The latter was a wealthy young man who turned his back on worldly success and made a vow of poverty. He founded his own religious order and demanded of his sizable (and ever growing) following that they too do the same.  For the remainder of his natural existence, the Saint, wearing no more than rags, lived among the most impoverished of the impoverished, ministering to their material and—more importantly—spiritual needs.  St. Francis didn’t lament his poverty: he revered it.  In so doing, he inspired hope and faith in the poor. 

The Saint has been widely heralded as “the Second Christ,” such was his humility, compassion, and love for all of God’s creation.  The world, it was Francis’ conviction, has a sacramental character, for it reflects the glory, the beauty, and the goodness of the God Who created it.  It should be revered, yes, but because divine activity everywhere pervades its parts, each provides cause for delight as well.

St.Francis referred to animals as well as the sun and the moon as his siblings.  When he became sick near the end of his life, he even referred to his illnesses as his “sisters.”

For sure, he was a great and devout man.  Equally certain, the Catholic world’s new Pope took the name of the Saint precisely in order to signify that he shares his namesake’s vision.

This sounds all fine and good.  However, while it may very well be too soon to say much in the way of criticism of Pope Francis, some initial reports of his views on “social justice” most definitely do not sound fine and good.  Compounding my concern is the optimism on the part of many in the media as well as many Catholics that his “Latin American” background makes him just the man to “reform” the Church.

Whether used by so-called secular “progressives” or Catholic clerics, the call for social justice is the call for a larger, more powerful, more intrusive government.  That is, it is the demand for a government that is capable of and willing to confiscate the legally owned resources of some citizens so as to “redistribute” them to others.  When social justice is the order of the day, anything other than a robust, activist government is not an option.

It is crucial for everyone, Catholic and non-Catholic alike, to grasp this: social justice and liberty are mutually antithetical.  Liberty, at least the liberty that those of us in the Anglo-sphere have traditionally prized, consists in a decentralization of power of a kind that the American Constitution guarantees.  Liberty presupposes a resolutely non-activist, even anti-activist government, a government that is like an umpire or a referee, one made “of laws, not men,” as we say.  A government fitted for social justice, on the other hand, is of a fundamentally different breed.

Yet it isn’t just that the call for social justice is a call to undermine liberty.  Social justice is actually a great injustice to the poor and the non-poor.

Charity is a Christian excellence that consists in human beings voluntarily expending their time, energies, and treasure on helping those of their fellows in need.  Social justice, in stark contrast, coerces the better off to relinquish their resources to an omnipresent, alien, impersonal bureaucracy.  Worse, it makes this demand upon them for the ostensible purpose of benefitting others—“the poor”—who claim to have a “right” to their goods.

By leading them to believe that their misfortunes are attributable solely to others who must now give them their just desserts, the concept of social justice engenders resentment in the poor while discouraging them from working to improve their plight.  At the same time, social justice provokes the same bitterness in the non-poor who are compelled to work longer and harder for a bunch of ingratiates who claim to be entitled to it.  As a consequence, real charity diminishes.

Social justice destroys the only thing that enriches lives both spiritually and materially: community.  The omnipotent government that it requires and the adversarial attitudes that this government in turn generates make sure of this.    

To be fair to Pope Francis, he is not at all atypical of the Church in promoting social justice.  A lifelong Catholic like me can only hope, and pray, that among the ways in which he will “reform” the Church will be to recognize the error of his—and its—ways and call out social justice for the injustice that it is.          

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



Previous Posts

Leading Atheist Philosopher Concludes: There IS A God
The Christian world just celebrated the Easter holiday, the Resurrection of Jesus, the God-Man, from the dead. Yet there are many people who either don’t believe in God or, if they do, certainly don’t believe that the Supreme Being assumed flesh in the person of Jesus of Nazareth. At the same

posted 9:47:19am Apr. 21, 2014 | read full post »

If I Am a Moral Relativist, So is God
Evidently, I am a moral relativist. In a recent article, I applauded a colleague for adapting to our school stage a play—Songs for a New World.  This play, I contended, marked a quite radical departure from the standard Politically Correct line insofar as it resoundingly affirmed “the morali

posted 9:23:32pm Apr. 17, 2014 | read full post »

Affirming Individuality: Reflections on "Songs for a New World"
Legions of Americans have, rightly, written off the entertainment and academic industries (yes, the latter is a colossal industry) as the culture’s two largest bastions of leftist ideology. Sometimes, however, and when we least expect it, the prevailing “Politically Correct” (PC) orthodoxy

posted 5:59:05pm Apr. 15, 2014 | read full post »

Pope Francis: A Socialist By Any Other Name
Pope Francis is once again insisting that he is not a communist, that his abiding concern for “the poor” is grounded in the Gospel of Christ, not the ideology of Marx, Engels, or any other communist. Back in 2010, while still a Cardinal, he felt the need to do the same. Why? It may very

posted 8:48:27pm Apr. 08, 2014 | read full post »

Pope Francis: As Clever a Politician as They Come
Much to the disappointment of this Catholic, Pope Francis balked on a golden opportunity to convey to the world just how fundamentally, how vehemently, the vision of the Church differs from that of President Obama when the two met a couple of weeks back. Why?  Can it be that Francis is the fello

posted 9:30:34pm Apr. 04, 2014 | read full post »




Report as Inappropriate

You are reporting this content because it violates the Terms of Service.

All reported content is logged for investigation.