Harriet Miers' Christian Roots

Reprinted with permission from New Donkey.

Inevitably, Harriet Miers' religious views are going to get some scrutiny in the very near future, particularly since the initial reaction to her nomination from Christian Right leaders was significantly warmer than that of other conservatives. So far, all the press seems to have figured out is that she spent many years as a devoted member of a "conservative evangelical church" in suburban Dallas, and that she was raised as a (apparently nonobservant) Catholic.

I did a little quick research on Valley View Christian Church, and also happen to know a bit about the tradition it comes from, so I thought I'd share this analysis for future reference. Keep in mind that I am at best an amateur Church historian, so this account may well include errors, though I profoundly hope it gets the big issues right.

VVCC is an independent "Christian" church aligned with the conservative wing of the Campbell-Stone "Restorationist" tradition. It's closely related to the conservative quasi-denomination, the Churches of Christ, and more distantly related to the mainline protestant Disciples of Christ.

[The term "Restorationist" is occasionally applied to "Reconstructionism" or "Dominion Theology," a scary theocratic movement of recent vintage. It has no connection whatsoever with historic "Restorationists," or with Harriet Miers. And no one should confuse the conservative "Churches of Christ" with the "United Church of Christ," a very liberal denomination created by the merger of the Congregationalists with German Reformed Churches in the 1940s].

"Restorationism" is a distinctly American religious tradition, a product of the Second Great Awakening on the midwestern and southern frontier, largely under the leadership of Thomas Campbell and Barton Stone, both former Presbyterians who were troubled by denominational and intradenominational rivalries. The basic idea of "restorationism" was a systematic effort to return to what its adherents understood as the practices of the Primitive Church, rejecting "human" creeds, theological traditions (Protestant and well as Catholic), and sectarian denominations, with Scripture, and especially the New Testament, serving as the only source of authority in all matters.

Ironically, under the leadership of Thomas Campbell's son Alexander, the restorationists created their own denomination (albeit a loosely organized, congregationally-based denomination with a strong commitment to ecumenism), the Disciples of Christ, which grew most rapidly in the Midwest and Southwest. Their most distinctive feature was an insistence on weekly communion (most evangelical denominations, following the Calvinist practice, had long detached communion from regular Sunday worship and observed it irregularly) along with a continuing hostility to theological speculation or creeds.

Eventually, and roughly at the same time that the Fundamentalist Controversy broke out in the larger Protestant denominations, a significant minority of conservative Disciples, especially in the South and Southwest, drifted out of the Disciples, most affiliating with the new Churches of Christ but others simply becoming "independent Christian" congregations like VVCC.

Continued on page 2: »