Another Look at Cardinal Law

Cardinal Law's resignation might not improve the situation. But it's hard to imagine he'll be part of the solution.

Brought to you by The New Republic Online

In America, somebody has to personalize a story before it becomes alive in the culture. When it comes to the crisis of sexual abuse in the Catholic clergy, that person is Bernard Cardinal Law, the archbishop of Boston. Late last week, Law re-affirmed his decision not to resign his office but to continue "to serve this Archdiocese and the whole Church with every fiber of [his] being." In so doing, he managed not only to duck responsibility for his own actions. He also demonstrated himself not yet capable of recognizing--let alone rectifying--the deep institutional problems within the Church that created this crisis in the first place.

Certainly, no one of us would ever want to be judged by his worst moment or her worst decision. And it is beyond doubt that over the years the Catholic Church, in Boston and indeed throughout the world, has benefited enormously from this churchman's gifts. Law's work on behalf of the Church in Latin America, his pro-life initiatives, his concern for racial and ethnic justice in U.S. society, none of these should be forgotten by those who cast aspersions at him. If the only thing Law had done was champion the career of Francis Cardinal George, the Archbishop of Chicago and the most intelligent member of the U.S. hierarchy in decades, this alone would earn him high marks in my book. (A disclaimer: Anytime friends were going to Rome and wanted tickets to a Papal event, Cardinal Law's office would help me out. I have always found him a charming man personally, and he has been very good to friends of mine.)


But the question facing the Cardinal is this: Does his egregious behavior in covering up for, and reassigning, clergy who sexually abused minors rise to that level of offense for which resignation is the only recourse? To analogize from politics, Nixon's cover-up of Watergate did rise to that level, Clinton's cover-up of Monica did not. Of course, in politics, the president is ultimately accountable to the Constitution and the other branches of government. In the Church, there is no such accountability. The people of Boston have no say in the matter and the Pope is very ill.

leave comments
Did you like this? Share with your family and friends.
comments powered by Disqus